Following a speech by Clifford Small (Conservative)
“Madam Speaker, it is an honour and a privilege to stand here today to speak on behalf of the people of Coast of Bays—Central—Notre Dame and the people of Newfoundland and Labrador. This budget is going to have a $62-billion deficit and new spending of $151.5 billion in the next fiscal year. It is going to add $765 billion of new debt over the next five years for this country, representing $44,000 of extra expenses for each household in this country, but it is no wonder. We just heard the announcement of a $1.2-billion spend on the new oceans protection fund. Industries like fishing, aquaculture, tourism, goods transportation, and oil and gas will be placed under attack. Every industry that depends on the ocean to earn its livelihood will be under attack. It is totally unnecessary. Canada has the most protected oceans in the world. Is the Oceans Act not enough? Who is going to receive all this funding? Will it be the ENGOs that are already working feverishly to shut down our fishing industry, our aquaculture industry and our oil and gas and to severely restrict cruise ships, which many of our coastal communities depend on for tourism? Conservatives have been trying to get Canada’s ocean envoy, the Prime Minister’s wife, Madame Fox Carney, to come to the fisheries committee and to every other relevant standing committee here in Parliament to explain her role with the $1.2-billion fund the Prime Minister just announced to be administered by none other than his wife. Again today, Liberals voted for the fourth time to shut down debate on the motion we put forward to have Ms. Fox Carney appear at the fisheries committee. I do not know what the cover-up is. We cannot even debate the motion. They could have simply voted it down and said she is not coming, but they do not want to talk about it. What is the big deal? We just heard talk of nearly half a billion dollars committed by the Prime Minister to the forests of Brazil, which his very own companies helped to destroy. That money can buy 10 brand new water bombers to protect the forests of Canada. Are the forests of Canada not worth protecting? In spite of all this rampant spending, the Liberals have cut funding to Canada’s military cadet and junior rangers programs. We have been hearing concerns from parents. In fact, one parent who was to bring her child to Ottawa this weekend as a part of his cadet program was in touch with our office today. She told us it was cancelled because the funding is not there. The leaders of the cadet program are extremely disappointed. They care about these youth, and they care about what the cadet program means for our next generation, our younger generation. Nine communities in Coast of Bays—Central—Notre Dame have cadet programs: Bishop’s Falls, Botwood, Gander, Grand Falls-Windsor, Lewisporte, Springdale, Summerford and Triton. The Summerford program supports Twillingate, New World Island and the surrounding areas. The impact is massive. In a cost of living crisis, when parents are struggling to find affordable activities to enrol their kids in, the most affordable program and most meaningful program in Canada that is basically free for parents is being slashed while enrolment is at a record level. Cadet programs have increased their enrolment over the last year, year over year, by 10,000. It is a program that teaches our youth responsibility, respect, discipline and courage. It introduces them to volunteering in an age where volunteerism is dying. That shows the priorities of the Liberal government. The cadet program is so important because cadets are 10 times more likely to serve in the armed forces than non-cadets are. It is nearly 100% guaranteed that they are going to get through boot camp, their basic training. Of all the new entrants into the armed forces, the ones the Liberals bragged about last year, nearly 90% of them failed out of basic training, and they had to bump them up. Our cadets want to serve, and they will do well in training. At a time when the Liberals have promised 5% of Canada’s GDP to the military, they are cutting the legs out from underneath the very basis, the foundation, that brings people into our military to serve and protect our country. It is very disheartening that there is all this spending but a program like the cadets is being axed when its enrolment is at an all-time high. During a cost of living crisis, a valuable program for parents and families is being pulled out from under their feet. It is just not good enough. Everyone knows we are in a cost of living crisis. It is caused by a few things, mostly by fiscal mismanagement and a Prime Minister who came with a big promise a year and a half ago but has not delivered. Our Canadian dollar is less than or equal to where it was when he was elected. If he is a fiscal guru who is running our economy but our dollar is in the toilet, and everything we import, even gas at the pumps, is costing about 80¢ or 90¢ a litre more than it should because of the weak Canadian dollar, then the government needs to do better. We need Canada to prosper. We have the third-highest amount of natural resources in the world. We should not have deficits. We should be giving out cheques to everybody. Education should be free here. However, the government squashed it. We have a revenue problem and an even more terrible spending problem. It is not good enough, and I will not support this budget.”
Statement grade
A+
The average of Signal, Relevance, Respect and Clarity.
Average 97 / 100
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.
Madam Speaker, Procedure · 11 wordsI would like to come back to a rather important point.ProcedureClaims · 78 wordsMy colleague mentioned the scope of the cuts to health transfers, which will now be set at 3% over the next few years.1In practical terms, this means a budget cut of about $14 billion for Quebec, when we know that health care is a priority for people and that there are major problems with the health care system, including issues with our hospitals and services.2That is $14 billion that Quebec will not have to work with.Reasoning · 6 wordsThe government should be increasing transfers, Claims · 8 wordsbut instead it is doing the exact opposite.The question · 34 wordsI would like to hear my colleague’s thoughts on that.In his opinion, should we be concerned about the fact that the federal government is creating a $14-billion hole for Quebec in health care?3