Analysis · Speech on a bill · beta

Rebecca Alty

1205 words · 74 sentences · 85 clauses

Statement grade
A+
Average 97 / 100
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Greeting 2%Procedure 5%Claims 66%Reasoning 20%Promise 6%Positioning 1%

This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.

Madam Speaker, Greeting · 21 wordsI would like to begin by acknowledging that we are gathered on the unceded traditional territory of the Algonquin Anishinabe people.Greeting Procedure · 20 wordsToday, I want to speak about Bill C-39, the building Canada strong act, and why it matters for Canada’s future.Procedure Claims · 47 wordsCanada is at a pivotal moment. The global economy is undergoing a major transformation. Countries around the world are competing to attract investment, create jobs and develop new industries. At the same time, Canadians are feeling the effects of the rising cost of living and economic uncertainty. Reasoning · 66 wordsTo meet these challenges, we must grow. We must build roads, ports, clean energy projects, transportation networks and other infrastructure that will enable Canada to grow and create good jobs. When we talk about building Canada, we must remember something important. It is not just about what we build, but also about how we build. That is why indigenous peoples must be part of this work. Claims · 35 wordsAfter all, first nations, Inuit and Métis are not only rights holders. They are business leaders, investors, entrepreneurs, employers and project owners. They are helping to shape Canada’s economy and create opportunities for future generations. Reasoning · 11 wordsSimply put, we cannot build a stronger Canada without indigenous peoples. Claims · 128 wordsThat is why we have taken steps to support indigenous participation in major projects. We have opened new consultation resource centres to help communities participate in project reviews. We have provided funding so indigenous communities have the expertise and capacity they need to engage in discussions about projects that affect them. The growing role of indigenous ownership is reflected in the success of the First Nations Finance Authority, a first nations-led, not-for-profit financial institution created under the federal First Nations Fiscal Management Act.1 Earlier this year, the FNFA issued a record $800-million bond, helping push total first nations investments financed through the institution beyond $5 billion.2 Those investments are supporting housing, infrastructure, business development, clean energy and indigenous participation in major projects across Canada because participation is important, Reasoning · 37 wordsbut ownership is even more powerful. When communities have ownership, they do not just have a seat at the table; they have a stake in what is being built and a share in the benefits that result. Procedure · 12 wordsAcross Canada, we are already seeing examples of what that looks like.Procedure Claims · 368 wordsWataynikaneyap Power is a first nations majority-owned transmission project.3 The project connected remote communities and Ontario’s electricity grid, reducing reliance on diesel fuel while creating a long-term indigenous-owned infrastructure asset that will provide benefits for generations to come.4 The Canada Nickel’s Crawford project is showing how indigenous communities are becoming true partners in Canada’s critical mineral sector. The Taykwa Tagamou First Nation made a significant equity investment in the project, helping ensure that economic opportunities, decision-making and long-term benefits are shared with the community.5 The project will help supply the critical minerals needed for batteries and other clean technologies that drive down emissions while also creating jobs and economic growth in the region. In B.C., the Portland Canal marine terminal is a deep-sea port with the primary purpose of critical mineral transportation from the region to overseas markets.6 The terminal is jointly owned by the Nisg̱a’a and Tahltan nations, 7as well as Arrow Transportation Systems. These projects are among many across the country that show what reconciliation looks like in action. They demonstrate that indigenous communities are not simply participants in Canada’s economy, but helping lead it. Many indigenous communities have told us that consultations often start too late. Others have told us that they have to answer the same questions posed by different government departments. Some communities are experiencing consultation fatigue; in other words, they spend so much time navigating government processes that they have less time to devote to the issues that matter most. We have listened to these concerns. These comments have helped shape the building Canada act. The goal of the legislation is simple. We want to make project reviews more efficient and more predictable while maintaining indigenous rights and environmental protections. One of the key parts of the bill is reducing duplication. Instead of having several federal bodies reviewing the same project separately, the legislation supports a more coordinated approach with the goal of having one federal review process and one coordinated consultation process whenever possible. We also propose creating a Crown consultation hub.8 We can think of it as a central coordination team. Its job would be to help federal departments work together, identify issues earlier and improve communication with indigenous communities. Reasoning · 15 wordsThe goal is not to have less consultation; the goal is to have better consultation. Promise · 26 wordsWe want indigenous communities spending less time dealing with red tape and more time having meaningful discussions about projects that affect their lands, waters and futures. Procedure · 18 wordsI also want to be very clear about what does not change under the building Canada strong act.Procedure Claims · 43 wordsCanada’s duty to consult does not change. Our obligations under modern treaties and self-government agreements do not change. Indigenous rights remain protected. Meaningful consultation remains essential. When more time is needed for consultation, the legislation allows for extensions or timelines to be paused.9 Procedure · 15 wordsThere is another reason why it is important for good projects to move ahead faster.Procedure Reasoning · 25 wordsIf Canada really wants to fight climate change, we need to build infrastructure that will help to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and improve our future. Claims · 35 wordsThat includes the renewable energy generation, power lines, energy storage and other clean energy projects. All too often, projects that could help communities reduce their dependence on diesel are subject to long, complicated approval processes. Reasoning · 50 wordsBy making reviews more efficient, reducing duplication and improving coordination, we can help move forward projects that Canadians need while continuing to uphold strong environmental protections and meaningful consultation with indigenous peoples. Building faster and protecting the environment are not competing goals. When done properly, they go hand in hand. Claims · 97 wordsI also want to note that the situation in Canada’s north is unique. In the Yukon, Nunavut and much of the Northwest Territories, project reviews are already carried out through modern treaty and co-management systems that were designed with indigenous partners and reflect constitutionally protected agreements. Bill C-39 does not replace those systems. However, in the Inuvialuit settlement region, where federal impact assessment processes continue to play a significant role, the improvements in coordination, consultation and permitting proposed in this legislation could help provide greater certainty and efficiency while continuing to respect indigenous rights and existing obligations. Positioning · 12 wordsSome people talk as though economic development and reconciliation were at odds.Positioning Reasoning · 43 wordsI see them as working hand in hand. Indigenous peoples are not just being consulted on major projects: They are increasingly owning, investing in and leading them. When indigenous communities are true partners, projects are stronger, communities benefit and everyone is better off. Claims · 38 wordsThat is the vision behind the building Canada strong act. It is a Canada that builds, a Canada that creates jobs, a Canada that attracts investment and a Canada that respects indigenous rights, honours treaties and advances reconciliation. Promise · 43 wordsWe can build the infrastructure our country needs. We can create opportunities for future generations, and we can do it together. That is how we advance reconciliation. That is how we create shared prosperity. That is how we build Canada strong for all.

Analysed on