Analysis · Debate reply · beta

Melissa Lantsman

169 words · 7 sentences · 10 clauses

Replying to Alexis Brunelle-Duceppe (Bloc Québécois)
“Madam Speaker, I really loved my colleague’s last answer. She is absolutely right. There is a significant difference between what the Liberals call an investment and what is, in reality, spending. She is correct on that point, and the Parliamentary Budget Officer has said as much. Once again, her response was both accurate and on point. There is another issue on which I suspect my colleague and I may agree, because her leader has spoken about it repeatedly. He calls it corporate welfare. The government continues to provide subsidies to industries that do not need the money. I am referring to the oil and gas industry. We are talking about an industry that is posting record profits, that is one of the few sectors largely unaffected by tariffs, that is 60% American-owned and that sells 90% of its products to the United States. However, it is the economic sector that receives the most support from this government, financed by the tax dollars of Canadians and Quebeckers. Would my colleague not agree that these subsidies should be scrapped and the money should be returned to Quebeckers and Canadians?”
Statement grade
C
61 / 100, held down by Relevance
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Positioning 20%Procedure 4%Reasoning 50%Claims 25%

This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.

Madam Speaker, Positioning · 22 wordsI love the sound of the Bloc Québécois finally agreeing that corporate welfare in this country needs to come to an end, PositioningPartly on pointProcedure · 7 wordsbut there is a bigger problem here.Procedure Reasoning · 59 wordsWhen the government has all the cash, when private capital is not put to work here and when companies do not see an investment climate that they can invest in, the government ends up with all of the money. The problem is that industries rely on those handouts before the government ever criticizes or speaks out against an industry.Partly on point Claims · 37 wordsThe government House leader stood here and talked about $500 billion coming into an investment summit.1 Today, this Parliamentary Budget Officer and the Liberals’ own budget say that none of that is attached to a single project.2Off point Reasoning · 26 wordsThe problem with getting investment is that we have to have a project or we have to have an item that the investment can go to, Claims · 6 wordsand none of that is clear.Partly on point Positioning · 12 wordsThis is all smoke and mirrors, and soon Canadians will realize that.PositioningOff pointUnearned certainty

Analysed on