Analysis · Debate question · beta

Warren Steinley

132 words · 12 sentences · 12 clauses

Following a speech by Scot Davidson (Conservative)
“Mr. Speaker, after a decade of failed Liberal policies, Canadians were told that the new leader of the Liberal Party was a financial wizard, a master negotiator, a Prime Minister who would supposedly spend less, invest more and build the strongest economy in the G7. Instead, what they got was the Wizard of Oz, with a booming voice, grand announcements and a great spectacle, all meant to distract from the fact that life has only gotten harder for Canadian families. Across the country, and in my community of York—South Simcoe, people are struggling to pay for groceries, rent and mortgages. Job losses and food bank use are at record levels, yet the Liberals have nothing more to offer in budget 2026 than smoke and mirrors. Pull back the curtain on it all, and we will find the Prime Minister working the levers just like the Wizard of Oz. The lever he has reached for once again in the budget splits government spending into operating expenses and so-called capital investment, letting the Liberals cook the books by moving spending from one column to the other. The Parliamentary Budget Officer has taken a dim view of this creative accounting and lever pulling. According to her analysis, $94 billion of what the Prime Minister calls investment is actually ordinary day-to-day spending. If calling spending an investment makes it free, why stop there? Based on the justification they have already been using, the Prime Minister’s eye-watering inflight catering bills become an investment in hospitality and agriculture. The $60 billion in interest on the debt becomes an investment in capital markets. The possibilities are actually endless. If the so-called investments are such a sure thing, why hold back? The budget promises an investment supercycle that will mobilize $400 billion. If the math is that good, why not spend $1 trillion to get $3 trillion back? After all, according to the government, it is just a capital investment. It might as well be free. Of course, we know the answer. When the Liberals pick pet projects and winners and losers with borrowed money, taxpayers end up paying the bill. We saw this with Stellantis. Taxpayers committed more than half a billion dollars to help retool its plant. For a year, the Prime Minister and his industry minister promised Brampton workers that they would hold the company to its obligations with stern letters and threats of legal action. Last week, Stellantis sold the plant to an armoured vehicle maker, and the Prime Minister called it a betrayal. What he did not tell Canadians is that his own government sat at the table for months, knew the terms of the deal and did nothing to stop it. Unbelievably, the industry minister has responded by offering even more taxpayer money to the company if it keeps the plant open, instead of ensuring the conditions that would let businesses like theirs succeed here in Canada on their own. If workers are being left behind under the Liberals, there is one group that certainly is not, and that is the Prime Minister’s buddies and his Liberal cronies. They have given a $2.3-billion contract to a longtime friend of the PM, $1.6 billion for an AI firm tied to a Liberal donor now running a federal agency, a $2-billion rebate through his old firm Brookfield and hundreds of millions more to keep the media happy and quiet. This is the real return on Liberal investment: bad deals and job losses. Canadian taxpayers get stuck with the bill, and Liberal insiders get rich. All the while, the Prime Minister spins half-truths and tells Canadians only what they want to hear. The Prime Minister, similar to the Wizard of Oz, is doing all this to hide the truth. In this case, he is hiding that it is Canadians who are paying the bill for all of this spending, but Canadians are noticing every time they fill up at the pump, every time they go to the checkout line and every time they look at their paycheque. Instead of ensuring that Canadians can save on food, fuel and homes, the Liberals are adding $765 billion in new debt, costing the average family $6,000 in interest costs this year alone. Under the Liberals, more money is now going toward servicing the debt than health care. It is a great time to be a banker or a bondholder, but it is not a great time to be stuck in an emergency room or waiting for surgery. The Prime Minister would have us ignore all that and put on green-tinted glasses just like they did in the Emerald City. He keeps telling us we have never had it so good, that affordability is the best it has been in 10 years, that the House is in order, while his flying monkeys criss-cross the country repeating the same message. The Liberals say they are making life more affordable with another top-up to the GST credit, but most of the middle class cannot get it, it barely dents grocery bills that are up 33% since 2020, and it comes while the Liberals are making everything more expensive with the industrial carbon tax and bringing back the gas excise tax. Small businesses are being squeezed just as hard. The Canadian Federation of Independent Business called this budget “mega disappointing”, and optimism among entrepreneurs and business owners is at record lows. There is no place like home, but the Prime Minister’s promise to build 500,000 homes a year did not even make it into budget 2026. It is no wonder. Housing starts are down 11% from last September and down 4% so far this year. For all the government’s talk of bringing immigration down, Canada could see more than 600,000 new permanent residents next year, the most in our history, while our hospitals, highways, schools and housing are already at the breaking point and the social fabric is stretched to the limit. If we take our glasses off, we can see just how detached Liberal promises are from the reality Canadians are living in every aspect of their lives. With budget 2026, the Liberals say they want to make us masters of our destiny, but increasingly, more Canadians are becoming masters of none. They cannot find good-paying jobs or save for things they have worked toward, like starting a family, starting a business or retiring with dignity. How can they feel in control of their lives, let alone their destiny? Just like Dorothy, too many Canadians feel like they have been swept up into a storm and dropped somewhere they do not recognize anymore: a Canada where hard work no longer pays off and where the promise of a better life for the next generation is slipping away. Sadly, this budget will only make things worse. I will be voting no on budget 2026.”
Statement grade
A
Average 94 / 100
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Claims 64%Aside 6%Procedure 12%The question 17%

This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.

Mr. Speaker, Claims · 17 wordsI was back in my riding last week, like all members of Parliament were in their ridings. Aside · 8 wordsI am sure my colleague was as well.Aside Procedure · 16 wordsDo colleagues know what I heard about the budget that the Prime Minister just brought forward?Procedure Claims · 30 wordsCrickets. There is nothing in the budget for everyday people. Groceries are more expensive. We just saw Stats Can say inflation is 3.1%, gasoline is higher and groceries are higher.1 The question · 10 wordsI wonder what comments my colleague heard from his constituents. Claims · 38 wordsMy constituents said the budget does not help them. We will be $755 billion more in debt by 2030.2 Debt financing is going to be one of the highest expenses in the federal budget, higher than health care.3 The question · 13 wordsWhat did my colleague’s constituents tell him when he was home last week?

Analysed on