Analysis · Debate reply · beta

Elizabeth May

127 words · 7 sentences · 12 clauses

Replying to Patrick Bonin (Bloc Québécois)
“Mr. Speaker, I want to ask my colleague what she thinks about the fact that the government is presenting this budget as a green budget. It even sent its supposedly green members, including the member for Honoré-Mercier, to say that this is a revolutionary green budget. The Minister of the Environment is currently at the United Nations conference, waving the budget around and telling people to look at how good we are and what we are doing to fight climate change. At the same time, some former members who left that party are publicly saying that the minister is lying and that it is not true that she is honouring Canada’s commitment to the Paris Agreement. It is quite clear, as we understand it, that this budget does not respect the Paris— I accept that, Mr. Speaker. We have a minister who, on the international stage, is saying that her budget will help us to meet our Paris Agreement targets when several other people are saying that it will do exactly the opposite. To what extent does my hon. colleague think this budget amounts to greenwashing, an attempt to make a government that is in bed with the oil and gas industry appear more environmentally friendly?”
Statement grade
A
Average 92 / 100
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Positioning 5%Claims 74%Reasoning 16%Promise 6%

This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.

Mr. Speaker, Positioning · 6 wordsI think my colleague is right.Positioning Claims · 94 wordsCanadian climate leaders are at the UN conference right now. We have Catherine McKenna and Steven Guilbeault at COP31, 1and they stand for climate action.Partly on point This budget does the opposite. As I said when I spoke to the budget on November 6, scandalously, on page 7 of this budget, it not only does not commit to the Paris Agreement targets, 2but also says that, for too long, we have been driven by targets.3 The scientific community has advised us that, if we do not meet those targets, we do not have a human civilization, Reasoning · 20 wordswhich would have a direct impact on our economy, but it would have a particularly large impact on my granddaughter.Partly on point Promise · 7 wordsThat will not happen on my watch.Vague promise

Analysed on