Analysis · Floor speech · beta

Melissa Lantsman

1573 words · 103 sentences · 128 clauses

Statement grade
B+
80 / 100, held down by Signal
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Procedure 4%Anecdote 18%Positioning 14%Claims 56%Reasoning 5%Aside 0%The ask 1%Promise 1%

This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.

Madam Speaker, Procedure · 14 wordsI am going to split my time with the hon. member for Kildonan—St. Paul.Procedure Anecdote · 206 wordsMembers of Parliament spend a lot of time on the road, and sometimes there is a spare moment here and there at an airport or in an Uber or when grabbing dinner. When that happens, like most people, most normal people, I find myself mindlessly scrolling through Instagram, because members of Parliament are normal people too. There is this guy who came across my feed. His name is Dave Ramsey. He keeps coming up on my feed. Members might have heard of him or might have seen him. He is a radio host who gives financial advice to random people who call in to his show. The calls normally go something like this. The person says they live paycheque to paycheque and have a boatload of debt, but they just got a big inheritance from this rich uncle of theirs who died. Dave nods along, because he sees where this is going. Then the caller says they are thinking they should buy a Ferrari. This makes for good entertainment, because we see the look on Dave’s face at the utter foolishness of this person who wants to blow their inheritance on a fancy car, when obviously they should be using it to pay down their debt.Anecdote Positioning · 37 wordsI think I should call in to the show next time and tell them about this place called Canada, a state of successive Liberal budgets that over and over again blow the inheritance on a fancy car.Positioning Claims · 135 wordsThe government just did that. It just came into a bunch of money, $158 billion more than expected this spring.1 The inheritance came from a rich uncle named higher oil prices and higher inflation. The Liberals just told us here in this budget they tabled in the House less than two weeks ago that they are going to spend 96% of that entire windfall.2 This means 96¢ of every single dollar will go towards buying a new bright red Ferrari complete with all of the bells and whistles instead of doing the responsible thing Dave would tell us to do, which is pay down some of that debt. Had they banked that windfall, the deficits over the next five years would have been cut roughly in half, from about $289 billion to about $137 billion.3 Positioning · 5 wordsThese are still eye-popping numbers.Positioning Claims · 8 wordsInstead, they came down by just $7 billion.4 Procedure · 8 wordsI will tell the House why this matters.Procedure Claims · 43 wordsThe Prime Minister likes to present himself as a careful steward of the public purse. I think that is why Canadians elected him. He is a former central banker, a numbers man, but the numbers in the budget tell a very different story. Positioning · 16 wordsThis is not a budget of a fiscal conservative, despite what he wants us to think.Positioning Claims · 38 wordsThis is his second budget, 5and he cannot blame a minority Parliament anymore. He has the majority.6 He has a free hand and he can use it to borrow and spend more, which is exactly what he did. Positioning · 32 wordsAll of those who are watching this from Bay Street who thought maybe he was a fiscal conservative, maybe he was a responsible manager of the purse, are seeing right through this.Positioning Claims · 64 wordsThe deficit this year is $62.3 billion with no return to balance anywhere even in a plan, not next year and not even by the end of the decade.7 Even that number flatters the government. More and more spending is being moved off the main books into Crown corporations and into funds. This includes a $25-billion sovereign wealth fund funded entirely by borrowed money.8 Positioning · 27 wordsIt is like a family telling the bank that the budget is balanced while starting a secret renovation on a credit card that is from another bank.Positioning Claims · 46 wordsThis is what is going on in Canada and that is why Ottawa will borrow $765 billion in new cash over the next five years.9 The Parliamentary Budget Officer said that today.10 Net debt will rise from $1.45 trillion this year to $1.92 trillion by 2031.11 Reasoning · 18 wordsThis is important because debt is not free. Until we pay it back, we pay interest on it. Claims · 20 wordsLast year, that interest bill was $53.5 billion and by 2031, it will be $85.5 billion, an increase of 60%.12 Procedure · 7 wordsLet me put that in human terms.Procedure Claims · 107 wordsBy the end of this plan, Ottawa will spend more than $5,000 a year for every household in Canada on interest, 13and that total is going up to $8,000 a year by 2031. That is a couple of months’ worth of rent. That is a new furnace. That is a whole year of RESP contributions for a family. It could have paid for hospitals, it could have paid for schools, and it could have paid for equipment for the armed forces, but it did not. It just pays for interest. It is the fastest-growing line item in the budget. Instead, it goes to bondholders and buys nothing. Procedure · 16 wordsHere is a fact that every Canadian should know about when they look at this budget.Procedure Claims · 130 wordsStarting this year, Ottawa will spend more on interest than it sends to the provinces in the Canada health transfer.14 That means that a Canadian family spends more on the interest on the debt than the government spends on providing health care for Canadians across the country. Today, about 10¢ of every federal revenue dollar goes to interest.15 By 2031, the same date I have been talking about, it will be almost 14¢.16 Interest on the debt is the fastest-growing line item within the budget.17 It is growing faster than health care, faster than transfers to the provinces for anything else and faster than any program that the government puts forward. It is not health care, it is not seniors and it is not defence. These are not my numbers. Procedure · 8 wordsThat is what I want everyone to know.Procedure Claims · 23 wordsThese are the numbers right from the Liberal budget that was presented in this House.18 People will probably remember the name David Dodge. Aside · 7 wordsI am sure the Prime Minister does.Aside Claims · 73 wordsHe is a former Governor of the Bank of Canada, just like the Prime Minister.19 He warned us that once debt servicing, 20which is the money that we pay down on the debt, passes 10¢ on the dollar, the debt becomes unsustainable, and borrowing gets too expensive. The Prime Minister is now taking us to 14¢ on the dollar. That is 40% past the benchmark that his predecessor at the Bank talked about. Reasoning · 9 wordsWe know the budget is a statement of priorities. Procedure · 3 wordsWe get that.Procedure Positioning · 24 wordsWe just do not see that Canadians were prioritized in this budget. It shows Canadians what the Canadian government values when choices get hard.Positioning Claims · 20 wordsThe government’s priorities seem to be very clear in this budget: more spending, more borrowing and more debt for Canadians. Positioning · 7 wordsCanadians are living with very different priorities.Positioning Claims · 30 wordsGrocery bills are higher. Rent is still climbing in most cities in this country. Families are reviewing their mortgages and are facing bigger payments, while interest rates continue to climb. Positioning · 14 wordsCanadians, every day in their homes, are doing exactly what the government will not.Positioning Claims · 10 wordsThey are making hard choices and living within their means. The ask · 13 wordsAll we are asking is for the government to do the same thing. Claims · 63 wordsWhen families are stretched thin, the last thing they need is a government adding billions more in borrowing, which puts more pressure on prices, on interest rates and eventually on mortgage renewals. The government’s main answer on affordability is a modest grocery rebate.21 That is a drop in the bucket next to a paycheque that stopped covering those essentials a long time ago. Procedure · 5 wordsHere is the bottom line: ProcedurePositioning · 66 wordsIf Canadians are trying to make ends meet in this country, if they are trying to fill their tanks to get to work, if they are trying to save a little to get ahead or take a small vacation once every year or once every couple of years, this budget is not for them. It is for the government. There is nothing in here for Canadians.Positioning Claims · 60 wordsCanadians’ tax dollars go to interest instead of to the services that they rely on. Maybe that does not mean anything to them today, but it will certainly mean something to them tomorrow, the day after and for a generation into the future, when our grandchildren and our children will pay for these decisions that they had no say in. Anecdote · 77 wordsI started with Dave Ramsey, the guy whose videos I had been scrolling through, and I will end with him. When a caller asks about the Ferrari, Dave does not laugh for long. He knows that the car loses value the minute it leaves the lot. While debt and interest keep growing, his advice never changes. He says to use the windfall to get out of debt and get one’s house in order in case something happens.Anecdote Reasoning · 24 wordsThis is not an ideology. It is the responsible thing for governments to do. Canadian families do it at their kitchen tables every day. Claims · 15 wordsThe government got an inheritance. It got a windfall, and it spent the whole pie. Reasoning · 29 wordsIf the Prime Minister called that show, Dave would tell him the exact same thing: Do not buy the car. Pay down the debt. Do it for future generations. Promise · 9 wordsFor those reasons, I am voting against this budget, 22The ask · 7 wordsand I hope members opposite will too.

Analysed on