This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.
Mr. Speaker, Claims · 10 wordsimmigration is a hot-button issue. It is a polarizing issue.Partly on point Procedure · 14 wordsToday, we are debating a bill to designate a specific month as immigration month.Procedure Claims · 6 wordsThe Bloc Québécois supports this bill, Procedure · 21 wordsbut I see it as an opportunity to share certain facts that will help people draw their own conclusions about immigration.Procedure Claims · 9 wordsIn recent years, immigration levels have been very high.Partly on point Procedure · 28 wordsHowever, before we look at the numbers and the new statistics, let us first examine Canada’s total population, followed by Quebec’s, in order to put things in context.Procedure Claims · 94 wordsWhat we are seeing is that Canada’s population grew very little between 2025 and 2026. In percentage terms, it was the slowest population growth since 1915.1 The situation in Quebec is much the same. According to figures released in the spring of 2026, Quebec’s population declined slightly in 2025, 2although it had grown significantly, at an exceptional rate, from 2022 to 2024 because of uncontrolled immigration policies. Looking at the overall population in both Canada and Quebec, what we see at present is a slight decline, or at least a stabilization of population growth.Partly on point Procedure · 18 wordsAnother interesting point to consider before we discuss immigration targets is what is actually happening on the ground.Procedure Claims · 30 wordsIt has received relatively little attention, but the day after the budget, on November 6, the government tabled its annual report to Parliament on immigration levels for the previous year.3 Reasoning · 12 wordsThat report matters because it provides a clearer picture of the reality.Partly on point Procedure · 4 wordsWhat does it show?Procedure Claims · 38 wordsIn 2025, the federal government had set a target of 367,000 temporary foreign workers and just over 300,000 international students, for a total of approximately 673,000 temporary residents in Canada for 2025.4 However, those targets were not met, Partly on pointProcedure · 10 wordsand I think that is worth emphasizing and telling people.Procedure Claims · 50 wordsThe government had planned for 367,000 temporary foreign workers, but only 208,000 arrived.5 The gap is even more striking in the case of international students. The target was 305,000, yet only 115,000 students came.6 We can see that, in reality, over the past year, the targets have not been met.Partly on point Procedure · 7 wordsI think that is worth pointing out.Procedure Claims · 56 wordsWhat we are also seeing is a degree of course correction since 2024. Between the beginning of 2024 and the beginning of 2026, the number of new international students decreased by 71%.7 The number of new temporary workers fell by 57%.8 As for asylum claims, they were down 68% compared with the same period in 2024.9Partly on point Procedure · 18 wordsThese are facts that deserve to be mentioned before debating immigration. There is also the issue of migration.Procedure Claims · 66 wordsWith regard to the situation in Quebec, some fairly recent figures have been released. They show the impact of both international and interprovincial migration on Quebec. One interesting observation is that, in 2025, Quebec recorded a net loss in its international migration balance. In other words, 12,000 more people left Quebec for destinations abroad than the number of international immigrants who settled in Quebec that year.10Partly on point Procedure · 22 wordsAnother figure worth watching is the interprovincial migration balance. Are immigrants who first arrive in other Canadian provinces subsequently moving to Quebec?Procedure Claims · 37 wordsThe answer is no. In fact, the opposite is true. More people are leaving Quebec for other Canadian provinces than are moving to Quebec from elsewhere in Canada. The net balance is a loss of 9,000 people.11Partly on point Procedure · 32 wordsI mention all of this simply to put the facts on the table. Now let us turn to what was announced in the budget on November 5.12 I touched on this earlier.Procedure Anecdote · 17 wordsSince I was not at the lock-up, I received a copy of the budget at four o’clock.Anecdote Claims · 48 wordsOn leafing through the document, we come to page 216, concerning the 2027-2029 immigration levels plan. At first, we see that the government’s targets are 370,000 new temporary resident arrivals and 380,000 permanent resident admissions.13 We notice that these are the same targets that were announced last year.Partly on point Procedure · 7 wordsThen we get to the second paragraph, ProcedurePositioning · 5 wordsand things become really unclear.Positioning Claims · 43 wordsIt reads, “Help transition the many longstanding temporary residents to permanent residency. Up to 200,000 temporary residents already in Canada would have the opportunity to become permanent residents by the end of 2027.”14 It states, in the conditional tense, “would have the opportunity”.Partly on point Procedure · 9 wordsWe look at that and wonder what it means.Procedure Positioning · 28 wordsIt makes the people who drafted the budget look bad when readers are left with more questions than answers. It is a sign that it was poorly drafted.PositioningPartly on point Procedure · 3 wordsThe question is: ProcedurePositioning · 4 wordsWas that done deliberately?Positioning Reasoning · 16 wordsThe first point to establish is whether the 200,000 residents mentioned are included in the 380,000.Partly on point Procedure · 6 wordsIt is important to know that.Procedure Reasoning · 29 wordsAre these temporary residents, people who have been here for a long time and who will be offered a pathway to permanent residency? That could be a valid argument. Claims · 77 wordsIn the end, it was by asking questions that we learned that the 200,000 would be added to the total. It was also by asking questions that we learned that there are also 80,000 temporary residents who were planned for last year and who will also be added, for a total of 662,000.15 This is the second year that the government has done this. It sets thresholds, and then adds permanent residents who fall outside those thresholds. Positioning · 6 wordsIt really is a strange concept.Positioning The ask · 14 wordsWe just want the government to give the real figures and explain things properly. Reasoning · 21 wordsThat is really important, because, as I said at the beginning, immigration is a polarizing issue, one that is hotly debated. The ask · 26 wordsIf the government wants to bring in 662,000 permanent residents by the end of 2027, it should say so clearly, take responsibility and defend its position. Claims · 8 wordsPeople will be able to judge for themselves.Partly on point Procedure · 11 wordsWhat impact will the thresholds announced this year have on Quebec?Procedure Claims · 38 wordsIt is important to note that Quebec sets its own permanent immigration thresholds. Quebec just had an election, 16and the Parti Québécois has proposed setting the permanent immigration threshold at 35,000.17 Announcements will be made in that regard. Reasoning · 43 wordsSince Quebec sets its own permanent immigration thresholds, if the Quebec government decides to move forward with the threshold of 35,000, then only 35,000 of the 662,000 new permanent residents will settle in Quebec. The rest will have to settle elsewhere in Canada. Claims · 11 wordsThe programs we are hearing about will be available outside Quebec.Partly on point Procedure · 27 wordsWill temporary residents of Quebec decide to settle outside Quebec to obtain permanent residency? That is something to keep an eye on. However, one thing is certain.Procedure Claims · 14 wordsIf Quebec takes in 35,000 residents, it will be about 5% of the total. Reasoning · 99 wordsOur demographic weight within the Canadian federation would decline as a result. This illustrates the inherent difficulty of managing immigration within the Canadian federation. Either Canada agrees to lower its thresholds to align with Quebec policy—and I do not believe that will happen—or Quebec can become a fully independent country, able to manage immigration itself and make its own decisions rather than be affected by those of the federal government. Given that recent polling shows that Quebec is the most welcoming place in Canada, Quebec’s independence would allow us to better manage immigration and be more successful at it.18Partly on point
Analysed on