Buckley Belanger

Mr. Speaker, Claims · 14 wordsI have the incredible pleasure of serving as MP for a northern Saskatchewan seat. Positioning · 28 wordsAs an indigenous person within the House of Commons, I feel compelled to make sure we correct the record, in terms of what the opposition motion is suggesting.Positioning Procedure · 77 wordsI want to point out I will be sharing my time with the member for Winnipeg North. Before I get into my presentation, I want to say that somewhere along the lines of discussion, it is important to call upon all our intentions when we talk about the country of Canada. I want to briefly expand on that notion before I do my critique of the Conservatives’ presentation. First of all, to clarify to all of Canada, ProcedureClaims · 104 wordsand to the folks who might be paying attention to this particular debate, on May 5 the Prime Minister said, “The government will always defend private property rights.¹ We immediately appealed the Cowichan decision.² We have always defended private property rights; we always will, and we will always defend the rights of indigenous peoples to build a Canada that is stronger, fairer and more independent.” That is the Prime Minister of Canada being very clear as to the whole notion around private property rights as the Cowichan decision impacts some of those statements. I listened to the presentation by the Leader of the Opposition, Positioning · 46 wordsand I reject the premise of his presentation because it is not intended to provide solutions to the problems. It is really intended to divide Canadians, in my opinion, for cheap political theatrics, and that is something that should never happen in the House of Commons.Positioning Claims · 61 wordsI want to point out that, from the whole perspective of Canada as a country, those who helped build this nation were the first nations, the Métis people, the Innu and many other indigenous groups throughout the land. We stood side by side through centuries of conflict and through centuries of negotiations but more so through centuries of sharing the land.Off point Positioning · 32 wordsFrom our perspective, I ask, “What is our responsibility to the country as a whole?” as we grapple through some of these issues that impact not only B.C. but Saskatchewan and Alberta.PositioningPartly on point Claims · 48 wordsWe see many good examples of how Canadians, first nations Canadians, non-indigenous Canadians, Innu Canadians, Inuit Canadians, Métis Canadians and non-status Canadians, many from my own communities, are trying to keep this country together. All of the discussions we are having here are about strengthening and uniting Canada, Off pointProcedure · 14 wordsand that is an important point that I want to raise during this discussion.Procedure Claims · 11 wordsI listened to the presentation by the Leader of the Opposition, Positioning · 175 wordsand all I see is division from some of the points he raised. On one hand, he is suggesting that we do not look at any other agreements of this sort. That is what I understood from his presentation. On the other hand, the member for Edmonton Northwest said we need to strengthen the treaties.³ How does that work? They cannot give the same speech with a contrasting view like that, trying to be everything to everybody, because, quite frankly, they will be nothing to nobody if they do not make up their minds on which perspective they want to support. I see a huge divide within the Conservative caucus. They say one thing on one hand, and they say something extremely different on the other hand. Sooner or later, Canadians are going to catch on to that. As I stand here today, I ask Canadians, who is looking after Canada’s interests, and why is it important to me as an indigenous person and to indigenous folks, whether we are from B.C., Saskatchewan or Alberta?PositioningPartly on point Procedure · 4 wordsIt is very clear, ProcedureClaims · 19 wordsas the member from B.C. mentioned earlier, that there is no threat to private property ownership in this bill. Positioning · 24 wordsWhy do the Conservatives want to make it out to be a threat to Canadians? It is because it is in their political interests.Positioning Procedure · 11 wordsWe can look at the Canadian perspective, as I mentioned before.Procedure Anecdote · 64 wordsI was raised in a household with a father who was a World War II veteran.⁴ He was Métis, and his mom was an indigenous woman. Every day when my dad came home from his service to Canada during the Second World War, he spoke about the value of Canada as a whole. As an indigenous person, he was proud to serve his country.AnecdoteOff point Reasoning · 27 wordsSomewhere along the line, Canada’s interests need to be maintained in all of these discussions, through respectful dialogue and discussions among the many provinces that are impacted.Partly on point Procedure · 11 wordsI look at modern examples today of who is strengthening Canada.Procedure Positioning · 17 wordsI reject the member for Edmonton Northwest’s notion that we are creating division. We absolutely are not.Positioning Claims · 20 wordsThis government is working very hard to deal with economic reconciliation and to engage the indigenous community on many fronts. Positioning · 42 wordsI dare say that I would compare our record on any day of the week to the Conservative record when it comes to indigenous rights, indigenous opportunities and the indigenous right to sit with us as partners in developing this great country.Positioning Claims · 45 wordsAt the end of the day, there are many indigenous people across this country who are trying to strengthen our country in all kinds of ways. Many times I talk to the people in my riding about social and economic justice for the indigenous people, Promise · 16 wordsand we will achieve that as long as we have respectful dialogue between all parties engaged.Off pointVague promise Procedure · 4 wordsIn the Cowichan decision, ProcedurePromise · 9 wordsas I mentioned, we will respect private property ownership.Vague promise Anecdote · 175 wordsNow, I will go back to my father’s service to this country. It is a beautiful country. We had a number of family members serve in the military. They include my older brother who served as a warrant officer in the air force and my younger brother who served as a warrant officer in the army.⁵ I had a sister who also served in the air force, ⁶and my daughter almost joined the navy until her mother talked her out of it. The fact of the matter is that we come from a proud military history within my family. How did we get that service-to-Canada perspective? It came from our father, who was a World War II veteran who spoke about the value of keeping Canada together. He was one solid, strong patriot, and yet he was indigenous. If he saw the discussion here today, Off pointand the talk about dividing the country over indigenous rights versus private property rights, he would say to us that it is important to keep our country strong and together.Anecdote Procedure · 21 wordsAgain, our Prime Minister has been very clear. For the record, I am going to read to the opposition his quote: ProcedureClaims · 45 words“The government will always defend private property rights. We immediately appealed the Cowichan decision. We have always defended private property rights; we always will, and we will always defend the rights of indigenous peoples to build a Canada that is stronger, fairer and more independent.” Anecdote · 16 wordsThose are the exact same words that I think my father would say to us all.Anecdote Positioning · 17 wordsLet us make Canada stronger, let us make Canada fairer, and let us make Canada more independent.PositioningOff point