“Mr. Speaker, I thank my colleague for her excellent speech outlining the problems with the regime as it exists and also with the advance request provision. California legalized MAID, medically facilitated death, around the same time Canada did. We have more than 15 times the number of people here in Canada who are getting MAID. What does that tell us? Does that tell us that Canadians are just more likely to want to die than people in California, or does it say that there are different aspects of the system, the regime, the social context around it and the verification process in these two jurisdictions, and that they are having dramatically different effects? I would like to see more discussion in the House about all of the cases where we see safeguards not working, and where we see people getting rejected and then finding two people who agree. We need more discussion here about the evident problems with the existing system, but that is not the priority of the government. The priority of the government is continuing to try to push the bill forward with as limited a debate as possible without analyzing the serious issues and problems that are underneath it. I wonder if the member has a comment on that.”
Statement grade
A
The average of Signal, Relevance, Respect and Clarity.
Average 94 / 100
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Claims 64%Positioning 16%Reasoning 20%
This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.
Mr. Speaker, Claims · 115 wordsit is a very important comparison to make between Canada and state jurisdictions in the United States, or even in countries that Canada saw as very liberal in the application of MAID, such as the Netherlands and Belgium, prior to its legalization in Canada.1Canada has now surpassed other regimes in the world that we saw as the most liberal just ten years ago.In fact, many of the debates that took place in this chamber a decade ago were talking about the slippery slope that would allow the social context of the inability of our medical system to treat people with dignity to use MAID as an excuse to be offered in those circumstances.Positioning · 29 wordsWe have gone down that slippery slope now.It is so concerning that, in the name of compassion, we have actually eliminated compassion and reverence for the individual person.PositioningReasoning · 37 wordsOur medical system needs to bring that back and we, as Parliament, need to safeguard the rights of all people, especially for the vulnerable and those with disabilities, that they are recognized as valuable people of society.