“Mr. Speaker, I would like to thank my colleague, the member for Simcoe North, for his excellent speech. He is a member who brings a great deal of substance to parliamentary debate. I would like to discuss the form of the motion, because the motion simply calls for the Prime Minister to be invited to appear as a witness before the Standing Committee on Finance. He does not even have to accept. I think that is necessary. The Minister of Finance appeared before the committee recently. He was unable to answer questions or understand how the tax system works. He showed up with an infographic featuring coloured bubbles that looked like something a seven-year-old would draw for Halloween. Earlier, the member for Bourassa told us that, as the government, they do not move motions. They are above that. They bring down budgets. They are the ones doing the real work. We supported his private member’s bill, incidentally. He seems to have forgotten that. I get the impression that all of this shows a kind of neglect or contempt for parliamentary work. The Liberals will probably vote against the motion. What do they stand to gain by voting against the motion? We want to invite the Prime Minister to come answer questions. He can even decline the invitation. Why would they vote against that?”
Statement grade
C+
The average of Signal, Relevance, Respect and Clarity is 84. The grade is held to 67, 30 above Signal.
67 / 100, held down by Signal
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Thanks 42%Claims 26%Reasoning 15%Positioning 17%
This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.
Mr. Speaker, Thanks · 24 wordsI have shared many good conversations about economics with my colleague.I find him to be incredibly smart, and his question is quite correct.ThanksClaims · 18 wordsThe Prime Minister does not need to show up to question period every day, and he does not, 2Reasoning · 21 wordswhich is maybe why we are asking that he might show up to a committee to answer some questions about this.Thanks · 33 wordsWhile I have a lot of respect for the finance minister, and I hold him in very high regard as a parliamentarian, this fiscal promise to Canadians was not the finance minister’s promise.ThanksClaims · 18 wordsThis was the Prime Minister’s promise.1It is the Prime Minister’s choice to blow through the fiscal anchor.Positioning · 23 wordsIt is the Prime Minister’s choice to put our debt on a bad track.Frankly, the Prime Minister should want to answer questions.Positioning