Analysis · Speech on a bill · beta

Kevin Lamoureux

693 words · 41 sentences · 53 clauses

Statement grade
A–
85 / 100, held down by Signal
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Procedure 4%Positioning 38%Claims 43%The ask 4%Reasoning 4%Promise 7%

This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.

Mr. Speaker, Procedure · 12 wordsI want to be able to recognize the substance of Bill S-215.Procedure Positioning · 36 wordsRecognizing national immigration month is a positive thing. Having said that, I am discouraged by the comments I have heard from my colleagues in the Conservative Party and the Bloc Party, in particular, the Conservative Party.Positioning Claims · 17 wordsEarlier today, I put a challenge out to the shadow minister for immigration for the Conservative Party. The ask · 9 wordsI hope she takes me up on that challenge, Positioning · 29 wordsbecause I believe there has been a distortion of reality toward the negative side in a certain sector of society that uses and sees immigration as a bad thing.Positioning Claims · 13 wordsIt has raised the level of things like racism, and so much more. Positioning · 11 wordsThere are some within the House who are promoting it, indirectly.Positioning Procedure · 7 wordsLet me give members a tangible example.Procedure Claims · 154 wordsThe Conservative Party of Canada, on numerous occasions, in question period, even this afternoon, has tried to give the impression that there are 600,000-plus immigrants coming to Canada in the next year.1 That is just not true. It is far from reality. The minister herself made reference to the program, and well over 50% are people living in Canada today, most of whom are already employed.2 They are paying taxes. They are already housed. Every week I am talking to individuals, and I have a databank of hundreds of individuals who have been working in the province of Manitoba for two or more years. That is why I like the question the Minister of Immigration threw back today in question period when she asked the member which ones she would like to leave Canada.3 Is it those who have been working here for two or three years, or would it be the Ukrainian settlers? Positioning · 43 wordsIs that who the official opposition wants us to kick out of Canada? To me, it is more about perception and how, as an official opposition, they are trying to get that anti-immigrant feeling pumped to the degree that it is marginally racism, PositioningReasoning · 5 wordsand that hurts us all. Positioning · 4 wordsIt is very short-sighted.Positioning Claims · 17 wordsEarlier today, I sent an invite out to the shadow critic for immigration to come to Winnipeg. Procedure · 6 wordsI will do better than that.Procedure Promise · 24 wordsI will go to Calgary. I will debate this issue in any major city in Canada, ideally Winnipeg, followed by Calgary, then maybe Ottawa. Positioning · 73 wordsI am not scared of the truth. I see the benefits of what is being proposed on the floor of the House of Commons. It is sound. Do members know how many health care workers have been working in a health care field, and who the Conservatives are trying to imply to Canadians are not even here, but in some other land, and the Government of Canada is going to bring them over?Positioning Claims · 17 wordsIn reality, they are working here today, and contributing taxes, in health care, education and different ways. Reasoning · 23 wordsThe point is, when we look at this legislation, we should appreciate the contributions of immigration from the past, today and going forward. Claims · 35 wordsThat is what Bill S-215 would do. Having national immigration month in the month of November, the very month in which we are having second reading on this bill, makes a whole lot of sense.4 Positioning · 68 wordsIt is something we should look at as a treasure. One of the greatest treasures Canada has is our diversity, from first nations to the immigration policies to the immigrants who are coming today and everything in between. That is what has made Canada the greatest country in the world to call home, and we should not be preaching to others that they should be fearful of immigration.Positioning Claims · 33 wordsI can tell members on the opposite side that, in working collaboratively with provinces, I know that Manitoba desperately wants to be able to retain those individuals the Conservatives want to send away. The ask · 22 wordsTalk to the provincial government. Talk to the business council. Talk to the mayors of Winnipeg and Brandon and many other municipalities. Claims · 9 wordsThey see the benefits that we all will have. Promise · 26 wordsI look forward to the bill ultimately passing so that we can, in fact, celebrate the month of November as a month of diversity and immigration.5

Analysed on