Analysis · Debate reply · beta

Elizabeth May

227 words · 10 sentences · 16 clauses

Replying to Garnett Genuis (Conservative)
“Mr. Speaker, I want to thank the former and future leader of the Green Party for her comments. I certainly wish Mike Morrice well in his caucus management efforts. This is a serious question for my colleague. In a way, she answered a question I had asked more honestly and more directly than the justice minister had. I tried to ask the justice minister if a person should be told at the moment their life is being ended if they had signed an advance directive. I think what she said, which was direct though also horrifying to me, is that a person who provides consent and then loses capacity should be killed regardless of what their future self who is affected by that illness thinks, based on an advance directive. In other words, the person can, at full capacity, bind their future self. At the point at which they lose capacity, they also lose the right to not want to proceed with a death that had been decided for them previously. Is that really what she thinks?”
Statement grade
B+
Average 84 / 100
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Aside 10%Thanks 4%Claims 57%Reasoning 30%

This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.

Mr. Speaker, Aside · 22 wordsI am certain of one thing, and that is that I am not the future leader of the Green Party of Canada, AsideThanks · 8 wordsbut I appreciate the member’s humour as always.Thanks Claims · 130 wordsThe thing about this is, to make it way too personal, perhaps, when my husband’s younger brother was dying with cancer and asked for medical assistance in dying, my husband was in the room with his little brother.1 The doctors looked to him, and of course, there was no question of mental capacity. He had terminal cancer and was in a lot of pain. The doctors just said to him, “Can you sign this? Can you confirm that you want the procedure, medical assistance in dying?” My husband said his brother looked up with a big grin and a thumbs-up. He no longer had the capacity to sign, but he had the capacity to know that he could not stand the suffering and he was going to be dying soon.Partly on point Reasoning · 67 wordsNow, as to the question about medical and mental capacity to make the decision, Partly on pointif someone else had made some kind of decision about another’s future, it would be unpardonable to imagine that they would not have the ability to say, “I don’t want that.” However, when a person makes a decision for their own self, in their right mind with full capacity, that should be honoured.

Analysed on