Analysis · Debate reply · beta

Wayne Long

64 words · 8 sentences · 8 clauses

Replying to Jean-Denis Garon (Bloc Québécois)
“Madam Speaker, I am not sure there is any point in asking my colleague a question. He is just going to stand like he did before and say that the government has a job to do for Canadians and that it is going to do that job, whether it was elected to do it or not. I would like to remind him that we debated another time allocation motion not so long ago. At the time, I was asking questions of the minister responsible for Canadian heritage, who was defending that time allocation motion. I explained to him that, ever since the Liberals got a majority, they have been using it to hold in camera meetings at the expense of Driver Inc. victims and to quash investigations into the conflicts of interest of the Minister of Finance and his wife. Do members know what the Minister of Canadian Heritage said to me at the time? He asked me whether I thought he wanted to be here, because he had been forced to come and defend something that is indefensible. I will conclude my comments by saying that I serve on the Standing Committee on Finance and that I participated in the study of Bill C-30. As soon as the Conservative Party presented its first amendment, the Liberals clearly indicated that they were going to oppose any and all amendments because they have a majority. They did not even wait an hour to make that clear. They said it in the very first minute of the meeting. The Liberals were asking for a special report on specific changes to the Canada pension plan. I tried to negotiate a solution myself. Officials told us it was doable, but the Liberals refused. The reality is that the government is trying to curtail debate, whether it is a minority or a majority. Circumstances do not matter, and this government has decided that it will make all the decisions. According to the government, in a democracy, the opposition serves no function. I will say it again: I think Parliament is better than what the Liberals are doing with it.”
Statement grade
C
61 / 100, held down by Signal
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Claims 33%Positioning 67%

This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.

Madam Speaker, Claims · 21 wordsI come from the private sector.1Off point This type of filibuster, 30 hours of basically producing nothing for Canadians, is not acceptable.2 Positioning · 43 wordsCanadians see it.Unearned certainty Canadians know it.Unearned certainty I know that here in the Ottawa bubble, people think that it is okay and that Canadians accept it. They do not accept it.Unearned certainty They want us to move forward. They want us to build Canada strong.Positioning

Analysed on