Alana Hirtle

Madam Speaker, Thanks · 26 wordsI would first like to thank the member of Parliament for Edmonton Strathcona for bringing Bill C-259 forward and for her advocacy on behalf of workers.¹Thanks Claims · 12 wordsThe Government of Canada recognizes the spirit and intent of Bill C-259, Positioning · 10 wordsbecause fairness for all Canadian workers is our top priority.Positioning Claims · 72 wordsGiven the economic headwinds we are facing, worker fairness is needed now more than ever. Canada’s economy is at a turning point.Partly on point The global labour landscape has shifted dramatically, causing economic shockwaves felt at home and abroad. Tariffs have dealt a significant blow to workers and employers. This has caused real stress for families and communities across Canada.Off point During uncertain economic times like these, Canadians expect the government to have their backs, Positioning · 3 wordsand we do.Positioning Claims · 20 wordsWe are working closely with employers and unions to shore up Canada’s workplaces and ensure they remain fair and productive.Partly on pointVague promise Procedure · 5 wordsOur marching orders are clear.Procedure Reasoning · 27 wordsWe must protect Canadian workers while strengthening our country’s economic resilience. We cannot build a strong economy without respecting the workers who keep it running every day. Promise · 25 wordsThat is why we are fully committed to ensuring that workers and their employers have the tools they need to weather this current labour storm.Partly on pointVague promise Claims · 43 wordsAt the heart of Canada’s labour framework is the Canada Labour Code. It is more than a law that governs federally regulated workplaces in Canada. It is a promise to protect and support more than one million workers in 22,000 federally regulated industries.² Promise · 9 wordsIt is a promise we will continue to keep, Vague promiseReasoning · 11 wordsbecause fair workplaces and a strong economy go hand in hand. Claims · 7 wordsOur federal labour framework already works well, Promise · 26 wordsbut we are always on the lookout for ways to build greater trust, strengthen our labour relations approach and make our policies more flexible and proactive.Vague promise Procedure · 24 wordsToday, I would like to highlight our ongoing approach to supporting federally regulated workplaces and the collective bargaining process that is protected by law.Procedure Claims · 15 wordsThe structural integrity of the collective bargaining process is held together by trust and independence. Reasoning · 24 wordsWithout those two key ingredients, the process would fail. For agreements to work, workers must trust their union, and employers must trust the system. Claims · 8 wordsAny perception of outside influence weakens the system. Reasoning · 33 wordsWorkers should also be able to choose their representatives freely and trust that those representatives act in their best interest. They deserve unions that answer to them without being influenced by external pressures. Claims · 235 wordsThat is why Canada’s labour relations system is built on a structured process that balances workers’ rights and employers’ responsibilities. I can assure members that the Government of Canada firmly believes in the right to strike. It is protected under the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, ³and it is a key element of free, balanced and respectful labour relations. We believe in open and unfettered dialogue between the parties and that workers must have real bargaining power to reach those agreements. We know that the best agreements are those negotiated at the bargaining table. We also know that collective bargaining is not easy, but it produces the strongest deals that represent the needs of the parties involved and that help stabilize the economy. That is why we have taken concrete measures to strengthen that right while maintaining balance across the system. I am referring to Bill C-58, a historic act to ban replacement workers in federally regulated workplaces during strikes or lockouts.⁴ It also improved the maintenance of activities process so that parties determine early in the process what work needs to continue to ensure public safety during a work stoppage.⁷ It received unanimous support in Parliament and was written into law one year ago this month, on June 20, 2025.⁵⁶ Banning the use of replacement workers protects workers’ right to strike, removes distractions from collective bargaining and brings greater stability to our economy. Reasoning · 10 wordsWe cannot have a strong economy without stable labour relations. Claims · 143 wordsReforms like Bill C-58 help establish a better balance in negotiations and protect the integrity of the collective bargaining process. Collective bargaining can lead to tension at the table, but it remains the ideal mechanism for finding lasting, balanced solutions. That is why the federal labour regime relies on established rules and fair, transparent, independent decision-makers to help parties come to solid agreements. I am referring to the Canada Industrial Relations Board and the federal mediation and conciliation service. They both play an invaluable role in Canada’s labour relations system. While news headlines may paint a different picture, the truth is most labour disputes are resolved without a work stoppage.Unearned certainty In fact, in the last fiscal year, the vast majority of disputes in federally regulated workplaces were resolved without a work stoppage when the parties worked with the federal mediation and conciliation service.⁸ Reasoning · 22 wordsThis tells us the system works well, when parties bargain in good faith and when they have access to the right support. Claims · 65 wordsLabour relations affect wages, productivity and economic stability. Success at the bargaining table contributes to a stronger economy, but we also know the opposite is true. When labour disputes collapse, this can have rapid and significant repercussions for millions of Canadians, businesses, exporters and the economy writ large. When an economy slows down significantly, it is often workers who bear the brunt of the impact. Reasoning · 23 wordsThe collective bargaining space must remain uncluttered by external distractions, so parties can focus on solutions that can stand the test of time. Procedure · 20 wordsIt is here that I would like to turn back to the task at hand and talk about Bill C-259.Procedure Claims · 108 wordsBill C-259 proposes a handful of specific amendments. It proposes to further define and codify employer influence and to bar certification of employer-dominated unions.⁹ It also adds procedural and governance requirements for certification and creates new penalties, such as summary conviction, up to $100,000.¹⁰ These preventative and clarifying measures are consistent with the code’s foundational values. In fact, part I of the code already prohibits employer interference, ¹¹and CIRB has previously applied these rules broadly through past decisions.¹² We have also found limited evidence of widespread employer-dominated unions in federally regulated sectors. We are aware that the absence of widespread problems is not an argument against clear rules. Reasoning · 14 wordsWe know that clear rules set clear expectations, often preventing problems before they arise. Procedure · 23 wordsI am sure we can all agree that a proactive approach is always the best approach, especially when it comes to labour relations.Procedure Promise · 36 wordsThe Government of Canada will always protect the rights of Canadian workers, including the right to strike.Vague promise We are always looking for ways to help strengthen labour stability and bolster Canada’s competitiveness while supporting workers’ rights.Vague promise Claims · 74 wordsOne way to ensure workers are supported and policies reflect the distinct challenges of today’s workplaces is through consultations. That is why this government held consultations in the spring with unions, employers and indigenous partners to discuss potential ways to improve worker support and the federal labour relations framework.¹³ These talks provided invaluable perspectives on the collective bargaining process in federally regulated industries, for example. We have explored various important topics in these consultations, Promise · 10 wordsand we are all ears for new and innovative improvements. Reasoning · 30 wordsDiscussions like these are essential to help inform practical and long-lasting ways to support workers and workplaces, and ensure they have the tools they trust and that help them succeed. Thanks · 27 wordsI would like to close by once again thanking the member for Edmonton Strathcona for bringing this bill forward and for her advocacy on behalf of workers.Thanks Promise · 49 wordsI would like to reaffirm the Government of Canada’s unwavering commitment to the integrity of collective bargaining and fair worker representation. We will continue working closely with all stakeholders to ensure that our federally regulated institutions can rely on fairness at the bargaining table, now and in the future.Vague promise