Analysis · Debate question · beta

Patrick Bonin

152 words · 10 sentences · 11 clauses

Following a speech by Jason Groleau (Conservative)
“Mr. Speaker, over the past few days, I have spoken with families, workers and business owners in Beauce. I listened to them, and their message is clear: The people of Beauce are very disappointed in this Liberal budget. “Disappointed” is too mild a word, actually. I would say they are fed up with this irresponsible Liberal government. The people of Beauce were expecting relief from the rising cost of living. Small and medium-sized businesses were certainly expecting the U.S. tariff issue to be resolved so they could remain competitive and productive, hold onto their contracts and, above all, keep their workers employed. People wanted the Liberals in Ottawa to be careful with their money. Instead, what the Liberal government has delivered is a generational deficit in excess of $62 billion. In my view and in the view of most Canadians, this is an inflationary Liberal budget that is completely out of control. Our constituents need some breathing room. The rising cost of living is hurting folks in Beauce. Rising rents hurt. Going to the grocery store hurts. Renewing the mortgage hurts. Paying the power bill hurts. Paycheques, unfortunately, are not keeping up with rising prices. I am thinking of young people who work full time and wonder whether they will ever be able to buy a home in their neighbourhood. I am thinking of seniors who keep their thermostats turned down low just to make ends meet. Let us talk about truckers. They also know about the rising costs of transportation and driving. On Tuesday, in Chaudière-Appalaches, the average posted price of diesel was $2.70 a litre. For 500 litres, that amounts to about $1,350. Before the truck even leaves the yard, the price to pay is $1,350. Suspending the federal excise tax on fuel provided a little relief, but the Liberals in Ottawa are going to reapply a two-cents-per-litre increase on February 1, with another four-cents-per-litre increase to follow at the beginning of April. That means an extra $20 every time a truck is filled up. For a company that operates multiple trucks, that makes a huge difference. Costs add up very quickly. The Liberals can leave that tax at zero. We need to give people a bit of a break. Today, we are asking the government to maintain the tax relief on diesel. This is important for our transportation companies, our farmers and our business owners, who need to keep their equipment running and deliver their orders every day. We also need to talk about manufacturing costs in Canada. The Conservatives want to do away with federal industrial carbon pricing. At a time when our manufacturers are struggling to keep their American customers, the Liberals should be trying to give them the means to remain competitive. For our SMEs that export, the most obvious and immediate pressure comes from U.S. tariffs. I have spoken before in the House about Camnor Steel Group, Beauce Atlas and Garaga. What I am hearing from manufacturers is that they are struggling to keep their customers. It took these companies years to build their customer base. When American customers ask for a price, the Canadian company has to lower its profit margins and sometimes even lose money. If the company raises its prices, then it will lose the contract and we will lose jobs. That means lost hours of work here in Canada. The three companies that I mentioned are paying an additional $4 billion a month in taxes. Let us think about it. Who is going to foot the bill? What are the Liberals doing to help them? They are asking businesses to fill out one form, followed by another, then yet another and another. Meanwhile, as they fill out these forms, their cash flow is declining and jobs are being lost across Quebec and Canada. Things are just as dire in the lumber industry. On Tuesday, I raised the issue here of sawmill closures in Quebec, a situation that has led to the loss of more than 500 jobs. When a sawmill closes or scales back its operations, the ripple effects are felt by small-scale loggers, the truck drivers who transport the logs, and the small mills that process them. In our region, these businesses all work together. The Liberal government has completely let the forestry industry down. Instead of helping our local companies, the government would rather give $500 million to other countries to protect tropical rainforests. When a family cannot make ends meet, when its budget is tight, it has to make choices and sacrifices. Honestly, I think we could have passed on this one. I think we have other priorities than giving $500 million for tropical rainforests. Quebec’s sawmills and small lumber processing businesses are being left to fend for themselves. Businesses in the Beauce region watch every dollar they spend, and they rightly expect the same level of discipline whenever the Liberal government signs an agreement. The government needs to examine it and ask whether it will actually benefit Canadians, especially in these very difficult times. The government is sending $500 million for the Amazon rainforest while hard-working Canadians are losing their jobs. That shows a troubling disconnect from reality. Talk about Liberal logic. While the government is spending $500 million on foreign forests, it is slashing funding for the cadets and the Snowbirds, a source of Canadian pride that inspires young Canadians. Our cadets are our future military personnel, yet their budget is being cut. Let us now turn to Telesat, a story that stinks to high heaven. Telesat is headed by Dan Goldberg, a long-time friend of the Prime Minister. In fact, they have been friends for over 20 years. In December, Telesat will have to repay a $2.3-billion debt to its American creditors. What did the Prime Minister do on July 31? He granted Telesat an untendered contract for the same amount, $2.3 billion. The Prime Minister says that he had no hand in the decision. According to reports, on November 13, more than three months after the contract was awarded, he requested a conflict of interest screen for him and his friend at Telesat. The contract was awarded in July. The conflict screen was requested in November. Why are the Prime Minister’s friends always given priority when contracts are awarded, at the expense of other Canadian businesses? What safeguards were in place when Ottawa awarded the contract? The Liberal government has to be transparent and table the relevant documents in Parliament. Canadians have a right to know the truth of the matter. We should expect this same due diligence throughout the budget. This week, the Parliamentary Budget Officer estimated that, without the new tax measures and spending, this year’s deficit would have been $43.8 billion, but the budget projects a deficit of $62.3 billion. That is a difference of $18.5 billion. The Liberals had the opportunity to reduce the deficit, but they chose to use that margin differently by spending money abroad and abandoning Canadian families and Canadian businesses in particular. Then, there is the yearly bill. As my colleague from Lévis—Lotbinière reminded us, according to the budget, the interest on the debt is projected to cost $60.2 billion this year. The revenue from the goods and services tax does not even cover the interest on the debt, which is costing us approximately $165 million a day. Believe it or not, in 2030-31, the annual bill will have reached $85.5 billion, or $25.3 billion more than today. Every time this amount goes up, it places an ever greater burden on future generations. The Conservatives are asking the Liberals to clean up their spending, justify their contracts, demonstrate transparency, and cut any programs that do not produce results or generate revenue. When they promise assistance to a small business, they need to eliminate the layers of unnecessary bureaucracy that prevent the business from receiving that assistance in a timely manner. Instead of hindering businesses, we need to simplify the process for them. I have children, and I want to help them have the same opportunities we had. We have had a good life, a good job, a loving family, and we have lived in our own home. Leaving them with hundreds of billions of dollars in debt is not going to help them. To the people of Beauce who are watching, I want to say that I hear them. They have talked to me about the cost of living, which keeps going up, and about their deep disappointment in the Liberal budget. They work hard to support their families and to help Beauce move forward. They sent me here to defend their interests, their families and their jobs and to make sure they have more money left in their pockets at the end of the month. That is why I am standing up here today and will continue to stand up for Beauce.”
Statement grade
A+
Average 100 / 100
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
The question 16%Claims 84%

This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.

Mr. Speaker, The question · 15 wordsI would like to hear my colleague’s thoughts on one particular aspect of this budget. Claims · 127 wordsOnce again, the government is bringing back its “Canada love pass”, which gives free admission to parks across Canada. However, it is not just available to Canadians. It is also available to all foreign tourists, including people from the United States. No one has to pay anything to visit Canadian parks. The Liberals are spending tens of millions of dollars on this measure. I believe the number is $87 million. Meanwhile, when it comes to protecting parks, the government intends to cuts hundreds of jobs, including jobs at Forillon National Park, at La Mauricie National Park and on the north shore at the Mingan Archipelago National Park Reserve. That money could probably be used to keep those employees on, maintaining good jobs and protecting our national parks. The question · 10 wordsI would like to hear my colleague’s thoughts on that.

Analysed on