Analysis · Speech on a bill · beta

Harb Gill

1644 words · 108 sentences · 133 clauses

Statement grade
A
Average 93 / 100
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Claims 45%Anecdote 9%Procedure 4%Reasoning 24%Positioning 5%Thanks 0%The question 3%The ask 7%Promise 2%

This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.

Mr. Speaker, Claims · 38 wordsas an immigrant, I can tell members that Canada has always been a country of promise, a promise that if someone came here prepared to work, contribute and play by the rules, they could build a better life. Anecdote · 17 wordsI am living proof of that promise. I stand here today because Canada gave me a chance.Anecdote Procedure · 8 wordsThat is why I support national immigration month, ProcedureReasoning · 20 wordsbut it is also why I believe we have a responsibility to make sure that promise is still being kept.Vague promise Anecdote · 55 wordsI left behind my parents, my relatives, my friends and everything familiar to me. I arrived in a new country with no guarantees. I was not looking for a shortcut or special treatment. I was looking for a fair opportunity, and Canada gave me one. I studied here, worked here and raised my family here.Anecdote Claims · 25 wordsI spent nearly three decades working as a cop, 1and today, I have the privilege of representing the people of Windsor West in the House.2 Anecdote · 20 wordsWhen I look back on that journey, I see a country that gave me the opportunity to earn my success, AnecdoteClaims · 9 wordsand I know thousands of Canadians have similar stories. Procedure · 3 wordsLook at Windsor: ProcedureClaims · 98 wordsGenerations of families came from France, Italy, Portugal, Poland, Greece, Vietnam, India, Pakistan, the Caribbean and so many other parts of the world. They worked in our auto plants, built our homes, staffed our hospitals, worked on farms and construction sites, and opened businesses. Many workers worked long hours and overtime, so their children could have opportunities they never had. They may not have had much when they arrived, but they had something powerful, the belief that their children could have a better future here. That is how Windsor was built, and that is how Canada was built. Reasoning · 60 wordsThose generations taught us something important: People do not have to abandon their heritage to belong here. They can celebrate Diwali, Eid, Christmas or Hanukkah. They can speak another language at home and pass their traditions on to their children. They can be proud of where they came from, and they can be equally proud of where they belong now. Procedure · 12 wordsHowever, we also must be honest about the reality facing newcomers today.ProcedureUnearned certainty Positioning · 29 wordsWhat happens when someone sells everything they own, leaves their family behind, spends their savings and travels thousands of miles, believing they are coming to a country of opportunity?Positioning Claims · 50 wordsThey arrive, and they discover they cannot afford a home, their qualifications are not recognized, the job they expected is not there, and rent, groceries and transportation consume almost everything they earn. Many have to work far below their qualifications. Others are exploited by unscrupulous recruiters, immigration consultants and employers. Positioning · 36 wordsImagine someone making the enormous sacrifice, only to discover that the Canada they were promised does not exist. That is not the Canada or the Canadian dream we should be selling. How did we get here?Positioning Claims · 44 wordsFor years, the Liberal government allowed immigration and temporary resident numbers to grow dramatically without ensuring that housing, health care, infrastructure and essential services could keep pace.3 The government seemed to believe that announcing immigration targets was the same as having an immigration plan. Reasoning · 43 wordsIt is not. A target is a number on a government document. A plan means making sure there are homes for people to live in, doctors to look after them, schools for their children and jobs that allow them to support their families. Claims · 56 wordsThe government recklessly increased the numbers, and it failed to manage the consequences. Everyone is paying the price. Young Canadians cannot afford their homes, families are struggling with rent and grocery bills, newcomers are finding housing out of reach, patients are waiting for doctors, and employers need workers while qualified people cannot get their credentials recognized. Procedure · 4 wordsLet me be clear.Procedure Claims · 49 wordsThe newcomer did not create the housing shortage, and the Canadian families struggling to pay rent did not design the immigration system. These people are not each other’s enemies. They want the same things: a safe place to live, a decent job and the opportunity to build a future. Reasoning · 35 wordsThey deserve a government that understands that. We can welcome immigrants and still insist on responsible immigration levels. We can celebrate diversity and still demand accountability. Those positions are not contradictory. They are common sense. Procedure · 10 wordsThere is another part of this discussion we cannot ignore.Procedure Claims · 73 wordsFor the Canadians born and educated here, who join our police services, serve our military and build businesses in this community, this is their home. This is their country, yet I hear from these same people that they are being asked where they are really from or told to go back to a country they do not even know. The hostility they experience today just did not happen 10 or 12 years ago. Reasoning · 53 wordsA Canadian should never have to explain why they belong in Canada. They should never have to produce a family tree to prove that this is their home. Racism and hatred have no place in this country. We must confront them wherever they appear. Political leaders have a responsibility to bring people together. Claims · 25 wordsToo often, the Liberal government has responded to legitimate questions about immigration, housing and population growth by questioning the motives of those asking those questions. Reasoning · 58 wordsWhen people raise concerns about affordability, they deserve answers, not accusations. When communities say that their infrastructure is under pressure, they deserve a plan, not a reprimand. We must never confuse a debate about government policy with an attack on the people who come to Canada. We must never allow the debate to become an excuse for prejudice. Procedure · 11 wordsI want to bring this discussion to a more personal space.Procedure Claims · 7 wordsI spent nearly three decades in policing. Anecdote · 27 wordsI know what it means to put on a uniform, leave one’s family at home and head out the door without knowing what the day will bring.Anecdote Claims · 134 wordsThis year, Canadians have mourned seven police officers who made the ultimate sacrifice in service to their community and their country.4 Among them were OPP officer Tarun Bali, who came to Canada from India as a child, 5and Montreal police officer Mohamed Benredouane, who came to Quebec from Algeria as a teenager.6 We also lost officers Ramandeep Kaur Maan, from India, 7and Nicolae Serban, from Romania.8 They had different beginnings and different journeys but one country and one commitment to service. They put on a uniform, accepted their responsibility and went to work knowing that their duties sometimes meant putting themselves in harm’s way. Tragically, they did not make it home. They were not outsiders. They were not guests. They were Canadians serving Canadians. They were our colleagues, our neighbours, our sons and daughters, Thanks · 3 wordsand our heroes.Thanks Claims · 22 wordsTheir families came here believing in the promise of Canada. Their loved ones helped protect that promise for the rest of us, The question · 56 wordsso I ask the government and every member of the House, are we are keeping faith with them? Are we keeping faith with families who came here believing their children could build a better future? Are we keeping faith with the next generation born and raised here, who should never have to question whether they belong? Claims · 12 wordsThose officers served their country. Their families made sacrifices for this country. Reasoning · 17 wordsThe least we owe them is a country that lives up to the promise they believed in. Procedure · 15 wordsI also want to say something to my colleagues on both sides of the House.Procedure Claims · 8 wordsNo community belongs to any one political party. Reasoning · 16 wordsWe should never take people for granted or assume that someone’s background determines what they believe. Claims · 44 wordsPeople want their children to be safe. They want decent jobs, affordable homes and a government that respects their hard work and spends their tax dollars responsibly. Those are Canadian values. They do not belong to one culture, one faith or one political party. The ask · 50 wordsIf November is going to be national immigration month, let us make it mean something.9 Let us tackle immigration fraud and worker exploitation. Let us address unreasonable processing delays. Let us recognize foreign credentials for nurses, doctors, engineers and tradespeople who can contribute. Let us confront racism wherever it appears. Claims · 48 wordsA commemorative month would not find someone an affordable home. It would not put a family doctor in a community that needs one. It would not protect a vulnerable worker or erase the hurt felt by a young Canadian who has been told they do not belong here. Reasoning · 7 wordsThese things require leadership, accountability and action. Anecdote · 28 wordsWhen I arrived in Canada in 1988, I came on my own with the hope and willingness to work.10 I was fortunate. This country gave me a chance.Anecdote Promise · 41 wordsI want the next person arriving in Canada to have the same opportunity I had, and I want every Canadian, regardless of where their family began, to know that hard work, contribution and commitment still count for something in this country.Vague promise Reasoning · 60 wordsThat is the promise of Canada. A promise is fulfilled not simply by repeating it. It is fulfilled when a young family can afford a home, when a newcomer can put their skills to work, when a child never has to feel like a stranger in their own country and when every Canadian can look to the future with confidence. The ask · 63 wordsLet us honour those who came before us, let us stand with those who are here today, and let us welcome those who want to build their future here. Let us make sure that the promise that brought generations of immigrants to Canada is not simply a memory of what the country once was but a reality for the generations still to come, Reasoning · 33 wordsbecause Canada is not simply a place people come to. It is a promise people come here believing in. Our responsibility is to make sure that promise remains alive for the next generation. Positioning · 12 wordsThat is the Canada worth celebrating. That is the Canada worth defending.Positioning

Analysed on