Analysis · Debate reply · beta

Leslie Church

155 words · 9 sentences · 11 clauses

Replying to Heather McPherson (NDP)
“Mr. Speaker, I certainly think the member’s government is also interested in protecting the Toronto waterfront because we keep hearing from the Toronto MPs that they have some interest in this, but then the government does not listen to Canadians, as usual. Members should listen as $7.3 billion of rent has been paid to the federal government by airports under the existing model, money that Canadians have earned, which the government has with the asset it has. The member talks about the fact that Canadians will still own the land, but when the government has given away the running of those airports for 50 years to potentially foreign investors, what difference does it make if the land is still there because the profits have been given away? The rights have been given away. There are 435,800 jobs in this sector and all of those jobs are at risk. This is shocking. It is a joke to have them talk about this as if this will be better for Canadians.”
Statement grade
B
Average 76 / 100
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Claims 60%Positioning 20%Promise 17%Reasoning 3%

This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.

Mr. Speaker, Claims · 23 wordsonce again, I stand up in this House to share directly what I have heard from residents in my community about our airports. Positioning · 31 wordsI share the determination to protect our city and our waterfront, while ensuring we have the transportation infrastructure and the public transit, in particular, in place to meet our city’s needs.Positioning Claims · 11 wordsOur government is not supporting the proposed expansion at the waterfront.1 Promise · 19 wordsWe will not pursue plans that threaten cherished public spaces, increase noise, cause significant environmental harm or limit housing. Claims · 59 wordsThe immediate focus is approved runway safety work.2Partly on point On the broader airport proposals the member referenced, lands and assets would remain federally owned with rules to protect travellers and workers.3 Part of this proposal is to ensure we have the means to support regional airports, air connections between communities and the infrastructure, 4Vague promiseand transportation that connects people and airports. Reasoning · 4 wordsTorontonians deserve reliable transportation. Promise · 8 wordsThat is what we are going to deliver.Partly on pointVague promise

Analysed on