“Mr. Speaker, the hon. Minister of Justice will not be surprised to hear that I object to pushing this bill through quickly. He will probably recall from many previous debates such as this that I always oppose pushing bills through quickly. This one has some particular concerns that are doubled by my experience of this new version of what is still, apparently, called a Liberal government, which says that once we push it through quickly at this stage, we are also likely to have it pushed through quickly in committee. We are also likely to not have enough witnesses, study or amendments at committee with adequate time to study. My pleading with the minister is this. I think the official opposition has a good point, that this bill could be split in two, but I still have problems with the first part of the bill, as do Canadian civil liberties organizations. We need to have proper and full debate. Also, while I have the floor, I object to the idea that there is a patchwork here. In the first versions of medical assistance in dying, when Jody Wilson-Raybould and Jane Philpott brought it forward, it was the same law across the country.”
Statement grade
A+
The average of Signal, Relevance, Respect and Clarity.
Average 95 / 100
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Thanks 15%Claims 33%Reasoning 52%
This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.
Mr. Speaker, Thanks · 28 wordsI would remind the member that I have great respect for her, as always, and appreciate her point of view in this instance and in others as well.ThanksClaims · 22 wordsOn the issue she raised with respect to a patchwork, I would remind the House that we are amending the Criminal Code, 1Reasoning · 59 wordswhich necessitates a conversation about very specific safeguards that we want to insist are in place, which would delve into provincial governments’ authorities should we do it in a way that would be uniform in nature across the country from day one, particularly the requirement that a repository is created in order to avoid criminal liability under the bill.Claims · 41 wordsMore specifically, on the issue of splitting the bill and the time allocated for debate, we have seen substantial debate play out on these issues across Canada, in Parliament, not only during the present debate but during previous studies as well.Reasoning · 41 wordsAt its core, I am uncomfortable delaying further the implementation of these rules knowing that there are people who are suffering and who deserve to have their agency recognized at a time when there is a deadly disease taking their capacity.