Analysis · Debate reply · beta

Sean Fraser

153 words · 6 sentences · 8 clauses

Replying to Connie Cody (Conservative)
“Mr. Speaker, under the bill, a Canadian whose death is not reasonably foreseeable can be assessed for MAID in a very short time. They can sign up for an advance request, fast-tracking their request for death instead of fast-tracking it to care. Currently, this leads provinces to deliver advance requests through their own health systems, and those are the same systems in which Canadians are already waiting half a year, a year or two years for surgery. People who might be able to recover very quickly are suffering more of an impact from the weight of the health care system. Before someone signs up for MAID to actually die, what assurances would the government give to make sure they receive the care they need in ample time?”
Statement grade
A+
Average 98 / 100
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Claims 64%Reasoning 31%Positioning 5%

This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.

Mr. Speaker, Claims · 98 wordsI take issue with the characterization of this being about fast-tracking people’s death. I keep in mind that we are dealing with sets of circumstances that involve, by definition in the legislation, intolerable suffering that is recognized by multiple medical assessors, 1where there is an irremediable condition.2 We are trying to respect the wishes of people, people I have sat down with who have told me what it is like to watch their parents lose who they were and become violent toward their children and their caregivers and then to have themselves be diagnosed with the same condition. Reasoning · 23 wordsIn those circumstances, it is my judgment, and the position of the government, that we should not characterize this as fast-tracking someone’s death. Positioning · 7 wordsI find that to be without taste.Positioning Reasoning · 25 wordsInstead, we should recognize that they deserve agency over the quality of life that they should enjoy as they deal with the worst possible diagnosis.

Analysed on