Analysis · Floor speech · beta

Mario Simard

1249 words · 75 sentences · 86 clauses

Statement grade
A
Average 93 / 100
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Procedure 3%Positioning 3%Claims 91%Anecdote 4%

This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.

Mr. Speaker, Procedure · 32 wordsfirst of all, I wish to inform you that I will be sharing my time with the always radiant member for Calgary Nose Hill. I am going to speak to health transfers.Procedure Positioning · 15 wordsI am no naysayer. I am capable of admitting that the budget contains some positives.Positioning Claims · 239 wordsBefore I get to the health transfers, I will point out that the budget includes a fairly significant amount for the forestry industry. We will see what the terms will be and how it will be rolled out.Vague promise The government announced $6.5 billion for its forestry industry strategy following the recommendations made by the task force, though it recommended $10 billion over 10 years.1 The $6.5 billion is a step in the right direction, but I would like to make one comment. I had a conversation with the Minister responsible for Canada-U.S. Trade in committee yesterday. He seemed flabbergasted to learn that $12 billion is sitting in trust funds at the US border right now and that people in the forestry sector could really use that money, 10which has been accumulating since 2017. The softwood lumber dispute has been going on since 2017.18 The government has not lifted a finger. Instead, in response to the trade war that is happening, the government has made massive investments in oil and gas infrastructure, even though that is the only sector that is not subject to tariffs.19 I will repeat what I have been saying for far too long now. That is the only sector that is not subject to tariffs, 91% of our exports go primarily to the United States, 11and 60% of the ownership structure of the major oil companies is American-owned.12 I explained all that to the minister yesterday. Anecdote · 46 wordsIf investing in a sector that will benefit U.S. energy security and the U.S. economy is not colonization, then I wonder what it actually means to be colonized. That is what we say back home in Saguenay—Lac-Saint-Jean about someone who is blind to their own interests.Anecdote Claims · 882 wordsThat is just a little observation. I want to return to the issue of health transfers. Health transfers are a source of tension in the federation. Year after year, when people are asked about their top priorities, whether in Quebec or elsewhere in the country, health care consistently ranks first. However, for many years now, the federal government has failed to meet its responsibilities when it comes to health transfers. In Quebec, roughly 42% of the total provincial budget is devoted to health care.13 What does that mean? It means that only about 57% or 58% of the Quebec government’s budget is left for other core responsibilities such as education, poverty reduction, infrastructure, road construction, support for municipalities and support for Quebec’s economic development.14 In other words, 42% of the total budget is eaten up because the federal government is not fulfilling its role in health transfers. I would like to point out that, when Canada first established a public health care system, for every $1 invested in health care, 50¢ came from the federal government and 50¢ came from Quebec or the provinces.2 Between the 1960s and the present day, health care funding has deteriorated significantly. Let me recap what happened. It is very important to know the background, because this budget is a continuation of a trend. Those who are a bit older, like the government’s parliamentary secretary, may recall that infamous period in the 1980s and 1990s, when the Mulroney government made successive cuts to health transfers.3 That was the first decline we saw, but the undisputed champion of cuts to health care transfers is Paul Martin. After the referendum, in 1996-97 and 1997-98, the Quebec government faced recurring $2-billion cuts to federal health transfers.4 As a result, every Quebec health minister since then has struggled in that role, because they have had to make do with fewer resources. Demand for health care is constantly rising, and they have had to make do with a system that is unable to secure sufficient resources to meet needs. That is why the so-called shift to ambulatory care happened. Who paid the price for that? Well, at the time, it was Mr. Bouchard. He was portrayed as a proponent of a narrow-minded, hidebound economic liberalism, despite the fact that it was Paul Martin who was really to blame. To top it all off, around the same time, Prime Minister Chrétien went to the G7 and told his counterparts the secret to his success. He said that the federal government could slash transfer payments to the provinces without looking like the bad guy because the public would believe that the provincial premiers and provincial health ministers were the ones not doing their job. I have to hand it to Jean Chrétien. He was honest. He himself said that when transfer payments are cut, the usual mechanism of political accountability does not apply. The federal government is doing that again in this budget.5 It is making frivolous announcements, like the return of Heritage Minutes. It is also planning huge celebrations for Canada Day next year.20 It is spending a lot of money on frills while trying to reduce the deficit and balance the books by cutting transfer payments. To me, quite frankly, that is outrageous. I want to talk about this troubling dynamic because, although the federal government does not get blamed when it cuts transfer payments, the provinces do. I mentioned two periods in particular, under Prime Minister Mulroney and under Prime Minister Martin, but we are seeing the same pattern repeat itself today. Why? It is because the federal share of health care funding continues to fall.15 The major issue is that the rising costs of the health care system are having an impact. We are no longer in the world of the 1980s, the 1990s or even the early 2000s. There are related pressures that are placing an enormous strain on health care systems. We have an aging population, which places a tremendous burden on public services. Plus, the cost of medications continues to rise sharply. New pharmaceutical technologies are being developed and, at the same time, there are new treatment and care options. On top of that, new avenues are opening up in health care. That is why health care spending is constantly rising across Canada. However, the federal government continues to follow the same approach: It balances its books by reducing transfer payments and leaving the provinces to suffer. Under the Harper government, a consensus had already been reached on a 3% escalator to try to cover the system’s costs.6 Members will recall the last negotiation on health care transfers, when the united front quickly broke down and Ontario decided to go its own way.7 In the end, the agreement did not live up to everyone’s expectations. The one positive thing was that the health care transfer escalator was set between 5% and 6% for a time.8 That was still not too bad. However, budget 2026 states that the federal government has decided to set the escalator at 3% starting next year.9 What does that mean for Quebec? It means a loss of at least $3 billion annually.16 Over five years, forecasts show that Quebec will likely chalk up a $14-billion shortfall as health care costs continue to climb.17 Positioning · 19 wordsConsidering all the money the government is investing to support the gas and oil sector, this is completely appalling.Positioning Claims · 16 wordsHowever, there is a solution—this is how I end all my speeches—and it is called independence.Vague promise

Analysed on