“Mr. Speaker, the government House leader keeps saying things that are just not true. He says it does not happen often that the status of a government changes from a minority to a majority. It has never happened at the federal level. That is something that has just never happened. He says that there are not two tiers of committees. There literally are two tiers of committees. There is a tier that handles legislation and is chaired by government MPs, and then there is a tier that is chaired by opposition MPs, which generally does not deal with legislation at all but provides oversight. Those two different tiers are literally spelled out in the Standing Orders. He says that these committees would still have the power to produce documents, compel testimony and order information from departments. What he fails to mention is that this would happen only if motions pass at committee, and he is now stacking the deck with two extra Liberals. Would Liberal MPs on these committees keep the government House leader’s word and commit to voting in favour of motions to investigate Liberal corruption, motions to compel testimony and motions to demand information from the government, yes or no?”
Statement grade
B+
The average of Signal, Relevance and Clarity.
Average 80 / 100
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Procedure 11%Claims 89%
This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.
Mr. Speaker, Procedure · 13 wordsit may be a semantic debate, and it may be a pointless one, ProcedureClaims · 104 wordsbut there are no two tiers of committees.There may be committees with different job descriptions, as there should be when there are some 30 total committees of the House of Commons and joint committees with the Senate.1Of course, committees are masters of their own agenda and their own destiny.They decide what to take up and they decide what to debate, and I am sure members on those committees would individually examine the merits of all proposals that come forward, whatever the source of those proposals, opposition or government, and make their own decisions on the merits of what is being proposed.Off point