“Madam Speaker, one of the aspects I want to highlight with regard to the legislation is the impact it would have on the industry as a whole after we see the legislation pass, go to committee and increase the amount of dialogue. There are industries, such as our aerospace industry. Quebec has a very healthy, growing and vibrant aerospace industry, and so does the province of Manitoba. I made reference to Magellan and the fine work it does. We are talking about good, quality jobs. By having legislation of this nature, we would be establishing a framework. My question for the member is, would he not agree that establishing a framework, so that we can do what we are doing with the legislation, will be good for our aerospace industry in particular?”
Statement grade
A
The average of Signal, Relevance, Respect and Clarity.
Average 90 / 100
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Claims 53%Reasoning 47%
This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.
Madam Speaker, Claims · 65 wordsto answer my colleague’s question, yes, as we said, we welcome Bill C‑28.In Quebec, the aerospace industry accounts for more than 40,000 jobs—nearly 42,000 according to 2023 data.1A lot of people work in this sector.I do not think Manitoba has 42,000 jobs in this sector.2I am not saying there are no skilled people or people working on interesting things in Manitoba, Off pointReasoning · 58 wordsbut I do think Quebec has significant expertise that we have to retain.We have to leverage that, not spread our efforts thin.Partly on pointThat is why I am concerned about putting so much discretionary power in the minister’s hands.I want to make sure we have a fair system that rewards excellence, not whoever Ottawa chooses to reward.
