Analysis · Debate reply · beta

Leslie Church

552 words · 44 sentences · 47 clauses

Replying to Garnett Genuis (Conservative)
“Mr. Speaker, my question tonight relates to the Air Canada strike and a decision made by the Minister of Jobs and Families to use section 107, but more fundamentally, it is a question about integrity. I know it is against our rules in the House to accuse a member of lying, and I would certainly never do that. I want to share some of the context around what happened in this case and allow people to draw their own conclusions about what the Minister of Jobs and Families said. In the context of deciding to use section 107 to end a strike at Air Canada, the minister spoke specifically about the transportation of pharmaceuticals and organ tissue as being a motivator for ending that strike. She said in a written statement, not in an off-the-cuff comment, “This nationwide labour disruption is impeding the movement of passengers and critical cargo.” Later in the statement she wrote, “Further, the shipments of critical goods such as pharmaceuticals and organ tissue, over 40% of which are moved by Air Canada, should continue to reach their destinations.” Blacklock’s, I believe, was the first one to do an ATIP and identify the fact that there were no records within the Government of Canada to verify claims about how the strike was putting at risk the transport of organs and tissue. I repeatedly asked the minister and officials at committee whether they could present the evidence they had relied on to do this. I also asked whether, if they had been told in some meeting that the transport of organs and tissue was at risk, they could share with us who told them that and when the meeting was. I then asked officials whether officials have any record of this meeting, where it took place and which officials were present. Of course, typically officials or staff of some sort would be present for briefings with the minister. No information was provided, in terms of when and where that meeting took place, so I followed up with this again with an Order Paper question, which is Question No. 1407. I asked in various ways what records the government has with regard to the transportation of organs by air and how those shipments are tracked and managed. In response to this question, the government repeatedly affirmed that it did not collect data. It had no data on those things. I then asked in the same question about the meeting or alleged meeting that took place in which the minister received this information. Again, there were no records of that meeting whatsoever and no record of the information. The best that the government could offer is that “the Minister receives a continuous flow of information, analysis, assessments, and advice from a broad range of sources within and outside government.” At best, taking the most charitable view, maybe the minister was, in private and off the cuff, told by somebody that this was a risk associated with the strike, and used that information as the basis for ending the strike, even though she had no evidence whatsoever to support that claim. Perhaps she made it up herself. Perhaps somebody else made it up and said it to her, but this was clearly a statement that was not true, one that the minister has repeatedly made and doubled down on. Speaking of the integrity of the minister, is she or a representative willing to acknowledge that this was not true? At what point, given the clear evidence in this Order Paper question, are we going to have an acknowledgement of that reality?”
Statement grade
B
76 / 100, held down by Relevance
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Positioning 2%Claims 75%Reasoning 22%Promise 1%

This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.

Mr. Speaker, Positioning · 11 wordsI do not accept the member’s characterization of the minister’s actions.Positioning Claims · 57 wordsShe has explained the concerns she was weighing in her responsibility to Canadians. At committee, the minister said she received briefings about disruptions to critical medical supplies.1 In the House, she explained why those concerns mattered. Canadians depend on the movement of essential medicines and medical products, including organs for transplant, within Canada and across our borders. Reasoning · 40 wordsFor someone waiting for treatment, getting those supplies on time matters. That had to be part of the decision. The member is entitled to question the decision. Canadians are also entitled to hear the context in which it was made. Claims · 12 wordsThe government believes in collective bargaining. We respect the right to strike. Reasoning · 17 wordsWe know that a negotiated agreement gives workers and employers the strongest foundation to move forward together. Claims · 207 wordsThat is why federal mediators work alongside the parties to help them find common ground. The vast majority of negotiations in federally regulated workplaces conclude without a work stoppage.2 That reflects the hard work of unions, employers and the people who help them reach agreements. In the Air Canada dispute, negotiations had been under way for eight months.3 Despite extensive support, the parties remained at an impasse.Partly on point The minister had a responsibility to protect Canadians’ access to essential medicines and medical supplies. People depend on those deliveries for their care. Those needs could not be set aside. That meant weighing the consequences of a disruption alongside workers’ rights. The minister directed the Canada Industrial Relations Board to send the dispute to arbitration under section 107 of the Canada Labour Code.4 As she has explained, the purpose was to help resolve the dispute and protect Canadians. Intervening in a labour dispute is a serious and exceptional step. Our preference was, and remains, an agreement reached by the parties at the table. The concerns flight attendants raised about their own working conditions also deserve action. I have said in this House that nobody should work for free in this country. Flight attendants do important work to keep passengers safe. Reasoning · 9 wordsThey deserve to be paid fairly for that work. Claims · 40 wordsWhen allegations of unpaid work were raised, the government launched an investigation into pay practices in the airline sector.5 We have been working with airlines and unions to examine compliance with the Canada Labour Code. Employers must meet their obligations. Reasoning · 3 wordsWorkers deserve certainty. Claims · 98 wordsWe also want to give workers and employers a better chance of resolving difficult disputes themselves. That is why Bill C-39 proposes earlier support for bargaining and clearer requirements before section 107 can be used.6 A special mediator would work intensively with the parties. If they could not reach an agreement, a public report would help Canadians understand the outstanding issues and prospects for settlement. A national impact assessment would examine the consequences of a disruption beyond the bargaining table. These changes would make the process more transparent and give the parties further opportunities to reach a deal. Reasoning · 34 wordsIntervention must always remain a last resort. Bringing people together takes work. It means listening to workers, expecting employers to do their part, and taking seriously the consequences for Canadians when talks break down. Promise · 8 wordsThe government will continue to do that work.Vague promise Reasoning · 16 wordsWorkers deserve fair treatment, and Canadians deserve a government that takes their health and safety seriously.Partly on point

Analysed on