Analysis · Floor speech · beta

Gord Johns

545 words · 24 sentences · 29 clauses

Statement grade
A–
Average 88 / 100
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Claims 60%Procedure 6%Positioning 23%The question 11%

This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.

Madam Speaker, Claims · 13 wordshere we are just three days into the fall sitting of the House, Procedure · 26 wordsand I am once again having to drag the government back into the House for an adjournment debate to protect our universal public health care system.Procedure Claims · 52 wordsBack in April, I asked a question during question period referencing the fact that the Minister of Health stood here and called herself “the guardian of the Canada Health Act”.1 After months of delay, she has failed to act while Alberta Premier Danielle Smith expands American-style pay-for-access diagnostics and two-tiered health care. Positioning · 14 wordsCanadians cannot afford more stalling while our universal health care system is being undermined.Positioning Claims · 109 wordsSince that time, on September 1, Alberta’s Bill 11 has landed on our doorstep.2 The Canadian Health Coalition, which I want to thank for its tremendous work advocating for our public health care system, commissioned a legal opinion stating that Bill 11 is the most serious threat against public universal health care we have seen since the Canada Health Act was passed in 1984.34 The first parts of Premier Smith’s draconian Bill 11 in Alberta just recently came into force at the beginning of this month, with the rest being enacted in the coming months.5 Bill 11 opens the door to the privatization of public health care in Canada. Positioning · 13 wordsAs Friends of Medicare has so succinctly said, we must slam it shut.Positioning Claims · 83 wordsShockingly, despite my repeated attempts at ringing the alarm bells around Alberta’s Bill 11 here in the House, through the media and in many meetings with the Minister of Health asking that she enforce the Canada Health Act to protect our public health care system from a threat that no one voted for, it was not until the eve of the recent coming into force of the bill that the minister finally said that she would be considering the ramifications of the bill.6 The question · 27 wordsIf the minister is truly the guardian, why is she taking so long to enforce the law and stop the erosion of our public health care system? Claims · 7 wordsThis is an issue of national unity. Positioning · 11 wordsWhat can happen in Alberta does not necessarily stay in Alberta.Positioning Claims · 33 wordsCanadians are united in their opposition to the insults and damage flowing from the American President towards Canada. The Prime Minister has been travelling abroad and hosting summits with billionaires here at home, Positioning · 20 wordsso what happened to “elbows up” and “Canada strong”? Protecting our health care is Canada strong. That is nation building, PositioningClaims · 21 wordsbut eroding our public health care system through inaction and failure to enforce the Canada Health Act is not Canada strong. Positioning · 43 wordsIt weakens Canada. It is not Canadian. It erodes the security of the very thing Canadians most closely identify with as part of being Canadian. Canadians do not want American-style health care, the queue-jumping for people with money or the so-called dual practice, PositioningClaims · 7 wordswhich is now under way in Alberta. Procedure · 7 wordsI will ask the government this again.Procedure The question · 34 wordsWhy has it not enforced the Canada Health Act to prevent the erosion of our public health care system, something that Canadians identify with in our shared values as a healthy and inclusive society? Positioning · 25 wordsPeople should use their health care card, not their credit card, to get the help and services they need when it comes to their health.Positioning

Analysed on