Analysis · Debate question · beta

Gord Johns

175 words · 15 sentences · 17 clauses

Following a speech by Ryan Turnbull (Liberal)
“Madam Speaker, I want to thank the member for Courtenay—Alberni for the collaborative working relationship that we have had for quite a number of years. He is a great guy and a great representative for his community. I understand his question, and just for the record, I was not dragged here. I volunteered to stay to answer his question this evening. Our public health care system is a point of pride, that is for sure, for all Canadians, including all Albertans. Our government will always work to defend our health care system because we understand that access to care should be based on someone’s need, not someone’s ability to pay. Furthermore, we recognize that our universal health care system underpins our economic strength. To build Canada strong, we need healthy Canadians. However, at the same time, all of us can see that our health care system is under strain. While provinces and territories are responsible for delivering health care, we all know that the federal government plays a key role in supporting the provinces. All of us need to work together to make sure that Canadians have the strong health care system they need and deserve. We have seen how provinces and territories are responding to these challenges with new ideas and determination. They are finding new ways to bring care closer to Canadians, by expanding the roles of nurse practitioners, pharmacists and midwives; embracing virtual care; and even training the health care professionals we will need for the future. There is no doubt that this is important work, which is why we have taken a collaborative approach with all provinces and territories, including Alberta, that respects their jurisdiction to explore innovative ways to improve access and care while strengthening the public universal health care system that we all take pride in. That does not mean that provinces and territories have free reign to ignore the principles of the Canada Health Act. As the Minister of Health has said repeatedly, she has been in close contact with Minister LaGrange, as she has been with all her provincial and territorial counterparts, to talk about how we can best support Alberta in strengthening our health care system and not eroding it. Likewise, as the minister has noted, Health Canada officials are working closely with Government of Alberta officials to ensure that the principles of the Canada Health Act are fully respected. A collaborative approach between our government and the Government of Alberta has always produced stronger results, and we will continue to work in that direction to benefit all Albertans and all Canadians.”
Statement grade
A–
Average 88 / 100
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Thanks 11%The ask 31%Claims 19%Reasoning 15%Positioning 17%Promise 7%

This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.

Madam Speaker, Thanks · 19 wordsI have deep respect for my colleague. I want to thank him for volunteering tonight and for coming in.Thanks The ask · 23 wordsI am going to ask him to volunteer to stand up against a province that is in violation of the Canada Health Act.1 Claims · 16 wordsThey are moving toward a private model. That is clear. This undermines the Canada Health Act. Reasoning · 10 wordsIt is the responsibility of the government to enforce it. The ask · 22 wordsIf the government is truly the guardian of our public health care system, it needs to act. It needs to act now. Reasoning · 16 wordsInnovation is one thing, but breaking the law and the rules of the country is another. Claims · 18 wordsThat is the responsibility of the government. It is the NDP that is showing up here at night. Positioning · 30 wordsI am volunteering to show up, to stand up for Canadians, because no other party is coming in here to stand up against the privatization of our health care system.Positioning Promise · 12 wordsWe will stand strong to protect our public universal health care system.Vague promise The ask · 9 wordsI hope the government will act and act soon.

Analysed on