“Madam Speaker, the government keeps trying to reassure workers, particularly on the issue of labour rights, which, quite frankly, are literally being trampled by Bill C-39. Despite the government’s attempts to sugar-coat it, Bill C-39 actually weakens protections for workers’ rights, which is a real cause for concern for trade unions across Quebec and Canada. They are trying to sugar-coat all this by saying there will be a mediator to advise the minister, but the minister will still have the right, under the bill, to disregard the mediator’s recommendations. The minister will have the right to stop a strike if he believes it is going too far and is in some way detrimental to the project at hand. Workers who hear this feel that they are losing their bargaining power and their dignity, in a sense. Their rights are truly being trampled by this bill. Despite the government’s attempts to sugar-coat things and its claims that it is putting all kinds of protections in place, at the end of the day, the minister is the one who will have the final say on matters affecting workers during bargaining and strikes. I would really like to hear my colleague from Winnipeg North do his level best to reassure me about that, but I am not sure he will be able to. I would also like him to tell the workers, unions and labour representatives watching us that he is truly committed to ensuring that, when the committee studies Bill C‑39, solid protections for workers’ rights will be added. As things stand, the bill offers no reassurance at all.”
Statement grade
A+
The average of Signal, Relevance, Respect and Clarity.
Average 99 / 100
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Procedure 3%Claims 51%Reasoning 36%The ask 10%
This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.
Madam Speaker, Procedure · 5 wordsI think it is important.ProcedureClaims · 13 wordsWhen we think of union workers, they have a constitutional right to strike.1Reasoning · 24 wordsI have always advocated that the best deal is a negotiated deal, and there is no doubt in my mind in regard to that.Claims · 65 wordsI have served in the Manitoba legislature.2I can tell the member opposite that all sorts of political entities, whether New Democrats, Conservatives, Progressive Conservatives or Liberals, in provincial and federal governments have at times had a need to legislate workers back to work.Just recently, in the province of Manitoba, health care workers were told to go back to work by the provincial government.3Reasoning · 31 wordsUnfortunately, in certain situations, the government is put in a very difficult position, but we believe that individuals have a right to strike, and the best agreement is a negotiated agreement.The ask · 16 wordsI hope that members will be open-minded about what is actually being proposed in this legislation.
