This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.
Mr. Speaker, Greeting · 19 wordsit is a pleasure to rise to address the House in regard to the opposition motion before us today.Greeting Claims · 9 wordsIt is a motion that I personally cannot support. Positioning · 33 wordsAt the end of the day, I believe the government’s policy is the right direction we should be following. There are a number of things the Conservative Party does not take into consideration.Positioning Procedure · 16 wordsThe primary one has to be the reality of what is happening around the world today.ProcedureUnearned certainty Claims · 91 wordsWhat is taking place in the Strait of Hormuz and in the Middle East is having a profound impact on prices not only here in Canada, but in fact around the world. I posed a question to the leader of the Conservative Party, and then another question was posed to him, and from my perspective, two things came out of them. The latter question posed to him was about the issue of taxes. He raised the United States and the rest of the world, saying that Canada was above the average.1 Reasoning · 28 wordsIt is important that we get a sense of what is actually taking place in the G7 countries, which are the most industrialized countries in the world today. Claims · 31 wordsOur price on diesel fuel is no higher than it is in many of the other G7 countries, which includes countries such as the United Kingdom, which has England, and others. Positioning · 17 wordsBeing very selective is something the Conservatives are very good at doing when trying to draw comparisons.Positioning Claims · 19 wordsCanada overall is, relatively speaking, in a very okay position compared to G7 countries on the price of diesel. Positioning · 4 wordsCan we do more?Positioning Claims · 60 wordsThat is ultimately one of the reasons we have taken the actions we have since the spring economic update. That was one of the issues coming out of the questions for the leader of the Conservative Party. Another issue, the one I specifically asked the leader about, was in regard to the Conservatives’ position on taxation with respect to fuel. Positioning · 15 wordsI suspect their position is even further to the right than President Trump’s, quite frankly.Positioning Claims · 67 wordsIf we listen to what some of the Conservatives are saying, whether today or in the week prior to the break week, one could easily draw the conclusion that they believe, or at least some believe, or want to imply that we should be getting rid of all forms of gas taxes. Then they go on to give a number of reasons, which ultimately lead to farmers. Procedure · 13 wordsThat is where I would like to begin my comments, although somewhat belated.Procedure Positioning · 96 wordsConservatives like to talk a great deal about farmers, as if the Government of Canada has not been sympathetic to the farmers of our nation. Nothing could be further from the truth. I would challenge members across the way to indicate a prime minister who has been as aggressive, along with cabinet, in trying to pursue additional markets that go beyond the United States. I do not believe they would be able to identify a prime minister, cabinet or government caucus that has been as aggressive in pursuing export markets that ultimately will support our farmers.PositioningPartly on point Procedure · 8 wordsLet me give a good example of that.Procedure Claims · 92 wordsI had the opportunity to get a better understanding of what is taking place in the Philippines, because of the trade discussions happening today with Canada and the Philippines, 2which are led by the Prime Minister and the President of the Philippines. Agriculture is on the agenda, and that is only one of many discussions that have been taking place over the last 18 months. In fact, we have seen well over 20 trade and security agreements signed off on by the Prime Minister and this government since the last federal election.3Partly on point Procedure · 13 wordsI will go to one agreement that I tie myself fairly closely to, ProcedureThanks · 26 wordsbecause the Minister of International Trade has been very accommodating in listening to what I have to say about the potential between Canada and the Philippines.Thanks Positioning · 12 wordsI am encouraged by how agriculture is being brought into the picture.Positioning Anecdote · 100 wordsI am someone who grew up in the Prairies and lived in all three prairie provinces, and I have been talking to farmers. The first farm I visited when I was 13 years old was the Stoynes farm just outside of Moose Jaw, Saskatchewan.4 I rode on the big tractors at 13. I understand the farming community in good part, although maybe not as well as others who are farmers and so forth, but understanding the industries has always been important to me, whether it is the canola or pork industry, which I have provided comments on in the past.Anecdote Positioning · 36 wordsI can say that the government, in particular our Minister of Agriculture, is very much on top of the file in regard to farmers, as is the Prime Minister, who also grew up in the Prairies.5Positioning Reasoning · 36 wordsI suspect that if we were to have discussions with farmers, what we would find at the end of the day is that creating additional markets for their product is something they see great value in. Positioning · 12 wordsTell me another government that has been as aggressive at pursuing that.PositioningPartly on point Procedure · 6 wordsAnother good example would be canola.Procedure Claims · 115 wordsMy home province of Manitoba benefited because the Prime Minister took an interest in trying to take down barriers between China and Canada, which ultimately dealt with some tariffs on canola. We can talk about Farm Credit Canada and how it continues to support our farmers during what can be very challenging times.Partly on point The special levy tax put on by the federal government was actually put into place by the current Prime Minister.6 The Conservatives like to say that it was their idea. Ultimately, the idea might have come from Wab Kinew, the Premier of Manitoba, who years ago gave a gasoline tax break to the people of Manitoba shortly after the last provincial election.7 Reasoning · 33 wordsThe point is that it does not matter where the idea came from. What is important is that we recognize that there is a need today to deal with issues such as affordability. Positioning · 85 wordsThis is something the Prime Minister, this government and every member of the Liberal caucus understand. It is a reflection of what we are seeing and hearing within our ridings. We want to deliver for the constituents we represent, Vague promiseand the affordability issue is an important issue for every one of us. We are a strong, united caucus on the issue of affordability and in supporting the initiative that the Prime Minister has taken in providing direct relief through the levy on taxes on gasoline.Positioning Procedure · 6 wordsThat is not the first time.Procedure Claims · 59 wordsIn fact, the very first action that was taken when he was selected as the leader of the Liberal Party and became the Prime Minister was getting rid of the carbon tax on gasoline.8 Was that 13¢ a litre or 17¢ a litre? I cannot think of the exact number. I think it was close to 17¢ a litre.9 The question · 9 wordsBob Zimmer: Whose idea was it? Hon. Kevin Lamoureux: Claims · 14 wordsMr. Speaker, it was our current Prime Minister who actually got rid of it. Procedure · 18 wordsThe member opposite wants to challenge me and ask whose idea it was. Let me tell him something.Procedure Claims · 106 wordsAt one time, the Conservatives were against it. They then became in favour of it and then they were against it. That is the Conservatives’ track record on it. The current Liberal leader, today’s Prime Minister, who was elected in the last federal election, made a commitment to Canadians on the issue of affordability and he is delivering on the issue of affordability in many different ways.10 He is not just dealing with the tax on gas, whether it is the carbon tax or the levy that has been applied. We constantly hear from members opposite, and even from my colleagues, about the importance of affordability. Procedure · 5 wordsIt has not stopped there.Procedure Claims · 81 wordsWhen we talk about affordability, this is affordability that benefits farmers. The tax break that was given, shifting from 15% to 14%, helped 22 million Canadians.11 To my Conservative friends, many of those people are farmers. Understanding that there are ways in which we can directly help Canadians with the price of food, we not only converted the GST rebate but, significantly, put up front literally hundreds of millions of dollars and converted it into the Canada groceries and essentials benefit.12 Procedure · 9 wordsAgain, we are dealing with the issue of affordability.Procedure Claims · 9 wordsOnce again, our farmers will benefit from that program. Reasoning · 33 wordsI put it in that form because I want members to recognize that one does not have to be in the opposition to value and appreciate what our farmers do for our nation. Claims · 11 wordsThey are the ones who provide the food on our table. Anecdote · 31 wordsI have travelled on the highway in the Prairies, where we see four, five and more combines forming a row and harvesting wheat from the fields. It is an impressive sight.Anecdote Claims · 75 wordsIn the province of Manitoba, when I think of farmers and producers, it goes beyond just the crops. I have talked about how important the pork industry is to my home province of Manitoba, from those who process it to those who have the barns and get the pork ready to be put in places like HyLife, Maple Leaf Foods and Winkler Meats. These are important people who play a critical role in food security. Positioning · 11 wordsFood security is important to every member of the government caucus.Positioning Reasoning · 41 wordsFor this reason, we often talk about why it is so important to support expanding the year-round production of things like vegetables and fruits so that we are less dependent on countries like the United States in dealing with food security. Claims · 21 wordsThese are some of the measures the government has put in place to support our farmers and Canadians as a whole.Partly on point Positioning · 71 wordsToday, we have the Conservatives saying, “Here is our idea”, because they want to one-up, in the best way they can, what the current government is proposing, even though when they had a chance to do things like this when they were in government, they did not. Now they are in opposition and they see a government actually taking some of these initiatives, they want to say they can one-up them.Positioning Claims · 73 wordsNo one can accurately predict what the price of fuel is going to be six months from now. We might like to think we can. This is a measure that was put in place on April 20, I believe, 13as part of the spring budget update. It was meant to provide temporary support, with a suspension until the Labour Day weekend.14 That was in Bill C-30, 15if members want to look it up. Thanks · 12 wordsWe are grateful that the Conservatives supported that legislation.16 That was great.Thanks Claims · 86 wordsOver the summer, going into August, a decision was made that we needed to be able to extend that tax break, Hidden agencywhich is somewhat similar to what the Province of Manitoba did when it brought in its initial price reduction on gasoline. That is exactly what Bill C-38 would do.17 It would allow for that extension, which incorporates diesel and gasoline. I can say it makes a very tangible difference for consumers. I am very much aware of the Bloc’s concern with respect to the issue. Reasoning · 73 wordsHow can we ensure that the tax break, whether it is given by the Province of Manitoba or the federal government, is being passed on to consumers? I believe we have some of the best civil servants and independent officers of Parliament, along with different stakeholders, who can ensure that those oil companies have a sense of accountability so that, in fact, that tax break goes directly into the pockets of the consumer. Procedure · 20 wordsThat is something we take very seriously. It is the reason why we are doing it in the first place.Procedure Positioning · 35 wordsThis is a government that is not only focused on short-term relief. It is trying to resolve the problem and secure our future so that Canada can be more independent in issues of this nature.PositioningVague promise Claims · 44 wordsIt is the reason why we had the Pacific link announcement.18 It is the reason why we had the LNG Canada phase two announcement.19 These are multi-billion-dollar announcements that are going to increase Canada’s capacity.20 The leader of the Green Party talked about refineries. Reasoning · 40 wordsIf we want more refineries in Canada, we have to continue to do what the government is doing, which is working collaboratively with other jurisdictions. We have to create the climate that will allow for the expansion of our refineries. Claims · 29 wordsI think we have 16 now.21 Maybe it is 17. I am not 100% sure. I know Manitoba is one of the only provinces that does not have one.22 Reasoning · 26 wordsI would like to see private businesses, private enterprises and the provincial governments, in particular, working with the federal government on ways we can do that. Positioning · 56 wordsThis government, headed by this Prime Minister, has made it very clear that we are a government that will work collaboratively with other jurisdictions, the private sector and, in particular, investors to build a stronger and healthier Canada for all and an economy that is there for all Canadians.Vague promise That is what we are all about.Positioning
Analysed on