Analysis · Floor speech · beta

Matt Strauss

540 words · 26 sentences · 33 clauses

Statement grade
A
Average 93 / 100
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Procedure 9%Positioning 8%Claims 54%The ask 21%Reasoning 7%The question 1%

This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.

Mr. Speaker, Procedure · 36 wordsit is always a pleasure to be here at the late show on my months-long quest to get very basic answers from the government, specifically the health minister, pertaining to the governance of Canada Health Infoway.Procedure Positioning · 9 wordsWhat on earth has gone on at that organization?Positioning Claims · 68 wordsIt has blown $1 billion over the last 10 years.1 It spent $300 million specifically on PrescribeIT, with nothing to show for it.2 The Minister of Health indicated in a roundabout way that she spoke with the board to get Michael Green fired. The chair of the board then said that she had done no such thing.3 The chair of the board has since resigned, 4as I understand, The ask · 27 wordsand I would just like the health minister to exercise some clarity, transparency and accountability and to disclose to us whether or not she fired the CEO. Reasoning · 14 wordsAccountability goes both ways. If she does a bad job, she should be accountable. Positioning · 34 wordsIf she fired Michael Green, that would be perhaps the best action that any minister of the Crown has taken in this Parliament, and I would just like to give her kudos for it.Positioning The ask · 23 wordsPerhaps tonight she could, transparently and in the spirit of accountability, just answer the question of whether she intended to fire Michael Green. Claims · 143 wordsThe last time I put the question to her in the House, she said that now that Michael Green is suing Canada Health Infoway for wrongful dismissal, the matter is before the courts and that therefore she will not answer.56 I said in my follow-up question that she has parliamentary privilege and is able to say whether she fired him or not, and that she is misapplying the idea of the matter being before the courts, the sub judice convention. I took the liberty of going through the House of Commons Procedure and Practice section on sub judice to find that, in general, the principle exists because we constitutionally recognize the independence of the courts and their ability to make decisions and judgments about matters that are put to them. What she did in this instance is not a matter before the court. Reasoning · 18 wordsShe can say what she did. She is not passing judgment on the merits of Michael Green’s lawsuit. The ask · 61 wordsI want to underscore again that I am here to find out whether the Minister of Health fired Michael Green. It is a very short question. It could have a very short response. We do not have to be here for the rest of my late show time if they would just answer whether the Minister of Health fired Michael Green. Claims · 72 wordsBefore they answer, I want to underscore again that House of Commons Procedure and Practice, third edition, on the matter of sub judice, says, “in 1976, the Speaker ruled that no restriction ought to exist on the right of any Member to put questions respecting any matter before the courts, particularly those relating to a civil matter, 7unless and until that matter is at least at trial.” This is a civil matter. Procedure · 12 wordsI am quoting directly from the policies and procedures of this place, ProcedureClaims · 8 wordsand this matter is not yet at trial. Reasoning · 8 wordsTherefore, I can ask, and they can answer. The question · 7 wordsDid the health minister fire Michael Green?

Analysed on