Analysis · Debate question · beta

Mario Simard

138 words · 6 sentences · 11 clauses

Following a speech by Mark Gerretsen (Liberal)
“Madam Speaker, it is an honour to rise today to speak to budget 2026. I want to use my time today to speak to a local issue, and then perhaps address some of the concerns that I have been hearing in this House from the Conservatives in particular. It is not that often that we get to see local issues or something that is important to our community actually spelled out in a budget document. Members can imagine how happy I was when I saw a really important initiative had been put into budget 2026, and that has to do with the LaSalle Causeway in Kingston. A lot of people do not realize that the Cataraqui River has 29 locks in the Rideau Canal system. The Cataraqui River is the last part of it that flows out into Lake Ontario. These locks go all the way to Ottawa. If people were to travel these 29 locks, approximately 200 kilometres, which I know many people in eastern Ontario do, by boat, they could eventually get from Ottawa into Lake Ontario. At that last little bit, right where the Cataraqui River spills out into Lake Ontario, there is a special bridge there, owned by the federal government. It was built in 1917. It was called the LaSalle Causeway. This was a lift-bridge that was so well designed for the time that the difference in the balancing act of this bridge was such that people could lift it by hand crank. There was only about a 300-pound difference that would actually tip the bridge to allow boats to go under. Over the years, it had work done to revitalize it and keep it up to current standards. One thing that they definitely did not expect when it was being built was that the city would grow the way that it did. When the federal government built this piece of infrastructure, it was a link between the city and a way out of the city, along Highway 2, eventually continuing east throughout Ontario. Over the years, though, the city of Kingston grew into the eastern side of the city. It is obviously restricted; it cannot go south because of the water, and going north is difficult because of Highway 401 and the challenges of bringing infrastructure over or under Highway 401. It had already grown as west as it possibly could towards Napanee and into the Hastings area. The city naturally grew to the east. However, what this meant is that the LaSalle Causeway started to experience volumes that it was never built for. During a routine repair of this bridge about three years ago, the bridge started to collapse. Under what was the right thing to do at the time, the department stepped in and immediately froze any activity on site until they could completely dismantle the bridge. The government then had to install a temporary bridge. This temporary bridge was incredibly important as about 5,000 or 6,000 cars a day travel over this bridge. Over the last number of years, the problem is that for people to use the canal system, to take their boats and to come into Lake Ontario, this bridge has to be manually lifted out of place for a day to allow the boats to go through. Whereas that lift would only be a 10- or 15-minute inconvenience for people travelling by vehicles, suddenly it becomes a major inconvenience, because now they have to find another way around and over the Cataraqui River. I was very thrilled to see that the minister responsible for public services committed the necessary funds to rebuild the LaSalle Causeway, so that it can properly reflect the demand that is required today and that the federal government will maintain this important piece of infrastructure. I look forward to a bridge that was not designed for 1917, but that is designed for the current day and for decades to come. I want to thank the government for that very important investment in the Kingston region, again, keeping up a piece of infrastructure that is owned by the federal government. I will shift in the last five minutes or so to talk a little about some of what I hear and, in particular, to respond to the concerns that I hear from Conservatives about the amount of debt that is incurred in this budget. A lot of people in this House and those who might watch the proceedings know that I have no problem trying to address some of those concerns, and I like to try to hit them head-on. One thing that I always hear from the Conservatives is about debt and deficit. They get up time and time again, and they challenge us on that. Who does not ask a lot about how much debt we have? Our economists typically do not ask questions about how much debt a country has. They ask a much more important question, which is how much debt a country has compared to the size of its economy. That is actually the important question. Think about it. If a really small country has a lot of debt, comparatively speaking, that can be extremely problematic. On the other hand, a really big country could have the exact same amount of debt, and it would not be the same kind of challenge. What is really important is the strength of the economy, what the economy can deliver and how it can service that debt. This is why I think we are in an extremely responsible position when we talk about investing in our communities, especially at a time like this. We have the best fiscal position in the G7 when we compare our debt and our projected debt to our economy and the projected growth of our economy. I cannot think of a more important time than when our biggest trading partner has decided to take isolationist approaches to their economy and has reverted to protectionism instead of looking for opportunities. We are not a country that believes that we will prosper through protecting our economy and closing it off to the world. We are a country that agrees, and I hope the vast majority of members in the House agree, that free trade is incredibly important to an economy in order to be prosperous. I know the Conservatives agree. They are the ones who really championed free trade back in the 1980s, and good for them for that. Free trade is just collectively saying that we are really good at this, and another country is really good at something else, so when we put our resources together, we end up being better off. The sum is bigger than the two individual parts. This is why, when we have the fiscal power and the situation we are experiencing with our southern neighbours right now, I cannot imagine a more important time to be investing in our country. There is another really important question, because I do not want to suggest that all debt is good. What it comes down to is what we are spending our money on. Are we spending our money on only giving tax breaks to the rich, hoping that trickles down, which was the Ronald Reagan approach in the 1980s, Reaganomics, or are we spending our money by actually investing? We realize that if we want to trade more with Europe and Asia, that means we need to rely more on port development as opposed to road infrastructure and transportation through trucks and other forms of moving and trading with the United States. That is the most important thing. When members look at this budget and look at how we are investing and what we are investing in, they will see that we are investing in making sure that we can build a resilient, strong economy for tomorrow. When we do that, we will actually improve lives for generations to come. I take the question and concern seriously, but I also know that Conservatives understand and know this. They know that in a growing economy, we can spend more because we have projected growth, which is going to pay for our spending and investing. I know that they know that, because 16 of the last 19 budgets introduced by Conservatives in this very House of Commons, by Brian Mulroney and Stephen Harper, ran deficits, so they know that this is how we do it. They know that every G7 economy does this. I hope that they will come around, see the value in this budget and vote in favour of it.”
Statement grade
A
Average 91 / 100
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Procedure 30%Claims 16%The question 47%The ask 7%

This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.

Madam Speaker, Procedure · 42 wordsearlier, in response to a question from my colleague from Winnipeg North, my colleague from Kingston and the Islands said that, given the trade conflict with the Americans, we need to further develop our infrastructure.1 Here is what I do not understand: ProcedureClaims · 22 wordsCanadian oil is not subject to tariffs, 2yet the government is investing $40 billion, 3and likely more, in the Pacific link pipeline. The question · 65 wordsWhere does most of that oil go? It goes to the United States. Fully 91% of our exports go to the United States, 4and the major oil companies are largely American-owned, so I do not understand why the government is investing in infrastructure that will benefit Americans, bolster their energy security and increase trade with them in a product that is not subject to tariffs. The ask · 9 wordsPerhaps my colleague can explain the logic behind that.

Analysed on