Following a speech by Jeremy Patzer (Conservative)
“Mr. Speaker, I was just speaking out loud and trying to figure out a way to say it differently. We will say it is a myth. The Prime Minister likes to speak in myths about job creation in this country. Let us go back even further, because the Prime Minister was the special economic adviser to the former prime minister, starting in 2020, 2021 or thereabouts. Canada, from 2019 to 2024, added zero private sector jobs. When the Liberals get up and start talking about jobs, quite often they are talking about new government jobs they have added. We heard the finance minister brag about 3.5% annualized growth, which actually happened to be from a bump in the Canada summer jobs program. It was government money that went out. Those jobs later disappeared, and the numbers cratered again. The Liberals have a kind of false way of moving the numbers around. Actually, the annualized number has dropped down to about 1.5% or just under 2% right now, and it is on its way even further down. The result is that the economy, in the months of July, August and September, grew 0%, 0% and -0.1% respectively in that same time frame. Let us go back to the five-year period of 2019-2024. The number of private sector jobs in Ontario per 1,000 people fell by approximately 17.8 jobs over that five-year period. Quebec lost an average of 5.5 private sector jobs during that time period. B.C. had it worse, with an average of 35.7 private sector jobs lost per 1,000 people. The United States, on average, added 7.6 private sector jobs per 1,000 working-age people, while Canada had none. There is another piece within the article from the National Post that reads, “If private sector job creation in Canada had kept up with the United States since 2019, there would have been 554,000 more private sector jobs in 2024”. Instead, a grand total of zero were added on, by the time we go through the net adding and subtracting of jobs over that time frame. The Fraser Institute issued a report that said that living standards for the average Canadian declined from 2020 to 2024 despite growth in the overall economy, and that the drop in GDP per person is the worst over any five-year period since the Great Depression. I recognize, and the government will be sure to stand up and say, that COVID happened. All kinds of things have happened. The reason the Fraser Institute took a five-year sample was so it could model out what was happening for the job recovery and the economic action that were going to be done to create jobs and create momentum upwards in Canada. The Prime Minister, because he was the special adviser to the previous prime minister, was a massive failure in his role as an adviser. We know how pathetic the previous prime minister was as well. There are two quick, little points I want to make so the Liberals do not stand up and say, “Oh, you’re so negative all the time.” I will give them credit on one tiny little thing, which is that there is a small recognition of the helium industry, which is a massive industry now in Saskatchewan. It continues to grow. No pun intended, but it continues to be the one area that is rising to the occasion. The Liberals did include helium in some of their preferential tax treatment, similar to how they are treating oil and gas. That is good to see. The industry was asking for more: to be given the critical mineral designation. Helium is already designated as a critical mineral, but it does not have the same treatment in the tax code as all the other ones, and the industry wanted that. The government added antimony to that, but did not add helium. It could have done that but did not. Also, the industry was hoping to build a helium liquefier in southwest Saskatchewan and has been working with the government to see about getting some funding for it. So far, there is nothing on that. This budget is adding a lot to the deficit. In fact, at the start of my speech, I went to debtclock.ca and started the clock right when I started my speech. In the 10 minutes of my speech in the House, the amount of debt that has been added is $1,300,000. The government is reckless in the way it is spending and in adding $756 billion to the national debt, which is absolutely insane. The Liberals need to stop the reckless spending and at least attempt to get back to a fiscal balance in the House.”
Statement grade
A
The average of Signal, Relevance, Respect and Clarity.
Average 92 / 100
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Procedure 30%Claims 43%The question 27%
This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.
Mr. Speaker, Procedure · 22 wordsI want to zero in on something I found very alarming, and I would like to hear the member’s comments on it.ProcedureClaims · 32 wordsThe Liberals are currently spending more on interest on the debt than they are on health care transfers: $60 billion in interest on the debt and $57 billion in health care transfers.1The question · 20 wordsI would like to hear my colleague’s comments about how that is impacting his community, or his thoughts in general.