Analysis · Debate reply · beta

Sean Fraser

148 words · 5 sentences · 8 clauses

Replying to Tamara Jansen (Conservative)
“Mr. Speaker, it is absolutely shameful that the Liberal government is shutting down debate on a bill that deals with life and death. Let us think about this for a minute. The Liberals had all summer, and now it has been nearly three weeks since Bill C-41 was introduced. We still have not seen the government’s own analysis of how this bill could affect Canadians’ charter rights and yet, they are already shutting down debate. This bill would allow someone to be euthanized years after making a request, when they can no longer consent and can no longer tell us if they have changed their mind, and other people who do not know them will be making that final decision for them. We are talking about ending the life of someone who can no longer speak for themselves. Surely, if there was ever a bill that deserves careful scrutiny, this is it. Instead, the Liberals are rushing it through, without even giving MPs the information we need to do our jobs. How can the government possibly justify shutting down debate on Canadians’ fundamental rights when it has not even given Parliament its own charter analysis?”
Statement grade
B–
74 / 100, held down by Relevance
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Reasoning 54%Procedure 3%Claims 43%

This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.

Mr. Speaker, Reasoning · 55 wordswith enormous respect to all members of this House, the motivation to move forward is born out of the strong desire to give agency to people who are losing capacity to make decisions for themselves, so we no longer condemn people to a death that is certain and that will involve, by definition, intolerable suffering.Partly on point Procedure · 5 wordsI would remind the member, ProcedureClaims · 63 wordsas well, that what we are talking about here is not a new health care regime, but a change to Canada’s criminal laws.1 The alternative to supporting this legislation is to maintain the fact that medical practitioners who abide by provincial standards and who follow, to the letter, the requirements of health laws developed by provincial governments, are to be treated as criminals.2 Reasoning · 25 wordsI do not think that is the right path forward. We should protect them from criminal liability and extend compassion to those who are suffering.Partly on point

Analysed on