Tamara Kronis

Madam Speaker, Positioning · 92 wordswhen it comes to housing, bureaucrats count starts. They count units. They count dollars. They count funds, programs, agencies and promises, but in Nanaimo—Ladysmith, we count something different. We count the months our adult children have been living in the spare room because rent has eaten the down payment they were trying to save for. We count the number of graduates who cannot find a job that pays enough to cover rent. We count the number of people with no home at all as we pass them on the way to work.Positioning Procedure · 9 wordsBefore I forget, I will be splitting my time.Procedure Positioning · 138 wordsOn a more serious note, we count the graves of friends lost to addiction, the treatment beds that are not there, and the people who make it through detox only to be sent back to the same chaos they were trying to escape. We continue to measure the distance between the government’s language and our reality. That distance is the distance between a young person with a diploma and a job and having no real path to owning a home in the community they grew up in. It is the distance between a person who is coming out of detox trying to stay clean and housing where drug use is not happening down the hall. Those are not separate crises. They are part of the same failure of government. We have lost the link between housing and hope.Positioning Claims · 90 wordsCanada does not lack for housing announcements. In the last decade, we have had strategies, accelerators, funds, agencies, accords and photo ops, including some that have their own complete purpose-built backdrop. What we do not have is enough homes that people can afford. In Nanaimo—Ladysmith, we do not have enough of the right homes for people who are trying to rebuild their lives. Now we have Bill C-20, which would create Build Canada Homes to promote, support and develop the supply of affordable housing.¹ From the speeches, it sounds ambitious. Positioning · 23 wordsThe question is whether it will be useful once the media has packed up and gone home and the sets have been dismantled.Positioning Claims · 207 wordsAll this bill does is create the skeleton. It creates the framework and the corporation itself. The government is presenting Build Canada Homes as a generational housing investment, but the Parliamentary Budget Officer says it will only have a modest impact.² The headline number is $13 billion, ³but the Parliamentary Budget Officer says the actual planned spend is $7.3 billion over five years on an accrual basis.⁴ The projected result is about 26,000 homes over five years, ⁵or roughly 5,200 homes a year across the entire country.⁶ This would increase housing completions by only 2.1% above the baseline and address just 3.7% of the estimated housing gap.⁷ Even with Build Canada Homes included, planned federal housing spending is set to fall by 56%, from $9.8 billion in 2025-26 to $4.3 billion in 2028-29.⁸ The Parliamentary Budget Officer has put the scale of the new housing gap plainly: Canada needs 3.2 million net new housing units by 2035, ⁹which means an average of 290,000 units a year for a decade.¹⁰ The PBO also warned that this would still not fully solve affordability in every region, because income, interest rates, regional gaps and the kind of housing built all matter, as my colleagues have pointed out in their speeches. Reasoning · 34 wordsThat last point matters the most to growing communities like mine, because we do not just need more housing; we need the right housing in the right places for the people who need it. Claims · 27 wordsHousing experts have made this same point over and over again. Mike Moffatt’s report says, “Canada needs to build millions more homes, ¹¹but not just any homes.” Reasoning · 30 wordsThey have to be homes built for today’s needs, and getting there is going to require bolder reforms, in our opinion, than those that have been put forward so far. Claims · 146 wordsBill C-20 would not speed up local approvals. It would not give our provinces and municipalities the infrastructure they need. It would not service land, and it would not set binding targets for how many homes will be completed by when, for whom, at what price. What Bill C-20 would do is create another federal bureaucracy on top of at least four others in this space.¹² There is CMHC, which already has the power to finance housing, lend, guarantee loans, invest and run federal housing programs.¹³ The Canada Lands Company already has the power to develop federal land.¹⁴ Housing, Infrastructure and Communities Canada already manages federal housing funding and agreements.¹⁵ The Canada Infrastructure Bank already has the power to finance infrastructure that unlocks housing.¹⁶ In other words, the functions are already there, and Ottawa does not lack agencies with housing powers. What it lacks is results. Reasoning · 42 wordsBuilding another bureaucracy means time spent setting it up. Offices need to be set up, executives hired, mandates written, files moved around and programs reorganized, and that is time and money that could be spent getting homes built. That is the problem. Positioning · 26 wordsThe government is using language that Canadians want to hear, but the structure does not match the urgency of the moment. Young Canadians understand this instinctively.Positioning Claims · 26 wordsWe tell them to study, work, save and be patient. Then they graduate into a labour market where entry-level jobs are harder and harder to find, Positioning · 23 wordswhere rent consumes too much of their income and where ownership feels less like a goal than a memory from someone else’s Canada.Positioning Claims · 51 wordsThis week, a recent software engineering graduate came to a committee of the House to say that he could still not find entry-level work in his field.¹⁷ When asked whether he was working, he said yes, but not as a software engineer. The Liberal MP’s reply was, “At least you’re employed.”¹⁸ Positioning · 17 wordsThat answer reveals something deeper than one exchange. It shows a government that has lowered the bar.PositioningOff point Procedure · 11 wordsI will continue my speech when the House resumes next week.Procedure