Analysis · Reply to a comment · beta

Claude DeBellefeuille

153 words · 11 sentences · 12 clauses

Replying to Garnett Genuis (Conservative)
“Mr. Speaker, I want to pick up on one thing my colleague said. She talked about how, when someone has dementia, they become, in certain respects, a very different person than they were before, which is, in a way, precisely the argument against advance requests, which is that a previous version of a person should not be able to definitively bind a future version of a person, as they may have different preferences and different desires, or they may have a quality of life or an experience of life that is different than what they would have expected. If asked what I would like to happen to me if I had dementia or some other disability, I would find it very hard to predict what my experience would be or what I would feel one way or the other. This is why, generally speaking, we expect contemporaneous consent. That is, we rely on the consent of the person themselves in the moment. It would seem strange to me to go from saying that a person becomes a completely different person to concluding that person one should be able to make life-or-death decisions for person two.”
Statement grade
A
Average 91 / 100
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Thanks 11%Reasoning 22%Claims 59%Positioning 8%

This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.

Madam Speaker, Thanks · 17 wordsI appreciate my colleague’s remarks, and I can see that he is giving the issue some thought.Thanks Reasoning · 14 wordsThat said, I do not think he fully understands the principle behind advance requests. Claims · 51 wordsAdvance requests exist precisely so that a person who is capable can consent to care, provided the necessary criteria are met. Once a person develops dementia and is declared incapable, that person can no longer make decisions. Advance requests cannot be made once a person is ill or living with dementia.1 Reasoning · 11 wordsThat is not really the issue before us in Bill C‑41. Claims · 19 wordsI understand that medical assistance in dying can give rise to ideological debates that are rooted in religious values.Partly on point Positioning · 12 wordsI respect my colleague’s perspective, even though I do not share it.Positioning Claims · 20 wordsThe beauty of this is that nothing is mandatory and nothing is imposed. What matters is the individual’s own wishes. Reasoning · 9 wordsPersonally, I strongly believe in people’s right to self-determination.

Analysed on