Analysis · Debate question · beta

Kevin Lamoureux

108 words · 5 sentences · 8 clauses

Following a speech by Sukhman Gill (Conservative)
“Madam Speaker, it is always an honour to rise on behalf of the good people of Abbotsford—South Langley. Today, we are talking about one of the most important topics. It is the federal budget that the government is presenting for Canadians. The Prime Minister promised to spend less. Instead, he has ended up spending more on consultants, borrowing more money and making life more expensive for Canadians. His budget should be called “Masters of debt”. The first priority of his budget should have been to save Canadians more money during these hard times, but what did the Prime Minister end up doing? He ended up adding $765 billion to a new debt, a record-smashing sum over the next five years. The Prime Minister will continue to inflate costs, fuel, food and homes. The budget is going to cost the households in Abbotsford—South Langley and nationwide $1.85 billion. Yes, that is billion with a B. This is just the borrowing amount, and it does not include the interest payments on the new debt. In fact, seniors, single moms and small businesses will now have to spend $60 billion each year on interest to bankers and bondholders. Every hard-working family of four in my riding of Abbotsford—South Langley will spend $6,000 a year on interest alone, an amount that rises to $8,100 annually by the year 2030-31. The Liberals are living in a completely different reality from what they are presenting and what they are displaying in front of us. Canadians are forced to cut back at grocery stores, and the Liberals are spending at speeds never seen before. Just last year, they spent over $19 billion on consultants alone, not doctors, not nurses and not hard-working families. They spent $19 billion on consultants. They spent $19 billion on Liberal insiders as well. How much more out of touch can the government possibly be? I want to break this down even further. I want to break it down and highlight how expensive these interest payments truly are. An average family of four in Abbotsford—South Langley, my riding, is spending $1,500 a month on groceries. The amount they will have to pay toward interest in the first year alone is equivalent to a third of their monthly grocery bill. The federal government and the B.C. provincial government signed a deal to expand Roberts Bank terminal two to increase trade and increase container capacity. It is a great plan and a great idea, but if the federal government is looking to increase development, it must also emphasize local infrastructure. We have said this again and again. My colleagues on the Conservative side, including my colleague from Abbotsford, have been advocating this for years now. We have had devastating floods over numerous years, and we have been advocating for our communities to make sure that local infrastructure is up to par. Just this summer, an MOU was signed to create a parallel line alongside the existing energy corridor in the Sumas Prairie region. With investment into our energy sector, it is great news, but without investment into our local infrastructure, our local highways and land development, the new development will leave the local area and the residents vulnerable to floods again. This year marks the five-year anniversary of the tragic floods that happened in the Sumas Valley area. When the floods happened, the residents on the Lower Mainland were told that the floods were due to a once-in-a-century type of storm. In 2025, floods happened again. Thankfully, because the community came together and made sure we were able to pull through in 2021, we had experience, but we are on the verge of another flood. We know winter is around the corner. We know rainfall has started again, and we know we are vulnerable. This is why we advocate to the government. While it allocates new plans for these terminal increases, which are great, we need to make sure our local infrastructure is up to par. This speaks to the larger question of whether or not our local infrastructure will be up to par. The Lower Mainland is gearing up for another season of rain. I have heard from many residents across the Fraser Valley who feel that another flood is bound to happen, not because there is going to be another storm of the century, but rather because local infrastructure has not been maintained. When speaking about the catastrophic flooding in Abbotsford five years ago, poultry farmer Dave Martens told the news, “Any time we hear of rain, there’s always anxiousness.” This is not how our residents should be living. The insecurity Dave and other residents feel increases year after year when the flood prevention mechanisms are not up to par or properly maintained. Energy sector growth is essential and necessary. Development of local infrastructure must be kept up to par so families living around the area do not bear the negative consequences of this growth. However, given the rhetoric and announcements around expansion in B.C., it is not hard to notice the reality on the ground. Just last month, Liberal MPs voted against Bill C-264, which would have repealed the west coast oil tanker ban. Strathcona Resources proposed exporting up to 250,000 barrels of Canadian crude oil daily through Prince Rupert using existing rail infrastructure and a new marine export terminal. The company says it could reach international markets under two years without any government subsidies, which would help Canada diversify energy exports, reduce dependency on the United States and attract private investment. Instead, the tanker ban remains in place, which is limiting our opportunities to bring Canadian oil to the market. The Liberals say they want to make Canada an energy superpower, yet they continue to maintain barriers preventing Canadian energy from reaching these markets. While we are talking about spending money and affordability, it is important to speak about rising food prices as well. The Prime Minister told Canadians to judge him based on the price at the grocery store. If Canadians were to grade the government’s performance, they would definitely give it an F. Food bank usage has hit a record high, with 2.35 million Canadians visiting food banks. It is up 117% since 2019. Archway Abbotsford Food Bank is serving more people than ever before, with a record number of people visiting the food bank. In 2024, the number was only 5,000 people per month. While Canadians are standing in line at the food bank, the Prime Minister fronted a bill of $524,000 for inflight catering. Canadians are told to cut back while the leader of the country is spending luxuriously. Liberals are living in a completely different reality, and it is time to call them out. They are out of touch. Conservatives have been fighting for relief for Canadians, and we will continue to call on the government to eliminate all federal taxes on diesel until at least Canada Day of 2027. The impact of high gas prices goes well beyond the families that are filling up at local gas stations. I think about the farmers, the truckers, the contractors and the small businesses. Fuel is not an option for these Canadians. It is their day-to-day cost of doing business. A trucker cannot deliver goods without diesel, a farmer cannot operate its equipment and machinery without diesel, and a contractor cannot take lumber and tools to a job site on public transit. For millions of Canadians, driving is not a luxury; it is a necessity. It is the way they earn a living, and fuel is built into the cost of living for everything. During a time that Canadians need money in their pockets more than ever, the Liberals have proposed a budget that would increase borrowing and interest costs. The strategy of the Prime Minister went from building at speeds not seen in generations to borrowing at speeds not seen in generations. Canadians deserve real, tangible results. They do not deserve this rhetoric again and again.”
Statement grade
B
79 / 100, held down by Signal
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Claims 31%Positioning 42%Reasoning 14%Procedure 5%The question 8%

This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.

Madam Speaker, Claims · 22 wordsas economies around the world are having to deal with issues like affordability, the government in Canada has been doing just that. Positioning · 3 wordsWe understand affordability, PositioningReasoning · 15 wordsand that is the reason we brought forward numerous policies to support Canadians on affordability. Positioning · 17 wordsWhat surprises me is that the Conservatives like to talk about and criticize the government on affordability, PositioningClaims · 12 wordsbut when we bring forward programs, the Conservative Party votes against them.1 Procedure · 5 wordsIt seems to me that, ProcedurePositioning · 25 wordsif we were to look up the word “hypocrisy”, we might want to give consideration to the collective efforts of the Conservative Party of Canada.Positioning The question · 9 wordsWhy else are you voting against the affordability measures?

Analysed on