This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.
Mr. Speaker, Procedure · 10 wordswe are here debating budgetary policy and this year’s budget.Procedure Claims · 182 wordsEvery year, the federal government is supposed to table something called the immigration levels plan.1 This is a document, required by law, which sets out how many people the government is going to allow into the country in coming years. Instead of tabling a separate document for parliamentarians to peruse, look through and really dive into to understand whether or not the numbers are sustainable, the government buried this document in the budget. It is actually in the budget this year, 2but the day after the budget came out, the Liberals tabled some very fine print, 3which showed the highest levels of permanent resident admission in Canadian history.4 At a time when the vast majority of Canadians are feeling that the government has let too many people into the country too fast for housing, health care and jobs to keep up, and at a time when many newcomers themselves are falling behind in the country or are in precarious circumstances, the government, instead of lowering levels, snuck the numbers into this budget and increased them to the highest levels in Canadian history. Positioning · 5 wordsWhy is this a problem?Positioning Claims · 25 wordsSome public data released this morning showed that, I believe, over 60% of Liberal voters themselves opposed the levels that were set in the budget, 5Reasoning · 7 wordsand it is because of these issues. Procedure · 4 wordsThe first is housing.Procedure Claims · 81 wordsHaving high immigration levels set such that the housing supply cannot keep up with the demand created by the levels that the Prime Minister is setting is good for only one group of people. It is good for corporate landlords like Brookfield, the Prime Minister’s former company. Rents go up when there is less housing and more people. When rents go up, people think that maybe they should try and buy a house, because they are paying so much in rent. Positioning · 4 wordsWhere do they go?Positioning Claims · 22 wordsThey go to Brookfield’s subdivisions, and if they need to have mortgage insurance, they go to one of Brookfield’s mortgage insurance companies. Positioning · 11 wordsWho benefits from scarcity in housing because of high immigration levels?Positioning Claims · 14 wordsIt is rich corporations like the one the Prime Minister used to work for. Positioning · 4 wordsWho does not benefit?Positioning Anecdote · 97 wordsLet us imagine a student in a foreign country who wants to come to Canada to build a better life. Their parents have saved up their life savings to send them to Canada to go to school. They end up in Brampton, paying an exorbitant amount of money or responding to ads on Kijiji that are asking for sexual services in exchange for rent, to live 10 deep in a basement suite. They cannot find a job, and the college their parents sent their life savings to is a scam college that is essentially profiting from them.Anecdote Reasoning · 10 wordsThose are the people who have had their promises broken. Claims · 52 wordsOn one hand, we have corporate landlords like Brookfield, benefiting from high rents. On the other hand, we have newcomers to Canada who are being scammed and abused and having the promise of being able to build a better life in this country completely eviscerated. That is what is in this budget, Positioning · 4 wordsand that is disgusting.Positioning Reasoning · 28 wordsThere should be no world in which immigration levels are set such that the people who are coming to this country are treated as units of corporate profit, Claims · 28 wordsand that is what we are seeing with these levels. There is not enough housing in the country to house the levels of people included in this budget. Procedure · 5 wordsThat is just the reality.ProcedureUnearned certainty Claims · 14 wordsThe Prime Minister has not answered the question of where these people will live. Positioning · 23 wordsThat is not fair to anybody. It is not fair to the newcomer who is coming to Canada to build a better life, PositioningClaims · 26 wordsand it is not fair to people who are already here, who cannot afford housing and therefore cannot afford to build a family of their own. Reasoning · 10 wordsThat is why the levels need to come way down, Claims · 17 wordsand that is why the levels set in this budget, the highest levels in history, are unconscionable. Procedure · 6 wordsHowever, it is not just housing.Procedure Claims · 64 wordsIt is also wage suppression. Every day, there is a corporate lobby group. In fact, I would be shocked if there was not one right now on Parliament Hill, lobbying for higher levels of immigration. These powerful corporate lobbyists come, and they talk to everybody in this place and give these lies. They say there are no Canadians who want to do these jobs. Positioning · 11 wordsWell, that is baloney. There is a stronger word for that.Positioning Claims · 34 wordsWe have a youth unemployment crisis in this country. We have a first entry-level job crisis in this country. We have corporate lobby groups that are coming here to say we need more immigration, Positioning · 84 wordsbecause they want to give the promise of Canada to a newcomer. They do not want people coming to Canada, finding a good-paying job and a decent place to live to build a better life for themselves and their family, like so many immigrants who have built this country have done. What they want is for immigrants to this country to be indentured to their company so they do not have to train people who are already here and so they can suppress wages, PositioningClaims · 14 wordsbecause if there are too many people for the jobs available, wages go down. Positioning · 31 wordsIf we scratch the surface of any corporate lobbyist who comes to this place to ask for more immigration, for the most part, it is for one of these three things.Positioning Claims · 64 wordsNumber one, their business model, their profit model, is based on suppressing wages through high immigration rates. The second thing is that they are not invested in skills training. There are so many youth in Canada who are underemployed or unemployed, who probably just need a bit more training or a place to be trained in an entry-level job in order to get ahead. Reasoning · 5 wordsThey just need that chance, Positioning · 20 wordsbut those corporations do not want that. The last thing is that they do not want to invest in productivity.Positioning Procedure · 6 wordsIt is not me saying this.Procedure Claims · 19 wordsThese are major economists. The Bank of Canada is saying that immigration rates that are too high suppress wages.6 Procedure · 24 wordsLet us think about how much it now costs, how many multiples of an annual salary it costs to buy a house in Canada.Procedure Claims · 28 wordsThat multiple has increased exponentially over the last several years, because we have brought too many people into this country too fast for social infrastructure to keep up. Positioning · 77 wordsThat is breaking a sacred promise, not only to Canadians who are already here, but to immigrants who were told that when we say welcome to Canada, it means welcome to Canada, that there is a job for them, that there is affordable housing for them, and, the third thing, that there is health care for them. The corporate lobbyists who come in and ask for higher levels of immigration are not looking at diagnostic imaging waits.Positioning Claims · 22 wordsThey are not looking at the 33-year-old man in Alberta who died in an emergency room earlier this year due to “overcrowding”. Positioning · 25 wordsNo, they do not care about that. Where are these people going to get surgery? What CT scan are they going to be scanned in?Positioning Reasoning · 24 wordsPeople who come to Canada deserve access to quality health care in a timely way, and so do the people who are already here. Claims · 23 wordsOftentimes, I think of newcomers who are in Canada who might be waiting for the same bed as somebody who is already here. Reasoning · 19 wordsIt is not the fault of the newcomer. It is not the fault of somebody who is already here. Positioning · 15 wordsIt is squarely the fault of the Prime Minister, who has set levels too high.Positioning Claims · 5 wordsImmigrants have built this country. Positioning · 3 wordsWe support immigration.Positioning Reasoning · 17 wordsIt has to be set in a way that people can come to Canada and successfully integrate. Procedure · 5 wordsI want to say this: ProcedurePositioning · 11 wordsIt is actually the Liberal government that does not support immigration, PositioningReasoning · 51 wordsbecause if it did, it would not be setting the levels so high that it is dooming newcomers to failure, that it is dooming newcomers to an environment of social tension created with scarcity that has been created by a lack of housing, health care and jobs, and by wage suppression. Positioning · 3 wordsThat is wrong.Positioning Claims · 23 wordsThe levels that are in here are way too high. It is about a city the size of Winnipeg in permanent residents alone. Positioning · 27 wordsWhere are they going to live? Where are they going to get health care? What jobs are they going to have? How are wages going to grow?Positioning Reasoning · 30 wordsIf the government is not going to answer these questions, then it is dooming a whole generation of Canadians and newcomers to failure. That is not the promise of Canada. Promise · 10 wordsThat is why we are going to fight against this.Vague promise Reasoning · 8 wordsThat is why levels need to be lower. Claims · 17 wordsThat is why Conservatives have put forward a whole swath of policies to reform the immigration system, Reasoning · 12 wordsbut the first thing we need to do is reduce the levels.
Analysed on