Analysis · Floor speech · beta

Leah Gazan

444 words · 17 sentences · 20 clauses

Statement grade
A+
Average 97 / 100
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Claims 75%Reasoning 14%Positioning 4%The ask 7%

This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.

Mr. Speaker, Claims · 73 wordsthe afternoon before the Liberals shot down my bill, Bill C-247, to uphold the right to strike and repeal their strike-breaking tool, section 107, I asked the Minister of Transport whether the Liberals would finally stand with workers and stop the unconstitutional attacks on their rights.1 The Minister of Transport replied by saying the quiet part out loud, that through the Liberals’ Bill C-39, “We want to make those strikes all too rare.”2 Reasoning · 25 wordsThe Liberals do not want to do it by doing it the proper way. They want to do it by violating the right to strike. Claims · 76 wordsIt is true that the government is continuing to attack workers’ rights, Unearned certaintyas well as indigenous rights and the right to a clean, safe environment through this fast-tracked bill, Bill C-39. The bill takes even further the government’s unconstitutional powers in section 107, which has been used nine times, in fact, in just three years to violate workers’ right to strike.3 This right is protected by the Charter of Rights and Freedoms and by international law.4 Reasoning · 21 wordsIt is workers’ tried-and-true method of bringing home a fair livable wage when corporate bosses fail to bargain in good faith. Claims · 71 wordsLet us not forget the Liberals have aided and abetted corporate bosses, like those at Air Canada, forcing people back to work after only 12 hours of being on the picket line.5 In fact, today I met with representatives of the Canadian Labour Congress, whose foremost priority was protecting the right to strike from ongoing Liberal attacks.6 They are clear that they will not allow these attacks on workers to continue. Reasoning · 16 wordsIf we want to get workers working, then we have to uphold workers’ right to strike. Claims · 102 wordsMake no mistake, labour leaders like Marty Warren have made it very clear that they will not sit idly by while the government threatens their charter rights.7 Meanwhile, the government has totally sold out workers by giving its blessing to Trump’s deindustrialization of Canada through the sale of Brampton’s Stellantis plant, all the while misleading the public that the government is opposed to the deal.8 While the NDP leader, Avi Lewis, stood yesterday with Unifor workers in Brampton supporting their call to reverse the sale, the Liberal government continues to stand by and do nothing while workers’ livelihoods are placed in jeopardy.9 Positioning · 18 wordsThat is another example of how its true allegiance is with its corporate buddies and the billionaire class.Positioning The ask · 31 wordsThere is still time for the government to reverse course and stop its attacks on workers, including by withdrawing the unconstitutional restrictions on the right to strike contained in Bill C-39, Claims · 11 wordswhich is being studied and fast-tracked through committee as we speak.10

Analysed on