Analysis · Debate reply · beta

Leslie Church

402 words · 20 sentences · 22 clauses

Replying to William Stevenson (Conservative)
“Mr. Speaker, in October, I raised an important issue during question period: the Liberal government’s decision to cut the search and rescue dog program in Banff National Park. I asked a straightforward question about why the government is cutting a 55-year-old program that helps save lives in our national parks. What was the response from the parliamentary secretary? Not once did he mention the rescue dog program. Not once did he address the concerns about visitor safety. Not once did he explain why Parks Canada is eliminating a proven program that has helped find missing people for more than five decades. Canadians deserve answers. Let us look at what the program actually does. The last rescue dog, Leroy, located 57 people over seven years. These dogs can cover terrain up to 50 times faster than human rescuers can. That is not an unnecessary expense. That is a life-saving resource, and this is not just about one dog or one program. It is about the safety of thousands of Canadians and visitors who enjoy our national parks every year. I launched a petition calling on the government to reverse this decision and protect the Banff search and rescue dog program. Canadians from across the country have responded. More than 12,000 people signed the petition to do the right thing. These are people who understand the value of the program and want to see it protected. When I posted my question and the government’s responses, the video received hundreds of comments, including the following ones. Mark said that this is politics summed up right there: When someone brings up in the question something that is important to people, it is followed by a completely pointless non-answer. William wrote that I should keep asking, because people need an answer and we need to keep the program going. He said the parks are getting busier and there are more rescues, so as many people and dogs as possible are needed. Ross asked about the 3,000 Parks Canada staff who received termination notices. He says that making people pay to go to the parks this summer would have paid for a lot of programs and staff. The mayor of Banff has raised concerns about the government’s approach to our national parks. Bringing back free national park admission while cutting essential services is completely “tone deaf”, to use her words. Parks Canada is also facing another round of workforce reductions, with approximately 500 full-time positions expected to be eliminated. These cuts could affect approximately 17% of park wardens, who are on the front lines. They protect visitors, enforce the law and respond to emergencies. At the same time, Parks Canada has spent approximately $400,000 on catering and $2 million in bonuses. How does that make sense? How can the government justify cutting frontline staff and proven life-saving programs while millions of dollars are being spent on bonuses? For the third time, the Liberal government is offering free admission to national parks through its Canada strong pass to everyone, including international visitors. I want Canadians to enjoy the national parks, as they are the most beautiful places in the world, but we have to be honest about the cost. More visitors, fewer staff, fewer wardens and fewer search and rescue resources is not a responsible plan. Responsible spending does not mean cutting the very people and programs that keep Canadians safe, and the government needs to get its priorities straight. We need to protect the search and rescue dog program in Banff National Park, and we need to protect frontline Parks Canada employees and park wardens. We need to properly fund the services that keep our national parks safe. Will the government finally listen, reverse these cuts and commit to protecting the people and programs that keep our national parks safe?”
Statement grade
B+
Average 82 / 100
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Claims 69%Anecdote 13%Thanks 8%Promise 9%

This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.

Mr. Speaker, Claims · 47 wordsvisitor safety remains at the heart of Parks Canada’s work. Its capacity to respond promptly to emergencies, conduct search and rescue, and help visitors in distress remains strong. Every day, visitor safety specialists, dispatchers, park wardens and operational teams help people enjoy our parks safely and confidently. Anecdote · 28 wordsI want to share that I hold Banff National Park in a very special place and have visited it on many occasions over the decades with my family.1Anecdote Claims · 13 wordsJust this summer, we hiked in Waterton Lakes National Park in southern Alberta.2 Anecdote · 26 wordsWe have hit the slopes in Jasper National Park. It has been a highlight of my life to have biked the highway between Jasper and Banff.3Anecdote Claims · 61 wordsWe want future generations to enjoy exploring Canada in these ways too.Partly on point That is why budget 2026 proposes $3.6 billion over 10 years, beginning in 2027-28, to preserve infrastructure in national parks, historic sites and marine conservation areas.4 This builds on the $520 million announced this summer to help rebuild Jasper National Park following the devastating wildfire a few years ago.5 Thanks · 33 wordsI also very much want to recognize our rescue dogs and their handlers. Their work has mattered to people and families in some of their most difficult moments, and they deserve our gratitude.Thanks Claims · 156 wordsMy understanding is that at the time of Parks Canada’s decision in this respect, there was one dog and one handler position in Banff National Park and its approach is intended to focus internal resources on core responsibilities and the highest needs and risks.6 Parks Canada continues to invest in trained personnel, specialized equipment and emergency response protocols. Established partnerships with external organizations and specialized providers, including dog handling, will continue. These partnerships have already delivered effective responses and helped meet specialized needs. I would also point out that Public Safety Canada’s heavy urban search and rescue program continues to fund specialized task forces trained to handle emergency scenarios in a variety of different ways, including the use of canine search.7 Budget 2026 invests $2.5 billion in wildfire response capacity and equipment.8 It also invests $7.8 million to support first nations with wildfire protection and an additional $7 million for the first nations fire protection strategy.9Partly on point Promise · 38 wordsCanadians can count on our continued commitment to visitor safety in our parks, effective emergency response and ensuring that a whole new generation of Canadians can experience the wonder of Canada’s geography from coast to coast to coast.Vague promise

Analysed on