Analysis · Debate reply · beta

Sean Fraser

154 words · 10 sentences · 11 clauses

Replying to Michael Cooper (Conservative)
“Mr. Speaker, the time allocation motion is nothing short of outrageous. We have had one day of debate on a bill that significantly expands MAID with the introduction of advance requests. The last time advance requests were meaningfully studied was back in 2018, when the Council of Canadian Academies’ expert panel recommended against them. Since then, there has been no meaningful consultation and no meaningful study. The minister spoke of the special joint committee. I sat on that special joint committee. At best, the committee did a cursory review of advance requests. Advance requests raise profound legal, ethical and practical issues and present significant risks, including the very real risk that MAID could be administered against a patient’s wishes, absent contemporaneous consent. Given all of that, how can the minister possibly justify shutting down debate?”
Statement grade
A
Average 94 / 100
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Procedure 7%Claims 41%Promise 21%Reasoning 31%

This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.

Mr. Speaker, Procedure · 11 wordsone element of the question was directed at a central issue.Procedure Claims · 13 wordsIt is about respecting a patient’s wishes. We clearly hold a different view. Promise · 13 wordsWe wish to move forward with a regime that provides for advance requests. Claims · 27 wordsIn fact, the legislation would not create the regime in provincial health systems but would simply decriminalize the practice where there is a provincial regime in place.1 Reasoning · 47 wordsThe reason we want to move forward is about giving agency and respecting the patient’s request. To do otherwise would be to condemn them to experience a death that is intolerable, in the level of suffering they would experience, with a known result and a continued deterioration. Promise · 13 wordsWe want to do what we can to give agency to those individuals.Vague promise Claims · 23 wordsWe have, at a government level, with the Department of Health, and as a Parliament, been able to study these and related issues. Promise · 7 wordsThe time to move forward is now.

Analysed on