Analysis · Debate reply · beta

Elizabeth May

259 words · 15 sentences · 18 clauses

Replying to Scot Davidson (Conservative). The question was off topic, so this reply is judged against the debate.
“Mr. Speaker, Canadians are lining up by the millions at food banks. I note that yesterday the Prime Minister gave an economy that is bigger than us, Brazil, $560 million. My colleague knows that I have been fighting here, since 2019, for the Lake Simcoe cleanup fund, a boots-on-the-ground environmental project, right here in Canada. We cannot even get that. The environment is important. It is important in my riding, and it is important to Canadians right here at home. I wonder if my colleague could comment on that.”
Statement grade
A–
Average 88 / 100
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Thanks 3%Procedure 6%Claims 59%Reasoning 24%Anecdote 8%

This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.

Mr. Speaker, Thanks · 8 wordsI thank my honourable friend from York—South Simcoe.Thanks Procedure · 15 wordsHe has picked an example, and I hope I do not disappoint him too much.Procedure Claims · 51 wordsLast year, the Prime Minister broke a promise to the President of Brazil and, I think, embarrassed Brazil on the world stage. The Prime Minister had committed to attending the high-level summit at COP30 that was taking place, the first climate negotiation to take place in the geographical Amazon, in Belém. Reasoning · 62 wordsThis money is not a lot when we consider that the Canadian climate and the world’s climate depend on what is sometimes called the lungs of the earth, the Amazon.Off point I think most Canadians would be glad to see us putting $560 million into protecting the Amazon rainforest because it is connected to our atmosphere and it is connected to our climate, Claims · 73 wordsbut it goes back to why the Prime Minister made a commitment to a foreign government with whom we are, by the way, trying to secure a trade deal. It is one of the BRIC economies. Brazil is a big economy. It is the biggest economy in South America. We could do more business. I know that one of my friend’s colleagues attacked President Lula. He recently won a democratic and free election. Anecdote · 20 wordsIt so happens that the former minister of environment is an old friend of mine. Her name is Marina Silva.Anecdote Claims · 30 wordsI am very happy to see funding go to protecting the Amazon, but I think it is paltry compared to the billions of dollars that are going to foreign multinationals.

Analysed on