Following a speech by Michael Guglielmin (Conservative)
“Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to rise and speak on the budget in the House of Commons today. Before I do, I would like to begin by giving a shout-out. I would first like to recognize the 10th anniversary of the Newman Global Initiative, founded a decade ago by Matthew Newman when he was just nine years old. This grassroots effort has grown from our community in Vaughan—Woodbridge into a dedicated network for young leaders. Over the past 10 years, the initiative has contributed over half a million dollars in community support and more than 5,700 hours of community service. From supporting educational and shelter projects internationally in India, Italy and Peru to local food security and youth programs here in Vaughan—Woodbridge, their work addresses real communities’ needs through direct action. This milestone is a tribute to our student volunteers, sponsors and supporters. I invite my colleagues to join me in congratulating the Newman Global Initiative on 10 years of service. The Liberals have titled this budget “Masters of our destiny”, but Canadians are not sold on this picture painting by the Liberal government. After reviewing the numbers and seeing what is inside this budget, I think the title masters of fiscal illusion might be a little more appropriate. Repeatedly we have heard from the Liberals that they are going to spend less and invest more, yet they committed almost all of their new fiscal room. They claim to balance operations using a definition that excludes $135 billion that would not qualify as capital investment in any internationally recognized accounting standards. Behind the headline, deficits sit at nearly $765 billion in new borrowing over the next five years. Members do not have to take my word for it. The Parliamentary Budget Officer delivered her verdict already earlier this week. She said, “This budget spends more, invests more and borrows more.” Canadians will pay real interest on this fiscal illusion. On Tuesday, the Parliamentary Budget Officer released a damning report on the fiscal track and sustainability of the Liberal budget. The PBO identified over $158 billion in new fiscal room that was largely granted to them due to an increase in oil prices over the recent months as a consequence of the war, which gave the Liberals an opportunity to demonstrate that they were actually prudent fiscal managers of our fiscal position. However, instead, what did they do? They went ahead and spent 96% of that newly found revenue on government programs. This, despite many economists urging the government to be cautious, saying that “those revenue increases should not be expected to continue.” According to the PBO, without the Liberals’ reckless spending measures, this year’s deficit could have fallen to around $43 billion, and in five years, it could have then fallen to $20 billion. They could have actually demonstrated here that we were on some sort of path to deficit recovery, but instead, they chose a path that leaves the deficit at $53 billion five years from now. Oxford economists labelled the Liberals’ budget as a “missed opportunity to lower the deficit and save” the future for the people of this country. This has not come as a surprise to Canadians at this point. We have become so accustomed over the past number of years to successive Liberal governments pushing the absolute limits of the public purse. The last few years have marked the worst fiscal stretch in Canadian history, with seven of the eight highest being the last seven consecutive years. The Liberals keep redefining their own fiscal anchors to fit their illusion to the Canadian taxpayer. Let us take, for example, that the Liberals dropped the declining debt-to-GDP ratio as their fiscal anchor before proceeding to take on historic levels of debt. The obscene federal debt is now projected to rise to $1.6 trillion in five years. Even the International Monetary Fund has recommended that the Liberal government restore its debt-to-GDP ratio as a primary fiscal anchor for Canada, saying that it would “strengthen discipline, transparency, and credibility” for future borrowing and the finances of this country. The PBO added, “Sustainability is commonly assessed by whether the debt-to-GDP ratio is stable or declining over the long term.” Those are her words. The Liberals instead point to their promise of balancing the operating budget, a term we are becoming more and more accustomed to hearing. That promise depends on what it calls “capital investments”. We hear them over and over again say that they are not spending, that they are making capital investments. That is why I use the phrase “fiscal illusion”, because that term, capital investment, and the way they are categorizing all of this really does reveal the real illusion that is at play with the budget. The PBO commented at the finance committee earlier this week that the Liberals list over $135 billion as so-called capital investments that would not qualify as capital investment under internationally recognized standards. If the $135 billion was appropriately treated as operating spending, the operating budget would remain in a deficit every single year for the next five-year forecast, despite the Liberal government’s claiming that it has met its fiscal anchor. That is the problem with the government’s marking its own homework. Its apparent success depends on a definition that it itself has chosen. I challenge the finance minister to table both calculations, so that Canadians can see exactly how much of this claimed balance comes from the government’s own made-up classifications. Canadians also deserve the full picture of federal borrowing. Over five years, the budget projects deficits totalling $289 billion. Its borrowing requirements total $765 billion. That is a gap of $476 billion. Neither of the government’s fiscal anchors places a ceiling on the cash borrowing requirements. When it comes to major projects like the Alto project, I had the transport minister at the finance committee. He seemed to suggest there was no ceiling to how much this project could cost. We hear the PBO say it could reach as high as $260 billion or more. It is a total waste of taxpayer dollars. Parliament should know who receives money, what return is expected and what happens if repayments fall short. Calling something an investment creates an obligation to demonstrate its value to taxpayers. Public debt charges are the fastest-growing expense for the government. This year, debt charges will cost $60.2 billion, reaching $85.5 billion in five years, consuming almost 14¢ of every dollar in federal revenue. If we remember, a previous governor of the Bank of Canada, David Dodge, came up with what is known as the “David Dodge Rule”, saying that governments should keep debt servicing costs below 10% of government revenues as a fiscal benchmark. This year, debt charges already exceed the Canada health transfer, the largest federal transfer to the provinces and territories. Every dollar committed to servicing debt is a dollar unavailable for another priority without additional taxes or even more borrowing. We are noticing a theme here. We see record levels of spending from the COVID era. One could make the case that during a time of crisis we needed elevated spending. None of that spending has been reduced. We see more and more layers added on, debt climbing higher and higher and debt-servicing costs growing even larger. The Prime Minister recently announced a loan of half a billion dollars to a Brazilian-run fund that provides compensation to governments that do not develop their rainforests. Why on earth would the Prime Minister believe that this is a good idea? Every dollar of that is a dollar that could have been used to help our own people, who are facing an ever-increasing need for help from the government. The government cannot demand fiscal discipline from Canadian families while treating scrutiny of its own decisions as a mere inconvenience. Housing is another primary indication of where we can judge the gap between promises and results. With housing starts declining, the government must explain how its plan to massively increase permanent residence will help the young Canadians I hear from every single day, who are struggling to afford homes and find a place to live. The government throws billions of dollars at housing while making the situation worse. Canadians deserve straight answers.”
Statement grade
F
The average of Signal, Relevance, Respect and Clarity is 66. The grade is held to 38, 30 above Relevance.
38 / 100, held down by Relevance
A score under 50 is red. Choose a measurement to see where it lost points and why; choose it again to clear.
Claims 18%The question 44%Positioning 38%
This view breaks the statement into its steps and names what each one does.
Mr. Speaker, Claims · 14 wordsCanadians go to the grocery store and experience shock when they see the bill.The question · 19 wordsIf the government’s policies are making life more expensive, how does handing people another temporary benefit solve the problem?Positioning · 30 wordsAt some point, we have to put out the inflationary arson that is happening today in our economy.We cannot keep handing a homeowner a coupon for a fire extinguisher.PositioningOff pointThe question · 15 wordsI would ask my colleague this: Should we not come up with a better plan?Off point