“Mr. Speaker, the fact that these thresholds had to be buried in the budget speaks volumes. It is clear that this approach is not working. Quebec will be penalized because the level of immigration the Liberals are planning simply is not sustainable. As Quebec’s deputy premier pointed out, this hidden increase has neither been explained nor justified. We expect greater transparency from the federal government. Can my colleague, the Quebec lieutenant, explain how Quebec is supposed to cope with such an unwarranted increase in immigration?”
Statement grade
B
The average of Signal, Relevance, Respect and Clarity.
Average 79 / 100
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
The ask 9%Claims 44%Positioning 30%Reasoning 18%
This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.
Mr. Speaker, The ask · 12 wordsI would once again invite my colleague to read the Canada-Quebec accord.Claims · 43 wordsQuebec controls its economic immigration.1Quebec sets its own thresholds.That is not changing.It will be up to Quebec to decide whether it wishes to take advantage of this one-time measure to grant permanent residence to individuals who are already in Canada.2Positioning · 39 wordsWhat I cannot understand is how the Conservatives can use this rhetoric while also writing to the government to request more temporary foreign workers, even as some of their own colleagues are calling for that program to be abolished.34PositioningOff pointClaims · 14 wordsQuebec will need 80,000 construction workers over the next five years to build Quebec.5Reasoning · 23 wordsWe are well aware of those labour needs, and I am confident that the Government of Quebec is aware of them as well.Partly on point