Following a speech by Sandra Cobena (Conservative)
“Madam Speaker, before I came to Parliament, I worked in commercial banking for 15 years. When someone came in for a loan, we started with two simple questions: How much money is needed, and how is it going to be repaid? I thought all bankers asked the same questions. Then I read the government’s budget and realized that the Prime Minister is a banker who only asks the first question: How much money is needed? I guess that is the difference between a banker who spends his career printing money and one who does not. The reality is that there is no credible plan to repay the debt in this budget. There is only a plan to borrow more, more in five years than Justin Trudeau’s government borrowed in 10, and that includes during COVID. The Prime Minister will be taking on more debt in five years than all prime ministers before 2015 combined. People think that the cover of the budget shows hydro wires. They are, in fact, wrong. The cover shows mountains, and it is a metaphor for the rolling mountains of debt that our children will inherit. Equally scary is how the government has redefined $136 billion in expenses and relabelled them as investments to trick Canadians into believing that it has magically balanced the budget. The Prime Minister has not, in fact, balanced the budget. He has invented an accounting scheme to make the numbers look better, and then, magically, the operating budget is balanced. Under the original definitions, that same budget remains in deficit for at least five more years. The finance minister was asked this very question in the finance committee, and he responded by saying he is doing this for transparency purposes. These are invented definitions used nowhere else in the world that are applied inconsistently and cannot be independently replicated with public information for transparency, and that was not enough. The government then turned to Crown corporations to hide more debt, $262 billion to be exact. There are hundreds of billions of dollars of debt set out in a single sentence in the budget, billions of dollars with one sentence of information without adequate breakdowns, identifying individual corporations, financing purposes or expected financial returns. As it is Crown corporations taking on debt, Canadians do not see it in the deficit numbers, but the obligation to pay is still there. In the upcoming year, the new debt taken on will be $169 billion. That is nearly $10,000 in additional federal borrowing for every Canadian household in just one year. The government focuses Canadians’ attention on the smaller number, the $62-billion deficit number, not on that $169 billion of debt. Interest costs are the fastest-growing expense and cost more than health care. Interest is more than all the GST collected in this country. Canadians deserve straight answers from their government and real solutions. Canada has a productivity problem. Productivity is what allows businesses to pay higher wages, families to enjoy a better standard of living, and governments to afford the services they depend on. When productivity grows, Canadians can earn more without everything having to cost more. When it stagnates, families work harder but struggle to get ahead. After a decade of economic stagnation, Canadians were promised something different. They were promised a prime minister who would spend less and invest more. Instead, they got a Prime Minister who spends more, borrows more and hides more. The Liberals promised houses built at speeds not seen in generations, a single national economy and fiscal prudence, but we got massive amounts of debt. Canada cannot borrow its way to productivity and it cannot spend its way to prosperity. Quite frankly, governments generally have a horrible track record with predicting markets and making sound investments. Let us think about the $50 billion spent on the EV industry, which has now closed down in many respects. We need an economy that rewards hard work, not a government that hand-picks the winners and losers. With the holidays coming up, a survey just found that 62% of Canadians are worried about their finances. For too many families, that worry starts at the grocery store. Last month, Food Banks Canada reported nearly 2.4 million food bank visits in a single month, and a third of those visits were from children. That requires confronting the real obstacles holding back our economy. Canada has an investment problem. Businesses invest in new equipment, technology and facilities when they have confidence in the future. They need affordable energy, predictable regulations, competitive taxes and access to markets, but after years of uncertainty and rising costs, too many Canadian businesses are choosing not to expand. The government points to its productivity mega deduction, and encouraging businesses to invest in new equipment is a positive step, but a tax deduction is of little use to a business that cannot afford to make the investment in the first place. A business cannot write off a machine it cannot afford to buy or reduce the tax burden on profits that do not exist, not to mention that most funds spent purchasing equipment leave Canada, as most equipment is purchased outside of Canada. The C.D. Howe Institute has warned that the government’s productivity measures are far from sufficient. Why? It is because tax incentives alone cannot overcome the broader barriers preventing businesses from investing in Canada. We need to remove those barriers, not simply offer businesses other government incentives to work around them. Canada has a small business problem. In Newmarket—Aurora, I regularly meet with entrepreneurs who have invested their entire life savings into building their businesses. They create jobs, train our young people and support our communities. They are not asking the government to build their businesses for them. They are asking for the opportunity to succeed, yet the government seems far more interested in foreign companies than addressing the daily challenges faced by small and medium-sized businesses that are at the heart of our economy. At the Canadian Federation of Independent Business, they called this budget “mega disappointing”. They asked the government to lower the federal small business tax rate from 9% to 6%. They asked for meaningful regulatory relief and better access to tariff support. Instead, entrepreneurs continue to face high costs and burdens that make it harder to expand. Small businesses do not need another government announcement. They need room to grow from a small business to a medium business to a large business. What does that look like? It means a barrier-free national economy, so businesses can grow nationally. It means less government intervention in the markets, so they do not become dependent on government handouts. It means access to talent. It means a government that moves fast on export loans, projects, permits and infrastructure. Today, we still have only announcements. We do not measure prosperity by how much the government spends. Canadians measure it by whether their wages are rising, whether their businesses can grow, whether their children can have better opportunities than they did, and whether a young family working hard and doing everything right can afford to build a home and a future. That is the real test of this budget. Canada is a country of extraordinary potential. We have natural resources, talented people, remarkable entrepreneurs and every reason to succeed. What we need is a government that trusts Canadians to build that prosperity, that removes obstacles instead of creating new programs, that rewards investment instead of depending on subsidies, and that measures success by results instead of announcements. Prosperity is not something a government can announce into existence. It is something Canadians create through their hard work, ingenuity and determination. It is time we had a budget that helped them do exactly that.”
Statement grade
A–
The average of Signal, Relevance, Respect and Clarity.
Average 86 / 100
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.
Mr. Speaker, Thanks · 15 wordsI appreciate my colleague’s remarks, and I appreciate her concern for debt and public debt.ThanksPositioning · 7 wordsAs someone who represents many young Canadians, PositioningReasoning · 41 wordsand as someone who worked for a considerable period of time in the Ontario Ministry of Finance, I understand the role that debt plays in constraining or giving opportunities to governments to make the kinds of investments they need to make.The question · 13 wordsI would ask my colleague if she would agree that the debt-to-GDP ratio, Claims · 65 wordswhich measures a government’s ability to carry debt in the context of an economy, is an important measure to consider, and that Canada’s debt-to-GDP ratio across all governments, as exhibited in the IMF’s October 2026 “Fiscal Monitor”, is showing us at 9.3% compared to the next peer country in the G7, Germany, at over 49%, indicating that Canada is actually in a strong fiscal position.1Unearned certainty