Analysis · Debate reply · beta

Kevin Lamoureux

206 words · 7 sentences · 10 clauses

Replying to Luc Thériault (Bloc Québécois)
“Madam Speaker, when it comes to this budget, the elephant in the room is health care transfers. Health care transfers are transfers of structural funding that provide predictability to Quebec and the provinces and give them the flexibility to rebuild their health care systems. In the wake of the pandemic, the government was set to contribute 18¢ per dollar, when it used to be a 50-50 split at one point, when the health insurance deal was struck. The government has restored the balance somewhat by injecting some new funds, but it has allocated only $46 billion over 10 years, even though the provinces were asking for $280 billion in new funding. Does my colleague think it is normal that, in addition to not having allocated that money, the Liberals decided to reduce the escalator from 6% to 3%, even though system costs are between 5% and 6%? That means the provinces will be out billions of dollars for taking care of their—”
Statement grade
C+
67 / 100, held down by Signal
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Positioning 46%Claims 44%Procedure 5%Aside 5%

This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.

Madam Speaker, Positioning · 18 wordsfirst of all, I do not necessarily concur with the numbers the member just put on the record.Positioning Claims · 17 wordsI can say with respect to health care that yes, we are continuing our health transfer payments. Procedure · 10 wordsI will use the example of the province of Manitoba.Procedure Claims · 74 wordsIn Manitoba, the day after the budget, the Prime Minister was at the table at an announcement with the premier, the mayor of the city of Winnipeg and indigenous leaders, 1where we made a commitment of $200 million dealing with health care, addictions, mental health and the issue of homelessness.2 The premier himself said that he was going to use that $200 million in order to build a hospital to deal with that issue.3 Aside · 10 wordsI am not too sure exactly what hospital that is, AsideOff pointPositioning · 77 wordsbut the member tried to give the impression that the federal government is cutting back on health, when we see announcements of that nature and the Prime Minister saying that he wants to work collaboratively with other jurisdictions dealing with homelessness and dealing with the issues of addiction.4 Nothing could be further from the truth than what the member just put on the record, because this is a government that is committed to health care in Canada.PositioningVague promise

Analysed on