Analysis · Reply to a comment · beta

Raquel Dancho

215 words · 10 sentences · 13 clauses

Replying to Kevin Lamoureux (Liberal)
“Madam Speaker, if that is the reason the member is voting against the budget, she needs to revisit her position. I cannot believe just how inaccurate the member was on so many accounts. We can talk about emergency services. Victoria General Hospital in Manitoba is getting a new emergency room. It is in today’s NDP throne speech in Manitoba. There is going to be more emergency work done in the province of Manitoba. CancerCare Manitoba is getting an infusion of capital for its new facility. I do not know where the member is getting her numbers about the mammograms she talked about. They are so out of whack. There would be an overall 5% increase to health care transfers, plus $5 billion over three years for capital investment from Ottawa. The member needs to read the section in the budget on health care, see what the Government of Canada plans to do and then maybe reconsider the way she votes on the budget.”
Statement grade
B+
Average 84 / 100
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
The ask 22%Claims 47%Positioning 28%Anecdote 3%

This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.

Madam Speaker, The ask · 21 wordsI recommend that the member meet with Breast Cancer Canada, the foremost advocacy group in the country for fighting breast cancer, Claims · 29 wordswhich is the number one cancer facing women. There was testimony at the health committee that not one single jurisdiction in the entire country is meeting the seven-week benchmark, Positioning · 13 wordswhich is still a long time, by the way, for the initial diagnosis.Positioning Anecdote · 6 wordsI have personal experience with this.Anecdote Claims · 64 wordsI can attest that the wait times in Manitoba are absolutely dismal for that initial diagnostic test. I have talked to thousands of Canadians and organizations over the last number of months in this role. I can confidently tell the member that no place in Canada is meeting the benchmarks for the best care possible, not in this country let alone in the world.Unearned certainty Positioning · 24 wordsWhat the parliamentary secretary is saying is wholly inaccurate, based on the experts whose job it is to advocate for saving lives in Canada.Positioning The ask · 26 wordsI would ask him to take a look at the ER at HSC and at the first nations men who have passed away waiting for care. Positioning · 18 wordsI can go on all day about the failures in Manitoba and in every province of this country.Positioning Claims · 9 wordsHe says that the budget would fix these problems, Positioning · 5 wordsbut this is blatantly untrue.Positioning

Analysed on