Analysis · Debate reply · beta

Blaine Calkins

217 words · 10 sentences · 12 clauses

Replying to Marie-Hélène Gaudreau (Bloc Québécois)
“Madam Speaker, this bill talks about life and death. With all due respect to my colleague, I would say that the very foundation of this is knowing our safeguards and ensuring that we respect the individual and their dignity in the event of such a request, whether it is an advance directive or a request for medical assistance in dying to avoid palliative care and sedation. As we all know, Quebec has taken the lead, and this bill contains some very good provisions. Does my colleague agree that, even if he wants to take more time, it might be a good idea to respect what Quebec has done so that it can move forward?”
Statement grade
B–
72 / 100, held down by Relevance
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Procedure 4%Reasoning 63%Claims 33%

This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.

Madam Speaker, Procedure · 9 wordsI understand both sides of the argument very well.Procedure Reasoning · 63 wordsAs somebody who personally believes strongly in the dignity of life, I have a lot of questions and concerns about the safeguards that would come with advance requests for medical assistance in dying. As somebody who grew up on a farm and is a hunter, I also understand that we want to be as humane as possible in all cases and all circumstances.1 Claims · 71 wordsMost advance requests now are about things like not resuscitating someone if they have a heart attack.2 This is about how not to provide care. That is a completely different question from how to administer the end of life. If somebody has the ability to do an advance directive on the end of their life, they will have given a set of instructions on how to go about ending their life. Reasoning · 74 wordsThat could be used and manipulated in a lot of different ways if we are not careful. We have to be very sure that the guardrails we have in place actually fulfill the directives of the individual in question, if that is how the House chooses to proceed, and make sure that vulnerable people, disabled people and elderly people are not susceptible to abuse. That is the real question that is before this place.Partly on point

Analysed on