Analysis · Speech on a bill · beta

Blake Richards

1410 words · 62 sentences · 81 clauses

Statement grade
A–
Average 85 / 100
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Procedure 5%Claims 31%Reasoning 38%Positioning 18%The ask 3%Aside 4%

This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.

Madam Speaker, Procedure · 20 wordsI rise today to speak about Bill C-41, the government’s latest piece of legislation related to medical assistance in dying.Procedure Claims · 27 wordsNow, my Conservative colleagues and I welcome the overdue admission in this bill that expanding MAID to individuals suffering solely from mental illness is a dangerous step. Reasoning · 41 wordsWe know that people living with mental illness can experience tremendous suffering, but we also know that recovery is possible, that circumstances can change, and that people deserve access to the treatment and support that can help them rebuild their lives. Positioning · 30 wordsFor years, Conservatives have been arguing that Canadians struggling with mental illness deserve treatment, support and hope, not the government telling them that MAID is the best option for them.Positioning Reasoning · 34 wordsThe responsibility of government should be to ensure that these options are available, not to create a system where someone who is struggling may come to see MAID as their best or only option. Claims · 18 wordsThe other part of this piece of legislation is a separate issue altogether, the idea of advance requests.1 Positioning · 47 wordsI really struggle to understand why the Liberals feel the need to tie these two issues together. I think I do understand why, but I really struggle to understand why they are doing this, taking two different issues, one where there seems to be pretty broad agreement, PositioningReasoning · 81 wordsand another one where there is certainly a need for more study. Advance requests raise serious questions about consent, safeguards, provincial jurisdiction and a whole host of things that need to be considered. They deserve to have a thorough study, not to just be rushed through in a piece of legislation because they are being tied together with the other concept that there is obviously a need to rush but also where there seems to be a lot more broad consent. Positioning · 52 wordsI think it is even more important to note that in the context of the government’s track record, in terms of ensuring that there are proper safeguards, ensuring that getting this legislation right when it comes to the topic of medical assistance in dying, the government’s track record is not exactly good.Positioning Reasoning · 42 wordsThere is no doubt that this piece of legislation needed to be split into two pieces of legislation to be voted on separately, Unearned certaintyso that one could pass with the speed that is needed, and the other one could be studied properly. Claims · 41 wordsNot only did the Liberals ignore our legitimate pleas to split the bill, 2but now they are shutting down debate, and ramming it through without allowing for that proper study or for that scrutiny to take place that needs to happen.3 Positioning · 38 wordsThis is literally a matter of life or death. The Liberals are relegating this legislation to limited debate based on, frankly, what seems to be just petty politics. The Liberals have to stop playing games with people’s lives.Positioning The ask · 21 wordsLet us pass the mental illness provisions, and let us give the advance request the study and scrutiny it is due. Procedure · 23 wordsI want to speak a little, while I have the floor, about the impact of medical assistance in dying on the veteran community.Procedure Aside · 43 wordsThat is a community that is near and dear to my heart, and one that I spend a lot of time thinking about and working for. It is an issue that I hear about quite consistently when I speak with veterans across Canada.Aside Claims · 57 wordsThere are far too many heartbreaking stories from veterans out there who were seeking help from the government to access benefits that they are entitled to, but instead of getting that help that they were asking for to live their lives, they were being offered, and in some cases even pressured, to consider medical assistance in dying.4 Positioning · 57 wordsCan members imagine the impact that has on someone, when they go to the government looking for help to live their lives and are asked if they would consider death instead? Can members imagine the impact that must have on someone, especially when they may already be in a state of suicidality, PTSD or mental health issues?Positioning Claims · 21 wordsThey are already dealing with sanctuary trauma from the organization that is supposed to help them not being there for them, Positioning · 5 wordsand then they get that.Positioning Procedure · 8 wordsWe need to understand what is happening here.Procedure Claims · 54 wordsWhen we are talking about these cases, we are talking about heroes who stepped up and served this country.Partly on point When those veterans returned to Canada, they did not ask for handouts, but asked for the care they earned through their service. They asked for treatment and assistance in their transition back into civilian life.Off point Positioning · 7 wordsWhat did they get from the government?PositioningPartly on point Claims · 33 wordsThey were met with a mountain of delays and denials.Off point Worst of all, in some cases, they were offered medical assistance in dying. In some cases, they were even pressured to consider it. Procedure · 8 wordsI really want people to think about that.Procedure Claims · 45 wordsA veteran calls Veterans Affairs for help and the person on the other end of the line instead offers them death. The system is so overwhelmed and backlogged that, for whatever reason, in some cases, death is being considered a more efficient option than support. Reasoning · 30 wordsIf that is the case, that is a deeply broken system. These stories should concern every single Canadian, no matter what their stance on medical assistance in dying is otherwise. Claims · 31 wordsOur veterans made a commitment to Canada. They accepted difficult assignments, away from their families. In many cases, they returned home carrying physical or psychological injuries that came from their service. Positioning · 20 wordsWhen they came back after fighting those battles, they found themselves fighting another battle, this time with their own government.Positioning Claims · 36 wordsThey are forced to navigate complicated application processes; wait months, and in many cases, even years, for decisions on their benefits; 5and then are often forced to repeatedly demonstrate that those injuries were sustained while serving. Aside · 14 wordsConsider what that means for someone who has already sacrificed so much for Canada.Aside Claims · 42 wordsThey may be dealing with physical and psychological injuries that affect their daily lives. They are not asking for special treatment. They are just asking for the government to honour the commitments it made to them when they signed up to serve. Reasoning · 44 wordsThe government has a responsibility to ensure that every veteran who reaches out for help is treated with dignity and compassion. That means ensuring that VAC employees are well-trained and are ensuring that veterans are connected with the appropriate health care and support services.Off point Procedure · 10 wordsThat brings me to the question of safeguards and accountability.Procedure Reasoning · 88 wordsWhen it comes to medical assistance in dying, the government must be able to demonstrate that medical practitioners are properly trained, that eligibility requirements are being respected and that concerns raised by patients, families and health care professionals are being taken seriously. That means ensuring that individuals are making decisions freely, that they understand the options available to them and that they are not being influenced by outside pressure, by inadequate access to care or a feeling that they have become a burden on their families or society. The ask · 6 wordsBill C-41 must get this right. Claims · 34 wordsWhile we welcome the decision to maintain the exclusion for individuals suffering solely from mental illness, finally, serious questions certainly remain about the safeguards, the oversight and the government’s ability to protect vulnerable Canadians.6 Reasoning · 112 wordsCanada should be a country where someone struggling with their mental health knows that help is available, where someone living with a disability knows they will be supported and where someone facing a serious illness knows they and their family will not be left to navigate those challenges alone. It should certainly be a country where the men and women who put their lives on the line in service to Canada can return home knowing that their government will stand behind them. We have a responsibility to protect those who are most vulnerable. That responsibility must be reflected in our laws, our policies and, most importantly, the services we deliver to Canadians. Procedure · 5 wordsThe answer here is straightforward.Procedure Reasoning · 39 wordsCanadians struggling with a mental illness deserve treatment, individuals living with disabilities deserve support and those facing serious illnesses deserve access to quality care. Our veterans deserve the benefits and assistance they earned through their service to this country. The ask · 20 wordsThe government must ensure that MAID is never presented as a substitute for the care and treatment that Canadians deserve. Reasoning · 26 wordsWhen someone reaches out to the government for help, they should be met with compassion and solutions, not the suggestion that death is their best option.

Analysed on