“Mr. Speaker, there is a lot I could say about the unpaid work issue, but that is not the core issue here. The core issue here is the integrity of the government. The minister made a written claim. That claim is not supported by any evidence or by any information the minister received. In response to my question tonight, the parliamentary secretary doubled down on and repeated this claim. The claim that the strike impacted organ transport is not a matter of opinion or philosophy. It is a falsifiable, factual claim. That is, it is either objectively true or objectively not, and whether or not it is true is dependent entirely on the evidence. However, the minister made a claim, that factual claim, as we now know from the Order Paper question, the ATIP and other supporting evidence, entirely without information or evidence. How do they defend that?”
Statement grade
A
The average of Signal, Relevance, Respect and Clarity.
Average 92 / 100
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Claims 62%Reasoning 38%
This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.
Mr. Speaker, Claims · 48 wordsthe member opposite keeps repeating his allegation.The minister told the committee that she was briefed on risks to critical medical supplies.1She has explained why she took those concerns seriously.Canadians depend on essential medicines, medical supplies and organs moving across this country and across our borders.Reasoning · 11 wordsTheir needs do not stop because there is a labour dispute.Claims · 13 wordsAfter months of negotiations, the parties at the time were at an impasse.2Reasoning · 16 wordsThe minister had a responsibility to work toward a resolution and consider the consequences for Canadians.Claims · 13 wordsThat is why she referred the dispute to the Canada Industrial Relations Board.3Reasoning · 8 wordsNobody should be expected to work for free.Claims · 11 wordsWe acted on allegations of unpaid work in the airline sector, 4Vague promiseReasoning · 6 wordsand employers must meet their obligations.Off pointClaims · 6 wordsThe member is entitled to disagree, Reasoning · 14 wordsbut the responsibility to protect Canadians does not disappear because a decision is difficult.