“Mr. Speaker, the Liberal Prime Minister touts himself as the master negotiator, yet he flip-flops on his position on U.S. trade like a magician distracting with illusions while nothing actually happens. Last year, the Prime Minister said “elbows up” to Washington. Months later, he put his elbows down and said, “Who cares?” about the talks. Fast-forward to this year, and the Liberal Prime Minister said that U.S. integration is subordination. A quick few months later he changed course and said that we are stronger together with the U.S. Here is the reality: Steel tariffs have doubled, lumber tariffs have tripled and manufacturing tariffs are hitting our workers here at home, yet after all the Liberal rhetoric and illusions, there is still no trade deal after more than a year. There is still no timeline and no plan. At what point will the Liberals stop blaming tariffs for Canada’s economic decline and start admitting that it is their failure to get a deal done and to reduce even a single tariff that is sending Canadians to food banks by the millions?”
Statement grade
A
The average of Signal, Relevance, Respect and Clarity.
Average 92 / 100
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Claims 49%The ask 13%Reasoning 39%
This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.
Mr. Speaker, Claims · 58 wordsthat is exactly why we moved today’s motion.We all know the government promised to end the tariff war and reach an agreement with the United States quickly.1Unearned certaintyThat was a year ago.2Unfortunately, it is not happening, and we cannot pretend that it will happen anytime soon.That is exactly why we put this proposal forward today.The ask · 15 wordsWe hope all members of the House will agree with the wording of the motion.Reasoning · 46 wordsI cannot imagine anyone—Conservative, Liberal or independent—voting against this motion.It is reasonable, it is based on stakeholder proposals and it will have an immediate and direct impact on the current crisis.It will save jobs, save businesses large and small, Unearned certaintyand keep Quebec’s regions alive.