“Mr. Speaker, I am following up on my question, which was asked to the Minister of Finance. At that time, I asked him about the Liberals’ projection on whether they were going to meet their fiscal targets in the ensuing budgetary year. I noted to the Minister of Finance that the Parliamentary Budget Officer had predicted that the government was unlikely to meet several of its fiscal targets. Now that we have seen the budget, we can confirm that the Parliamentary Budget Officer was correct. The budget is 360 or 370 pages, I do not know exactly, I do not remember, and most of it is just marketing. For anyone who is watching at home, they do not really need to read the first 300 pages, because there is nothing in there but platitudes, marketing and propaganda from the Liberals. What they really want to do is go to the annex of the budget. There are only a couple of pages and a couple of tables that set out what is important. I am going to give people two tonight that I think are probably the most important. The first is on page 326, table A1.8, entitled “Summary statement of transactions”. That means it is the revenue and expenses of the government. It sets out what the government calls the “budgetary balance”, which is the deficit. It sets out a number of comparators, for example, public debt charges as a percentage of GDP, and I am going to focus on that. On the budgetary balance side is the amount of money the government spends over and above what it is bringing in, which is the deficit. Next year, it will be $62.3 billion by the Liberals’ own estimation. Over the entire horizon of the budget’s five-year forecast, it is $288.7 billion. The second table that is important, for folks at home, is on page 336. It is table A1.11, which is the total financial requirements. It is how much money the government needs to borrow every year. Regardless of what government members say, regardless of whatever fiscal anchor they have today and is gone tomorrow, we can look at the table and see exactly how much the government is borrowing. If we look at that table, it shows us that, next year, the government will borrow $149.5 billion, and over a five-year period, it will borrow $764.7 billion. The fact is, Liberals can say they have a declining deficit, they have this or that, but the reality is that we are borrowing more money and are spending more money on debt. We can look at it right in their own tables, and that is both in aggregate, so total amount, and in proportion to the size of our economy. The government’s deficit numbers that the Liberals are trying to sell to Canadians are misleading. They are trying to show declining deficits, but that hides the fact that debt continues to rise. The Parliamentary Budget Officer explained this in October. The PBO predicted that “federal borrowing will grow...faster than deficits, which are measured on an accrual basis.” That is because the government is borrowing money to fund independent agencies to finance loans, investments, defence procurement, etc., but the reality is that the government still has to go to market and still has to borrow that money. It may not show up on the deficit number now, but it shows up on those tables on the debt charge. It is interesting that it was not so long ago that the Liberals actually believed in a declining debt to GDP, but they since have abandoned that. They believed it in 2024 in their budget. They believed it in 2025 in their election platform campaign, but now that the numbers do not line up and are actually increasing, they do not believe it anymore. My question to the parliamentary secretary or to the minister is: Why do they keep changing the goalposts?”
Statement grade
B–
The average of Signal, Relevance, Respect and Clarity is 77. The grade is held to 74, 30 above Relevance.
74 / 100, held down by Relevance
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Claims 80%Positioning 9%Reasoning 11%
This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.
Mr. Speaker, Claims · 22 wordsthe world is changing rapidly.Global uncertainty, trade tensions and rising geopolitical instability are creating new challenges for businesses, workers and families.Off pointPositioning · 19 wordsOur government has focused on what we can control, like building a stronger, more resilient and more prosperous economy, PositioningPartly on pointClaims · 97 wordsand fiscal discipline is central to this approach.By spending less on day-to-day operations and managing public finances responsibly, we can invest more in Canadian workers and industries while making generational investments in the infrastructure, defence, housing, innovation and productivity capacity needed to expand our economy.Canada’s strong fiscal position is what gives us the room to make these investments.It allows us to invest in our people, strengthen our sovereignty and create new opportunities for Canadians while maintaining the fiscal discipline that Canadians expect.Canadians also expect the government to operate efficiently and deliver effective services.Reasoning · 15 wordsThat means ensuring that public dollars are focused where they can have the greatest impact.Claims · 106 wordsBy reducing spending on government operations, we can dedicate more resources in budget 2026 to growing our economy, making life more affordable and protecting our culture and way of life.At the same time, we are using Canada’s fiscal strength to create the conditions for businesses to invest, expand and create good jobs.Partly on pointThrough strategic, targeted investments and broad-based tax policy changes, Canada remains among the leading advanced economies for tax competitiveness.Budget 2026 advances flagship tax policy changes, including the productivity mega deduction and the Canada growth incentive, 1which will also further strengthen our tax competitiveness and create the conditions to catalyze an investment supercycle.Off pointReasoning · 22 wordsResponsible fiscal management is not about choosing between discipline and ambition.It is about ensuring we have the capacity to do both.Partly on pointClaims · 42 wordsBudget 2026 keeps Canada on track to meet our two fiscal anchors: balancing day-to-day operating spending with revenues by 2027-28, a year ahead of schedule; 2and keeping the deficit-to-GDP ratio on a declining path while charting a plan to invest for growth.3Reasoning · 11 wordsMeeting these commitments means making deliberate choices about how government operates.Claims · 67 wordsThe public service is vital to delivering the programs and services Canadians rely on on a day-to-day basis, Partly on pointbut its growth had become unsustainable, outpacing population growth.4That is why we took decisive action to return the public service to more sustainable levels, refocus government spending and ensure that more resources can go toward the priorities that will strengthen Canada’s economy and improve Canadians’ quality of life.Vague promisePositioning · 18 wordsThat is our approach, to spend responsibly, invest strategically and build a stronger Canadian economy for the future.PositioningPartly on point