“Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to rise tonight to follow up on a question that I originally asked on September 23. I did not get an answer to my question. I would like to save time tonight and make sure the parliamentary secretary focuses on the question I wanted an answer to, which was whether we are going to see a cost-benefit analysis for what is now being called, for public relations purposes, the Pacific link, the pipeline to be built by the Government of Alberta and the Government of Canada in the absence of a private sector proponent. It is a project that expands greenhouse gas emissions. There were commitments made by the Government of Canada to meet the Paris Agreement commitments. However, my question was specifically about public expenditure of money. The minister gave an answer about how good their climate plans were, but completely avoided the question of whether there is a cost-benefit analysis to justify the expenditure of public funds on a project that is now, since the time of this question, designated as a project in the national interest. I will also add, because I will not get to it in the rebuttal, that part of the answer from the Minister of the Environment, in not answering my question, was to highlight what she calls clean energy, “to highlight Churchill Falls...14,000 megawatts of power”. That was not at all relevant to my question. Since we have not had an opportunity to debate that in the House, every time I hear a Liberal member talk about how Churchill Falls and Gull Island expansions will create clean energy, I would ask Liberals to be aware of the fact that it cannot be called clean energy if it poisons indigenous people. There is abundant evidence, many studies, on how the expansion of Churchill Falls and the Gull Island plant will increase methylmercury in the waters, and therefore in the fish and the food that indigenous people have a right to harvest and eat. We do not want to expand the poisoning of indigenous people by methylmercury. I will also point out that, as a matter of claiming that this has any relevance at all to climate targets, Gull Island is predicted, if everything goes according to plan, to be on stream by 2034 and the Churchill Falls expansion by 2035. That puts the provision of this so-called clean energy at the point when our commitments under the Paris Agreement will have already fallen due. According to the Canadian Climate Institute, there is no possible way that we are going to achieve the 40% to 45% below 2005 levels by 2030, which was our legally binding commitment under the previous government of Justin Trudeau. It does not even meet the legally binding commitment that was put forward as an intended nationally determined contribution by the previous government of Stephen Harper. It is again, on many levels, an affront, and I hope the parliamentary secretary can take on board at least this. Here we have in budget 2026, page 125, the only commitment under any of the projects they are describing as being potentially of national importance, a commitment “to provide $37 million in [budget year] 2027-28 to support robust cost-benefit analysis of proposed interties”. I favour those proposed interties, absolutely, but I find it puzzling that there is no reference in any other government document or financial projection for any cost-benefit analysis on any other project other than the interties question. I find it baffling that we would think it wise to pour tens of billions of dollars into a project that will lose Canada money and wreck through our targets.”
Statement grade
C+
The average of Signal, Relevance, Respect and Clarity is 73. The grade is held to 66, 30 above Relevance.
66 / 100, held down by Relevance
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.
Mr. Speaker, Greeting · 16 wordsit is always a pleasure to rise and respond to my dear friend from Saanich—Gulf Islands.GreetingClaims · 43 wordsWe all know that Canadians are facing a changing world.Unearned certaintyClimate change is bringing more severe wildfires, floods and extreme heat, but at the same time, families and businesses are dealing with affordability pressures, economic uncertainty and growing demands on our energy systems.Reasoning · 52 wordsThese challenges are interconnected, and we need an approach that recognizes that reality.Adapting to today’s economic and global circumstances does not mean that we will walk away from our climate action.It means being pragmatic, adjusting our approach and focusing on results that strengthen Canada’s economy while continuing to reduce emissions.Promise · 13 wordsOur commitment to a net-zero future remains an important part of that work, Claims · 137 wordsand budget 2026 sets out how we intend to get there.Our approach is built around four major building blocks: building clean energy supply, switching to cleaner technologies, transforming energy productivity and innovating for the solutions of tomorrow.We are mobilizing investment, supporting clean energy development, expanding our electricity system and creating the conditions for Canadian businesses to compete in a changing global economy, and we recognize that while the world is making the transition to a lower-carbon economy, Canada has an important role to play as a reliable and trusted energy supplier.That is why we established the Major Projects Office to bring federal expertise together, coordinate complex processes and give projects a clear path toward the approvals and investments they need.1The Building Canada Act gives us additional tools to advance projects of national importance, 2Reasoning · 10 wordsbut efficiency cannot come at the expense of our responsibilities.Promise · 16 wordsWe remain committed to respecting indigenous rights, meaningful partnership with indigenous peoples and strong environmental protections.Vague promiseClaims · 27 wordsThe Major Projects Office also benefits from the advice of an indigenous advisory council, helping it ensure that indigenous perspectives and interests are reflected in this work.3Reasoning · 42 wordsCanadians should not have to choose between economic prosperity and a healthy environment, nor should they have to choose between reliable energy, good jobs and a secure future.Our approach recognizes that we need to deliver on all of these priorities together.Promise · 24 wordsWe will continue to take meaningful action on climate change, strengthen Canadians’ economic resilience and create opportunities for workers and communities across this country.Vague promisePositioning · 19 wordsThat is what responsible nation building looks like, Partly on pointand that is how we will continue to build Canada strong.PositioningOff pointVague promise